Ring Pinion Contact Pattern Advice

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 22, 2014
Threads
4
Messages
26
Location
OH
Rebuilding the rear differential with Koyo bearings and need some advice...

Pinion Shim is almost nothing... 0.07mm (I've had it up to 1mm with only toe contact)
Pinion preload is at 2.5Nm (spec 1.86-2.55)
If I set the backlash at 0.1mm, I get only toe contact. (spec 0.15-0.2mm)
If I set the backlash at 0.18mm, I get mostly toe contact
If I set the backlash at 0.4mm, I get reasonable accel side contact, but coast is still toe side. (see attached photo)

To answer some questions... I did not take patterns before disassembly as the pinion bearing was broken. So, I figured it was pointless.

The FSM would suggest that I need to move the pinion away from the diff center line. However, I can only remove the paper-thin shim that I have in there. I tried moving the pinion way up but I still had toe contact. Sooooo, my question is does this look reasonable to anyone? I have adjusted this thing all over the place and I don't have many more cards to play! Advice (besides sending to an expert!), please. TIA

IMG_0007.webp
 
It is hard to see the pattern in your picture. You need to hold the flange to put more tension on it while you turn the ring gear to get a better pattern reading.
Getting a good pattern on used gears is tough, especially if they have been run with a failed pinion bearing. I cannot imagine that just changing the pinion bearings would make the pinion depth off more than .001 inch, which would be hard to see. I would keep the original pinion depth shim and adjust the backlash to get the best drive side pattern even if it means running on the loose side.

Are you sure that the pinion bearing is completely seated and that you don't have some dirt hiding under the pinion somewhere?
 
It is hard to see the pattern in your picture. You need to hold the flange to put more tension on it while you turn the ring gear to get a better pattern reading.
Getting a good pattern on used gears is tough, especially if they have been run with a failed pinion bearing. I cannot imagine that just changing the pinion bearings would make the pinion depth off more than .001 inch, which would be hard to see. I would keep the original pinion depth shim and adjust the backlash to get the best drive side pattern even if it means running on the loose side.

Are you sure that the pinion bearing is completely seated and that you don't have some dirt hiding under the pinion somewhere?


Thanks for taking the time to respond. I am positive that there's no dirt under there! I have access to a transmission shop, so I pressed the races in with a hydraulic press. All the parts were washed in a parts cleaner as well. And, I've had the race out a few times to change shims and didn't see anything.

I'll take your advice and return to the original shim, set the backlash to get the best possible pattern (with more force this time). Then, I'll post the final pic tomorrow. I'm ready to get this thing done! Its getting cold in the garage!
 
Take a look at zuk's webpage, he goes thru several, have a feeling you are missing something.

http://www.gearinstalls.com/

With a used gear set, its real hard to setup on the drive side, usually set up the coast, with a wasted pinion bearing you may need another gearset...
 
Ohh make sure you have the race seated all the way, if it were me I would take it back out and check where it seats, you may have nicked the housing driving out the old one not allowing the new one to seat.
 
Ohh make sure you have the race seated all the way, if it were me I would take it back out and check where it seats, you may have nicked the housing driving out the old one not allowing the new one to seat.

Took your advice and removed everything. I did find a couple high spot on the housing from where I pulled the race out. Those are now gone and everything is carefully back together. I am confident that everything is clean, burr free, and set according to FSM. Results are to be posted soon...
 
Thanks everyone for the advice. Based on Pin_Head's advice I reinstalled the original pinion shim. (And removed a burr caused by removing the race...RAYJON advice) Reset the preload back to about 2.5Nm. I then played with the backlash and ran patterns until I got one that might be reasonable, but let's see what the jury says...

This is with 45microns of backlash (FSM says 15-20). If I set it up in spec I only have toe contact. At least with the current setting I have reasonable accel side contact IMO.

I know these patterns are the easiest to see, and I really tried to make them better, but alas, they are what they are.

photo 5.webp


photo 2.webp
 
45 microns = .045 mm, which would be tight.

Are you sure you don't mean .45?

I had the same problem getting a decent pattern after replacing pinion bearings on a used gear set, but I could tell that it couldn't get any better when a thicker or thinner shim made it worse. If you completely remove the shim and it doesn't get better, then that is the best you can do.
 
Loosen up the backlash a little, you are using the specs for a new gear set, try about .010 thou backlash , see where the pattern moves, I would like it more in the center.. pay more attention coast side,

Try putting a rag on the pinion yoke holding it and turning the ring gear with a prybar.. putting more drag on the pinion will give you a cleaner pattern..
 
