Suggestions for 2nd battery

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
May 31, 2010
Threads
694
Messages
2,820
I am getting ready to pick up a 2nd battery for my dual battery set up. I have read all the battery threads so i know all the specs and what not. I am really only running the dual batt for self jumping and winching. No fridge or stuff like that. A few months ago i need to replace my primary batter. I read everything and finally just settled for a DieHard Gold 24F. It was available locally, good warranty, inexpensive (relatively compared to AGM), good specs and drops right in.

Now i am getting a second battery and i am really tempted to just grab a 2nd 24f. I dont really want to spend on the AGM and i dont think i need it. I cant find may good options of the 31 locally.Also I keep looking at all the slightly "bigger" batteries like the group 65 and what not. But the specs are all over the place with only slight improvement over the 24F or sometimes even less. The top quality (non AGM) 24F are pulling 800 CCA and 120 reserve which sounds just fine to me.

So for all the reasons stated above i am probably just going to go to my local Walmart/Home Depo/Sears or whoever and get a premium 24F. I hate to buy Walmart but the specs are good and they are allover the country for Warranty replacement. HD has this one that i am leaning towards.

Extreme 24F Auto Battery-24FX - The Home Depot

I also kind of like the simplicity of using the same battery on both sides. I know it is not really necessary because of how it is wired. But it will be nice to just buy two of the same battery at the same time in the future when i do future PM.

So honestly, any major flaw in my logic? Am i being stupid to do all the dual battery work and then drop in the "little" 24F?
 
IMO, your primary battery is for starting and winching....isolators and solenoids are NOT rated for the draw of your winch under load...been there, tried that...

Secondary battery is for fridges, accessory lights, radios, jump starting, etc.

"generally" it's recommended that both batteries be the same...size and age...for the longest life. I run dual OPTIMA YellowTop batteries and switch them side-to-side with each oil change to help balance their use and life.
 
Thanks for the input. My primary is only a few months old so i feel fine that they will both be "new". Hellroaring does specifically say NOT to run accessories off of the second battery. Run everything off of the main. For now i am going with their recommendation but i do appreciate your input. I THINK they say it is OK to combine them during winching but i am not 100% on that one. But that is all part of the reason i used 2ga cable between the two batt. But i do see lots of different opinions on this issue.
 
"generally" it's recommended that both batteries be the same...size and age...for the longest life. I run dual OPTIMA YellowTop batteries and switch them side-to-side with each oil change to help balance their use and life.

I don't want to argue with the boss, but in a dual battery isolated system, this statement is NOT TRUE. Assuming they are connected only during charging, and isolated when not charging, they don't see each other electrically and one cannot discharge into another.

It's only when they are permanently connected that having them be as close to the same is important. Like in a bank of batteries in an RV.

I ran that Hellroaring system a long time and it's a very good set up and caused no problems or issues. I think @surfpig is still running my old system now. Great choice. I used to force combine mine during winching and never had a problem, but connect your winch to the primary battery.
 
Agreed...permanently/constantly connected (ie: RV), it's REQUIRED to be the same age/size. As I noted, "recommended" the same for longest life in an isolated system. ;)
 
If you want to keep it simple and have a little more capacity you can get the Autocraft Gold 27F. Its quite a bit bigger then the 24F, not much if any difference in price. That's what I'm running for my primary for the last year or two. If you decide you want a deep cycle because you changed your mind and are running accessories then Walmart has the group 29 DC for less than $100. I would also recommend your starting battery runs your winch. The reason being its the first in the series to be recovered by your alternator.
 
IMO, your primary battery is for starting and winching....isolators and solenoids are NOT rated for the draw of your winch under load...been there, tried that...

Secondary battery is for fridges, accessory lights, radios, jump starting, etc.
x2 on this. I know HellRoaring says otherwise but I think it's bad info.
 
I don't want to argue with the boss, but in a dual battery isolated system, this statement is NOT TRUE. Assuming they are connected only during charging, and isolated when not charging, they don't see each other electrically and one cannot discharge into another.

It's only when they are permanently connected that having them be as close to the same is important. Like in a bank of batteries in an RV.

I ran that Hellroaring system a long time and it's a very good set up and caused no problems or issues. I think @surfpig is still running my old system now. Great choice. I used to force combine mine during winching and never had a problem, but connect your winch to the primary battery.

I have the same HellRoaring setup and that's exactly what I've done. No issues.
 
I've run an isolated secondary for many years (not in the Cruiser, but in my main 'wheeling truck, since '98 or so), for the purpose of being able to jump-start the truck when the main is drawn down for some reason. This has served me well (despite some occasional sniping of "...what do you need this for?"). For the most part (except for a few years after '98, when I still believed in the Optima Red Top nonsense...), the two batteries have not been identical. Everything runs off the main including the winch, except the Puma air compressor, mostly because I didn't want to lay out extra wire. But I typically run the engine when I'm airing up, so there's alternator voltage feeding the second battery. I've had good luck with AGM batteries, so I tend to stick to those.

In the FJ40, we installed the wiring for a secondary battery back in 2005; IIRC it was sourced from Painless. Unfortunately, we've never gotten around to the part where we actually would install a secondary battery... :)
 
Last edited:
I have the same HellRoaring setup and that's exactly what I've done. No issues.

Sorry, but are you saying you agree with Hellroaring? Run everything off the main? Personalyt he 100% most important thing is starting. Let my fridge and everyhting else go to hell. As long i can start my rug that us all really care about.
 
This is exactly why i have everything on the main batt. Winch, fridge, ham, cb misc chargers and power points....everything. the aux battery is for jumping and winching only. My theory is that i would hate to run down the aux with the fridge and also inadvertently run down the main using the stereo or leaving lights on too long by mistake. I also have the hellroaring setup and love it. I do combine for winching and have had to jump myself a few times. The aux battery is my get out of jail free card.

I once had a problem where the truck would die at stop signs and lights. It took a few times of this happening for me to figure out what was going on. The main battery had died (it was old) and at idle, there was no juice from the alt to keep things running. I flipped the switch in the cab to combine and drove like that for a week until i could get a replacement. I know this doesnt help the op with battery choice but i do love this setup.

Both of my batteries are very different sizes, ages and construction and i havent had any issues.
 
Oh, and i would rather know that only one battery is taking a beating and not both. The aux sees an easy life , giving me that warm feeling inside knowing that its ready to step up.
 
I'll second the fit of 27F group batteries. Pretty sure that is what these trucks were designed for.. perfect height and width for the available space.
 
So, I'm trying to learn here. From what I've read the AGM batteries handle the discharge/charge cycle better than the standard lead/acid batteries. It seems that for winching and Aux draw that's going to happen with the engine off (lights, fridge, air maybe) that would be the preferred option. It seems that even with the engine running the winch will draw the battery down far enough that you'd want the benefits of AGM.

I've got a set of yellow tops on my "down the road" shopping list. This conversation would steer me instead to the 27f, but even the 24f dual setup sounds adequate, if not ideal.

Like the OP, I don't have a fridge, but I look forward to using a light bar to set up camp and a compressor would be nice to use without sucking exhaust fumes.

So, school me. I don't think it's a hijack.
 
AGM batteries are fine but not magic. In the solar power world, the saying is: "Cost twice as much, last half as long" That is likely hyperbole, but you get the idea. A normal flooded lead acid battery has some advantages too. THe major one is cost. They also are not as picky about charging voltages and currents. On the deep cycle side they typically store more power in the same space. If you overcharge your battery a bit, you can add water to a flooded battery and it will recover. An AGM is sealed and that is not possible.

I've always found I get 4-5 years out of a battery whether flooded or AGM. Since flooded batteries are 1/3 the price, that's what I always use.

The one reason I could see running an AGM battery preferentially, would be if you had a location where you needed to mount the battery on it's side. You can 't do that with a flooded battery.
 
So, I'm trying to learn here. From what I've read the AGM batteries handle the discharge/charge cycle better than the standard lead/acid batteries. It seems that for winching and Aux draw that's going to happen with the engine off (lights, fridge, air maybe) that would be the preferred option. It seems that even with the engine running the winch will draw the battery down far enough that you'd want the benefits of AGM.

I've got a set of yellow tops on my "down the road" shopping list. This conversation would steer me instead to the 27f, but even the 24f dual setup sounds adequate, if not ideal.

Like the OP, I don't have a fridge, but I look forward to using a light bar to set up camp and a compressor would be nice to use without sucking exhaust fumes.

So, school me. I don't think it's a hijack.
Just fyi, the Puma air compressor I use draws a fair amount of current (IIRC some 60 Amps near peak pressure); it slows down significantly when I try to run it off the fully charged 34/78 Yellow top that is now my secondary battery (that's in my K5). I'm not sure it would be very practical to try to air up 35s or 37s off battery only (and detrimental to the electric motor of the Puma); in fact, I see folks using their hand throttle to up rpm and alternator output to prevent voltage drop when the compressor is in use.

One more note: the dual battery setup did get me home from -45 miles away the day the alternator died...
 
I set mine up to run everything off the main battery. Since I've installed the dual setup (thanks again @Cruiserdrew) I have yet to access the backup battery.

:meh:
 
I'm in the "Everything on the main" camp as well. I use a Die Hard Platinum Marine Group 31 as my main and a Toyota True Start as my backup. The True Start batteries are made to start these tucks and have an 84 month warranty. I also recently bought one of those Anti-Gravity batteries for my wife and I've used it 5 times since Christmas on the same charge. I might have gone this way had I known about it prior to installing my setup. Don't get me wrong, it is pretty sweet to self jump with my Blue Sea 7622. the only thing it doesn't have is a monitor for the status of the 2nd battery. Can I assume if it goes bad then it won't combine and then I'll know?
 
I'm opposite from everyone else. My main battery does one thing and one thing only, start the truck. It's the most important battery of the truck and if it dies it sucks. My aux handles 100% of anything else. All aux devices, jumper cables, power distribution, everything comes off the aux battery. If it fails I really don't care. It's been this way for eight years and 200k miles and I have no shortage of goodies and wiring in my truck :p

I really don't think there are wrong answers per se, just different methodologies.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom