Slider comparison

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jul 16, 2006
Threads
36
Messages
87
Does anyone, through experience of having seen both in person, know which slider sticks out further out of Hanna and Slee?
 
I have the Hanna sliders. I think they are stronger and come with a cat skid plate that I have used many times.

But the Hanna's seem to flex or more more than others and if I could do it all over again I would get one that kicks out in the rear. I think that MetalTech make sliders like this.

:cheers:
Sam
 
Last edited:
Interesting info (since I'm actively trying to decide which sliders to buy - or just fab my own).

I like the slee step sliders the most, and have a need for them. I really like the Hannah cat guard, but probably don't need it as I don't do really heavy wheeling (though I did recently break the weld on the cat bracket :frown:). The slee step slider does offer some protection for the cats, just not as much. The Hannah also has the mounting options on the DS void for an air tank or whatever - with protection.

I also really like the metal tech 'kick out' in the rear. But again, I don't do heavy wheeling so I probably have no need. Given that my primary need is to replace the running boards with a similiar purpose (steps for the kiddies) while adding the protection of sliders, it looks like Slee for me, unless I get really confident and decide to really use my Miller Trailblazer (and maybe even open the suitecase feeder and mig gun for the first time :D). That way, I can get the purpose-built step function with insert like the slee step sliders, but add the rear kickout like the metal techs, and add the cat guard and DS guard from Hannah! But I'm lazy and a slow (read bad) welder, so I'll just call Slee. If only there was some other mud vendor in colorodo who would make anything you want, just the way you want it, and not really charge any more for it ;).

Good luck with your choice!
 
If only there was some other mud vendor in colorodo who would make anything you want, just the way you want it, and not really charge any more for it ;).


There is Jim @SROR.com.
SolidRockOffRoad.com He can do all that and then some. And will probably not be any more than other vendors.
 
I LOVE my Slee Step Sliders. I have had them for a couple of years and have POUNDED them, broken Ubolts, etc, and they just keep takin' it. My good friend has a fab shop and was impressed with the attention to detail on the Slee units.

Wifey likes them too :)
 
Personally, I love my MetalTech sliders. I actually waited for these to come into production after seeing the prototype because of the kick-out and the cat gaurd. But mostly it was just how over-built they are! I have dropped off a 3' ledges and landed just on the cat guard and have yet to bend it.
 
I've been running Slee Tube Sliders for a long time, at least 5 years. I can say I've wheel them hard. And they have held up. Last time I checked, my cats were doing fine. Even though a lot of people say that Slee's cat protection is not enough. La Cabra is proof that it is.

I wish my sliders were a little longer, so they would protect the whole area between the wheel wells. My sliders are maybe 3 inches short in the front.
I wish the mounts would have been beefier. That's the part of the sliders that has taken the brunt of the damage. They are pretty bent.
From the pics on his website, looks like he's upgraded them and has addressed this issues.

I really like Metaltech's kickout. If I were to get sliders today it would be between Slee and Metaltech.

Alvaro
 
What about ARB?

I never hear anything about ARB sliders, but I know they make them. Anyone seen these or running them currently?
 
I have Slee, like it, it's good.

I have seen many Hanna sliders. Also good, and possibly my choice between the two.

Solid Rock Off Road is a guy that deserves a look and your business too. Just a regular guy who started his own FAB company. His work looks clean, and will do anything custom you want, like cat protection, kickouts etc.

Metal tech looks OK as well. It's really great having a bunch of good choices.

At this point, I would make my own, just for grins. If you don't have a welder and a ton of time. then choose one of the above.
 
Personally, I love my MetalTech sliders. I actually waited for these to come into production after seeing the prototype because of the kick-out and the cat gaurd. But mostly it was just how over-built they are! I have dropped off a 3' ledges and landed just on the cat guard and have yet to bend it.

would you say that your MetalTech sliders have a "step" in them to get into the cab? Or are they to close to the body to work as one?

barrypt5
 
would you say that your MetalTech sliders have a "step" in them to get into the cab? Or are they to close to the body to work as one?

barrypt5

I have MetalTech. Love them, wife loves them. You can easily use them as a step.... I know i do...bolt up was a snap. Very good design, built to take a beating.

I choose MetalTech mainly because Mark let me drive his truck at the Roundup last year... :-)
 
I've seen most of them in action and if you're looking for something to smash on the rocks (like I am) they'll all do a fine job.

I do have an opinion about "kickouts". I don't like them. I think sliders should "slide", they should allow rocks or whatever to slide down the side of the rig to the wheel.

I figure the wheel can protect itself and in most cases I want the wheel to hit the rock so it can climb it. I usually WANT the wheel to climb and lift the rig and diff rather than just nerf around.

I happened to observe a good lesson which confirmed my theory when watching a heavy wagon climbing Cadillac Hill after Rubithon. For the record, it wasn't MetalTech sliders and it wasn't even an 80 Series. It was a heavy FJ60 and an experienced driver who is a well respected fabricator (hint: it was green and there was a dog in the back).

Picture the heavy rig tipped way over to the passenger, all weight on the down hill side, sliding happily along the slider. Everything was looking OK, the rig was moving and it looked like it would make it. Then the "kickout" hit the rock and immediately stopped all forward momentum.

Remember, the rig was leaning over and riding the downhill slider. In order for the "kickout" to kickout or nerf the rig around the rock it had to push the entire weight of the cruiser up hill, sideways. Not an easy task. All force vectors (wheels) are driving ahead. Somehow, this is suppose to transfer to a 90 degree lateral force?

In fact it was impossible. The experienced driver backed up and tried again and again, but every time the "kickout" stopped forward movement. That is until the last attempt which had VERY much GUSTO, enough to rip the VERY large offending rock out of the ground pulling it into and under the rig.

Some rock stacking ensued which enabled the rig to get it's tires up onto the "new" rock in the trail. You may notice the change next time you approach V-Rock on cadillac.

I'm certain a rig with straight sliders would have went right up. The "kickouts" simply held it up. So I don't like 'em.

I guess if you were on slippery mud, with a level vehicle stance, with trees as obstacles, the kickout might provide some added protection. Otherwise, I think they just hang up and slow you down.

Just my opinion, your mileage may vary...

P.S. I think the "kickout" design originated in the mini truck and 4Runner crowd. They have lighter rigs with much lighter rear ends that may make it easier to nerf the rig laterally. A big heavy wagon is another story.


Cheers!
 
I would add, that if you really wanted a "kickout" you should consider making it full length. In other words, just make the sliders stick out further all the way from the front to the back. This wider style would provide more protection, while leaving your "net" width the same as just a kickout design.
 
Jim,

I have no idea who you might be talking about. But I know the dog is brown, and it's a Vizla. Kinda looks like this:
1100267.jpg

Anyway, point taken about the kickouts. It makes sense what your say.

Alvaro
 
Hey, Gabe knows that dog. That is the steak thief. He's still talking about that. I'm going to have to get him out on another trip so he can eat some fine steak prepared by the gourmet chief Doug.

Jim, I think the angle of the kickout and the pitch of the kickout would determine on whether or not the kickout hangs up. I've had them both ways, with kickouts and with them. Probably the best set of sliders I had for full function were a set of D&C Extreme sliders built for a Scout. They were 2x6 tubing with an angled outside edge and I mounted them so that the whole entire thing kicked out from the beginning to the end. So there was no edge to kick out on and no tube to get hung up on. With that said, I have had the MT sliders on my 80 (mine until Thursday :( ) for as long as anyone and I've never become hung up on them or have they impaired my forward progress. I can see though instances where they could, but it hasn't happened to me yet. I can see this being a problem in a really tight squeeze where you are are on two rocks sliding forward almost like a teeter totter and then you get hung on them. Another thing if we are talking perfect world solutions that is a weakness of all sliders designed with the outside tube is that sometimes the rock or obstacle will get hung up between the main body of the slider and the outer tubing. I have had this happen and it was frustrating.

Back to the Metal Tech sliders. I loved them. I would buy them again in a heartbeat. At first I was concerned my then 3 year old was going to have issues with them. Instead I found that he could wrap his hands around them and pull himself up into the truck with them. My wife uses them as a step. However, I will say this the tube is a tall (but I was 315s and a little over 4" lift) step. Why would I buy them again. Weight, they have enough protection without all the weight. Awesome cat guard. Good design of the mounting points. Easy enough to install. Good hardware. And they worked.
 
hmmm, good point Jim
 
I have the Hanna sliders. I think they are stronger and come with a cat skid plate that I have used many times.

But the Hanna's seem to flex or more more than others and if I could do it all over again I would get one that kicks out in the rear. I think that MetalTech make sliders like this.

:cheers:
Sam

thats the frame flexing on the 80, not the HQ sliders : )
 
Back
Top Bottom