I ment 10 thousandths backlash, I usually set them up at .008, but with some dana used gears they had worn to .010+ and that was the only way to get a good pattern..

Patience you will get there, the biggest thing once you get the pattern close,

pinion bearing preload.. and carrier preload.. without those being right all your work will be wasted in about 30k miles, done right 200k+ miles...

Good luck, you are alot closer now than before..
 
Had to find a metric and nm to inch pound conversion, I think you are a little off, if you have a sae indicator open your backlash up to .008 and see what the pattern does..

I use the sae specs, 10 inch lbs on the pinion and .007-.008 backlash.. the carrier adjusters I torque to 100 ftlbs, usually gets the preload on the carrier bearing right,

Find one of zuk's builds where he has a hard time and watch how the pattern changes as he adjusts pinion depth, a couple if the 4.88 swaps show this.. its hard to explain but moving the pinion just .003 makes a big difference.. and he does a good job of explaining. There is a reason shops charge 6-8 hrs labor to set one up, it takes time to do it right..

Good luck
 
I'm not seeing much of a contact patch in the photos. Here is a pattern I had on my front this summer:

Final Drive and Coast.webp


You can clearly see contact on the drive and coast surfaces of the gears located near the middle. This is what you should be seeing.

Contact Ken at GearInstalls and he can provide more precise information on what you need to do. He was invaluable with my 3rd member rebuilds.
 
45 microns = .045 mm, which would be tight.

Are you sure you don't mean .45?

I had the same problem getting a decent pattern after replacing pinion bearings on a used gear set, but I could tell that it couldn't get any better when a thicker or thinner shim made it worse. If you completely remove the shim and it doesn't get better, then that is the best you can do.

Realized that as I posted... You're correct. I should have said 450microns or 0.45mm.
 
Loosen up the backlash a little, you are using the specs for a new gear set, try about .010 thou backlash , see where the pattern moves, I would like it more in the center.. pay more attention coast side,

Try putting a rag on the pinion yoke holding it and turning the ring gear with a prybar.. putting more drag on the pinion will give you a cleaner pattern..

OK. I can definitely do that. I can open it up, no problem. I'll repost Monday night.
 
I'm not seeing much of a contact patch in the photos. Here is a pattern I had on my front this summer:

View attachment 958008

You can clearly see contact on the drive and coast surfaces of the gears located near the middle. This is what you should be seeing.

Contact Ken at GearInstalls and he can provide more precise information on what you need to do. He was invaluable with my 3rd member rebuilds.

Thanks for the advice. Believe me, I want to see a pattern like that, badly! I hear you guys telling me to get better pressure on the teeth when I'm running patterns. I did try, but apparently this is not my strength. I'm in no rush, so I'll keep trying. Plus, I'm getting pretty good at tearing this thing down and back together...
 
So, played with increased backlash. Double where I was. And accel side contact is more evenly distributed. But coast side is favoring the heel. And I have to say that I tried really hard to apply good torque for the pattern, but I think its still not meeting expectations!

Backlash at 0.8mm. I went all the way to 1mm, but the contact was not good. What do ya think?

(PS still studying Zuk's vids)

photo 2.webp


photo 4.webp
 
In my view it is clearly worse because the contact is hard on the face of the gear on the coast side. Try .25 mm or .010 inch. It looked better there. It is more important that the contact is centered face to flank as compared to heel to toe.
 
Last edited:
I agree try .010 inch, then take some shim out of the pinion, try a real light coat of compound see if your able to see the pattern better,

usually used stuff is the hardest to setup, if the backlash is in spec (loose side of the spec) and the coast side is centered I would run it and see if it howls.. the drive side has warn into a pattern and since you dont know what it was before there is no way to duplicate it, the coast side is your best bet... you may still have to find another ring and pinion you will know once you run it.. I have a feeling this ring and pinion have alot of wear and that is compounding your problem...
 
OK, so I went back to about 0.012" or 0.30mm, and the contact was too minimal for me on both sides. So, I went to 0.019" or 0.48mm. I really don't like the coast side contact...soooo as RAYJON mentioned, it may be time to tweak pinion depth again. I feel like I can effectively move the accel side pattern by backlash, but coast side isn't really budging. So, I've gotta turn another knob.

And, I am in complete agreement that with the unknown wear on these gears, I've got a challenge! But, I'm gonna press on and try to get them to work. I'd hate it if someone threw me out just cuz I'm old and worn!

480 Accel.webp


480 Coast.webp
 
I'd hate it if someone threw me out just cuz I'm old and worn!.

Thats so true....I'm old and warn and would hate if she threw me out... lol
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom