Thoughts on compression test results?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Sep 23, 2019
Threads
16
Messages
379
Location
New Mexico
I did a compression test today on a new-to-me 1996 FZJ80. Results are not good. I live at about 6,000 feet, so I adjusted the readings accordingly. But cylinder #3 doesn't look good. I put a little oil in it and it came up some, but not to the level of the others.

#1 - 181
#2 - 181
#3 - 84 (108 wet)
#4 - 181
#5 - 175
#6 - 169

So, I might have a valve issue on #3 or something. I have no misfires, and no CEL - the truck seems to run fine. The #5 and #6 being low means maybe the HG? - if I understand correctly, the HG tends to go out there first? The truck cooled down a bit before I tested the last few - I ran up and bought a different compression gauge to cross-check the one that I was using. That could also be why #5 and #6 are low.

There is a little smoke on startup - even when warm. PO said he didn't lose coolant. There is a crack in one of the PCV hoses, and the plug seals have never been changed - so I thought maybe that is where the smoke was coming from.

Coolant level is full currently, but the coolant sort of looks like garbage - looks like they swapped in the green stuff at one point. But it doesn't look great. I see no white/milky residue on the dipstick nor under the oil cap. I will send in a sample for some analysis and see what comes back.

Do you think this is just a valve issue?

Here are the spark plugs - #3 doesn't look that different. (#1 to #6 left to right below)


View attachment 2106743
 
Last edited:
So, I might have a valve issue on #3 or something.
Yes, you do have an issue with cylinder number 3. Most likely causes are a burnt valve or valve seat, bent valve, or even a simple built up deposits on the valve keeping it from closing all the way. Less likely cause would be a bad head gasket. Other then your issue with cylinder number 3 your other compressions look good.
 
Yes, you do have an issue with cylinder number 3. Most likely causes are a burnt valve or valve seat, bent valve, or even a simple built up deposits on the valve keeping it from closing all the way. Less likely cause would be a bad head gasket. Other then your issue with cylinder number 3 your other compressions look good.

Agree. Additionally, the valve seals will need to be replaced anyway, which is the likely cause of the blue smoke at start up. They deteriorate and will allow fairly significant blow by with a corresponding use of oil. At 200k mine was burning a quart about every 800 miles and had significant carbon build up causing pinging. Plan on getting the head rebuilt with all new seals and grommets.

While you are in there, perfect opportunity to replace ALL rubber under the hood. It is old and will let you down if you don't. I would go the extra step and pull the intake plenum all the way off, not just the top. Makes it easier to get to the hoses, PHH, etc. You can wrap the engine harness at this time, replace the fuel filter and even send the fuel injectors out for cleaning.

Before doing this, get the engine steam cleaned and verify where the oil leaks are, or may be. One it is much nicer to work on a clean engine, two, you are in there anyway and this is a great time to get at all the leaks.

As for leaks, replace the dist O ring, front oil pump seal, great time to replace/rebuild the power steering pump, which if it isn't leaking yet, will be right after you put it all back together and all power steering hoses. Also, the power steering reservoir is notorious for leaking, even after replacing it, it does not seem to take long to leak.

Pull the hood for better access and to make your life much easier. You may also think about pulling the engine entirely for this (I did and glad I did it). Found pitting on the block that caused me to get it rebuilt. If you do pull the block, replace the transmission shaft seal too...
 
Thanks for the responses. Starting to plan out an attack here. The PO put me in touch with localish mechanic who specializes in Toyota/Lexus and does a lot of work on Land Cruisers. I contacted him and asked if there is a machine shop around that he trusts to work on these and he said that luckily there is a good one - so that is good.

I had thought about putting a V8 in this rig - but I don't want to take that on right now - engine swaps take a lot of time, and I don't want to turn this into a year or multi-year project where I don't get to use the rig. I do love V8 power, but honestly, I think that the 1FZ seems to do just fine at moving around. So, I have decided to just rebuild this for now so I can get it back on the road ASAP. I am initially thinking of starting the tear down either over Thanksgiving break, or Christmas break (ideally it would be nice to dive into it over Thanksgiving so I can send the head off for cleaning/machining/valve job/whatever needed, and then button it back up over Xmas break - or the weekends before if I have time).

So the next question is just how far do I want to go? From the research I have done so far, it seems debatable whether or not it is worth it to pull the whole engine to do the job. Some say yes, others say no. On one hand, I like the idea of pulling it so that I can replace everything that I can, and also clean up the engine bay/frame area really well. On the other hand, I know how the "while I'm in there" mantra can snowball like mad - leaving you without a rig for a really long time (I did a frame-up resto mod on a 1969 Ford Bronco that included an engine/tranny swap that took 8 years to complete - although the main reason it took so long back then was financial reasons). But still.

The PO had the front and rear main oil seals replaced a few years back, along with the oil pan seals. Currently, I see leaks from the PS pump and reservoir, and the valve cover gasket is leaking. I see zero leaks from the transmission.

Sorry for the long-winded post - just thinking out loud a bit to see what others think.
 
Thanks for the responses. Starting to plan out an attack here. The PO put me in touch with localish mechanic who specializes in Toyota/Lexus and does a lot of work on Land Cruisers. I contacted him and asked if there is a machine shop around that he trusts to work on these and he said that luckily there is a good one - so that is good.

I had thought about putting a V8 in this rig - but I don't want to take that on right now - engine swaps take a lot of time, and I don't want to turn this into a year or multi-year project where I don't get to use the rig. I do love V8 power, but honestly, I think that the 1FZ seems to do just fine at moving around. So, I have decided to just rebuild this for now so I can get it back on the road ASAP. I am initially thinking of starting the tear down either over Thanksgiving break, or Christmas break (ideally it would be nice to dive into it over Thanksgiving so I can send the head off for cleaning/machining/valve job/whatever needed, and then button it back up over Xmas break - or the weekends before if I have time).

So the next question is just how far do I want to go? From the research I have done so far, it seems debatable whether or not it is worth it to pull the whole engine to do the job. Some say yes, others say no. On one hand, I like the idea of pulling it so that I can replace everything that I can, and also clean up the engine bay/frame area really well. On the other hand, I know how the "while I'm in there" mantra can snowball like mad - leaving you without a rig for a really long time (I did a frame-up resto mod on a 1969 Ford Bronco that included an engine/tranny swap that took 8 years to complete - although the main reason it took so long back then was financial reasons). But still.

The PO had the front and rear main oil seals replaced a few years back, along with the oil pan seals. Currently, I see leaks from the PS pump and reservoir, and the valve cover gasket is leaking. I see zero leaks from the transmission.

Sorry for the long-winded post - just thinking out loud a bit to see what others think.

Do you have another vehicle to drive while doing the engine work? if not I'd figure something out so that you don't have to rush or stress out while going through the process.
 
Do you have another vehicle to drive while doing the engine work? if not I'd figure something out so that you don't have to rush or stress out while going through the process.

Definitely - I just purchased this Cruiser as a project. It won't be a rush in terms of I "need" to get back on the road. I will just "want" to get back on the road. :) My DD rig is a 2013 Tundra.
 
After I rebuilt my engine, there was a noticeable increase in power. Getting on the freeway or hitting the grades was not nearly as much work as prior rebuild.

I still think pulling the engine is worth it, especially if you have over 200k miles on it. Yes it is initially a pain but, you will want to replace such things as the engine mounts, perhaps replace/rebuild the starter and steering pump, gain access to the front main crank seal and oil pump seal etc. You should also replace the O rings on the trans and engine oil dipsticks. Fuel filter is a no brainer, PHH and the engine coolant hoses on the firewall are not fun to replace with all that iron in the way nor is the power steering hoses, high or low pressure. If this is the original radiator, I would replace it as well.

When you look at climbing over your fenders and grill for several days, this all becomes significant in the terms of pain and contortion if you plan on replacing these. Why fight all of this? Do it right once and make it as easy on yourself as possible. That is unless you are a twenty something who is skinny, in good shape and have long arms and small hands. For me, with my back issues, and now older eyes, it was a blessing pulling the engine. I would do so again without any hesitation.

As far as cost, time for me has become more important that the money. If you have to keep climbing in and out of the rig to replace things for the next year, and continually dissasemble parts to get there, it will cost you a lot of time in duplicating your efforts. Bite the bullet, do it once, and enjoy the rig and other of life's niceties. The old saying "there is never enough time to do it right but, there is always time to do it again" rings true here. Maximize your time to the greatest extent possible, even if you are not pulling the engine, you have the head and hood off, you wont have this luxury, hopefully, for a very long time. Take advantage of it.

The way I look at it on the parts side and cost, if you buy quality, you will not have to revisit these items for another 15 to 20 years and not ruin weekends for some time to come.
 
After I rebuilt my engine, there was a noticeable increase in power. Getting on the freeway or hitting the grades was not nearly as much work as prior rebuild.

I still think pulling the engine is worth it, especially if you have over 200k miles on it. Yes it is initially a pain but, you will want to replace such things as the engine mounts, perhaps replace/rebuild the starter and steering pump, gain access to the front main crank seal and oil pump seal etc. You should also replace the O rings on the trans and engine oil dipsticks. Fuel filter is a no brainer, PHH and the engine coolant hoses on the firewall are not fun to replace with all that iron in the way nor is the power steering hoses, high or low pressure. If this is the original radiator, I would replace it as well.

When you look at climbing over your fenders and grill for several days, this all becomes significant in the terms of pain and contortion if you plan on replacing these. Why fight all of this? Do it right once and make it as easy on yourself as possible. That is unless you are a twenty something who is skinny, in good shape and have long arms and small hands. For me, with my back issues, and now older eyes, it was a blessing pulling the engine. I would do so again without any hesitation.

As far as cost, time for me has become more important that the money. If you have to keep climbing in and out of the rig to replace things for the next year, and continually dissasemble parts to get there, it will cost you a lot of time in duplicating your efforts. Bite the bullet, do it once, and enjoy the rig and other of life's niceties. The old saying "there is never enough time to do it right but, there is always time to do it again" rings true here. Maximize your time to the greatest extent possible, even if you are not pulling the engine, you have the head and hood off, you wont have this luxury, hopefully, for a very long time. Take advantage of it.

The way I look at it on the parts side and cost, if you buy quality, you will not have to revisit these items for another 15 to 20 years and not ruin weekends for some time to come.

Thanks for the input. I am not a twenty-something any longer (45), but I am in good shape and have long arms (I am 6'8"). However, bending over stuff for long periods of time does bother my back. The more I think about it and read posts like yours and some others, the more I am leaning towards just pulling the whole thing - transmission included. Then I can really get into it.
 

that's a toss up, before you decide to pull the whole engine at a minimum I would pull the head and inspect to see where the actual compression loss is coming from. The numbers did jump a bit when you did the wet test. I would be looking closely at #3 to see what the issue is then proceed to pull the engine if it is a cylinder issue. If it is clear it is a valve issue then rebuild the top end and run it another 100k. Just my honest opinion.

N
 
You could do a leak down test too. It may not tell you anything you don't already know, but it might help paint a better picture of what's going on before you tear into the motor.

Solid advice given from others here. My head gasket went at cylinder 6 at 296k miles and I'm still in the process of fixing it. I wasn't originally going to pull the motor until I found out the oil and coolant had mixed, but I'm sure glad I did. I have easy access to fix a ton of stuff and it's going to feel really good to establish a solid baseline on this still fairly new to me vehicle that had been somewhat neglected. It's not that hard to just pull the motor, and kind of fun, but definitely still doable to leave the engine in.

Either way, definitely remove the hood!
 
I would agree with pulling the head first. These are very robust engines, examine, determine what was the cause then plan your corrective measure.
 
Back
Top Bottom