pulling the block?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Apr 9, 2017
Threads
366
Messages
2,589
Location
tejas
i’ve got high oil consumption. really high.
and i’ve been reading up on some threads related to head gasket jobs on new to me vehicles. and i plan on watching a couple videos 50 or 60 times.
but i don’t understand something. as long as the vehicle is being worked on, you’ve got the hood off and say you pulled the engine to do the work in it and it is on and say it is on an engine stand you bought.
you are sending the head out to be have new valve seats put in right? and it is getting pressure tested for leaks? and also the camshaft bore is checked or something? and it is straightened if needed? and then milled as needed?
what else are you inspecting related to high oil consumption? rings and pistons? cylinder walls? and you need to clean the tips of the pistons anyway, right?
so why not send the block in (or does the whole engine have to go in i guess?) and let the machine shop pull the pistons, clean them and then check the cylinder walls and rings?
or the deal is that most of them don’t need this? or you don’t want to throw the money at it? or the machine shop won’t want to see the whole engine i guess?
anyone able to help me wrap my head around this a bit?
THANKS

44C0D056-C45F-4F53-BFF6-14B4F20AA16E.webp
 
Good gawd man, Breath.
High oil consumption is usually rings, unless it's just leaking (like mine) and then it's seals.
If you are going to pull the engine and send it through a machine shop you might as well have it bored to the next size, new pistons, rings, crank bearings...yadda yadda yadda.
Re-building the head: check your journal clearances- before rebuilding, new valves, dressed seats, valve seals, deck if needed, set clearances at reassembly.

I miss working on motorcycles sometimes, the parts are smaller and you can carry them around.
 
Good gawd man, Breath.
High oil consumption is usually rings, unless it's just leaking (like mine) and then it's seals.
If you are going to pull the engine and send it through a machine shop you might as well have it bored to the next size, new pistons, rings, crank bearings...yadda yadda yadda.
Re-building the head: check your journal clearances- before rebuilding, new valves, dressed seats, valve seals, deck if needed, set clearances at reassembly.

I miss working on motorcycles sometimes, the parts are smaller and you can carry them around.
THANKS. just trying to see if i have a plan.
so would a machine shop need to see the head and the block as separate parts normally? or would you run the whole engine over to them?
i’ve only ever worked on motorcycles so it is a little hard to visualize what i’d be getting myself into. plus as you mention the size is not so convenient.
would you pull the head and camshafts and lock the timing gear in place? then visually inspect the pistons and bores? and run the whole thing over in pieces? or pull the engine and bring it to them? depends on the shop?
from what i was seeing just cleaning the piston tops in place looks like enough of a bitch to just take it all to a shop and have them professionally clean the pistons out of the block. or i guess you are saying to go ahead and just plan to have them rebore with new pistons rings and sleeves?
i mean can i pull the whole engine at once and run it over?
 
Ever rebuild a motorcycle engine? Its the same thing as any inline OHV Jap bike, just bigger. All the same basic parts in similar locations.

I honestly don't know what a shop would want. But I would think the shop that's doing the work would want to tear it down. The tear down itself tells a story, it gives you a feel for what might be wrong. Is it running? Might be better to drive it over and let them take it out too. If you've picked out a shop, ask them.

Cleaning the piston tops doesn't do anything, it doesn't adress why they are all carboned up in the first place. Is it s 2 mile commuter and it never gets warmed up nor over 40 mph....I've seen that mess. Or is it just getting up there in milage and the rings are leaking a little, or the valve guid seals are kaput and it drips oil down onto the pistons when you park it. (Been there on the Camry)

Why are you tearing down? That's an important question.
1) Its at 300Km (186kmi) and Mr T.'s manual tells me that its time for a full rebuild, so that's what I'm gonna do.
2) I want more power, so I'm sending it out for complete machining and rework with port, polish, stroker kit and SC.
3) the Compression is low and I've determined it needs a valve job. (Well if it needs a valve job I'd do that myself as long it doesn't require decking the head. My mill isn't big enough nor flat enough.)
4) The Compression is low and I've determined it needs new rings. Well if it needs new rings, you need to hone the cylinders, if you're going to hone the cylinders you might as well bore them to the next size up and put new pistons, rings, rods and wrist pins in. And while you've got it all apart check your journal clearances and adjust as necessary.
5) The HG's blown, and the "F-it! While I'm in there's" grabs hold and next thing you know...POOF! your wallet is drier than a popcorn fart, the kids collage savings account is dry and there's an LS6 under the hood.
6) I have no idea why, it just seems like something I want to do.
 
Ever rebuild a motorcycle engine? Its the same thing as any inline OHV Jap bike, just bigger. All the same basic parts in similar locations.

I honestly don't know what a shop would want. But I would think the shop that's doing the work would want to tear it down. The tear down itself tells a story, it gives you a feel for what might be wrong. Is it running? Might be better to drive it over and let them take it out too. If you've picked out a shop, ask them.

Cleaning the piston tops doesn't do anything, it doesn't adress why they are all carboned up in the first place. Is it s 2 mile commuter and it never gets warmed up nor over 40 mph....I've seen that mess. Or is it just getting up there in milage and the rings are leaking a little, or the valve guid seals are kaput and it drips oil down onto the pistons when you park it. (Been there on the Camry)

Why are you tearing down? That's an important question.
1) Its at 300Km (186kmi) and Mr T.'s manual tells me that its time for a full rebuild, so that's what I'm gonna do.
2) I want more power, so I'm sending it out for complete machining and rework with port, polish, stroker kit and SC.
3) the Compression is low and I've determined it needs a valve job. (Well if it needs a valve job I'd do that myself as long it doesn't require decking the head. My mill isn't big enough nor flat enough.)
4) The Compression is low and I've determined it needs new rings. Well if it needs new rings, you need to hone the cylinders, if you're going to hone the cylinders you might as well bore them to the next size up and put new pistons, rings, rods and wrist pins in. And while you've got it all apart check your journal clearances and adjust as necessary.
5) The HG's blown, and the "F-it! While I'm in there's" grabs hold and next thing you know...POOF! your wallet is drier than a popcorn fart, the kids collage savings account is dry and there's an LS6 under the hood.
6) I have no idea why, it just seems like something I want to do.

<edit: vehicle has 225K>
THANKS for the help. i’ve done an old bmw top end. never disassembled the conrods or pulled the crank or camshaft or anything.
it’s burning 2 qt/1000 miles.
so if i go in to do valve seals it seems like i would be cleaning the piston tops which looks like a bitch to do in place. so i am thinking i would pull it and do it all on an engine stand.
i have the name of the local machine shop who does all the good work around here. the local LC shop needs $3K + to do head gasket and basically caution me about bribing it in if i don’t want to spend more.
so if i am going in i am wondering if i should just pull the motor. machine shop work will be half of what i would pay a shop so if they wanted $400 - $500 to do the head i am thinking i could do the whole deal for a grand and work on everything else in there while it is out. then i would “just” have to put it back in. but i haven’t done any of it before.
THANKS
 
Last edited:
Mine's leaking 2qts per 1200. I figure I can buy a lot of oil for the PITA factor of dropping the trans and fixing the rear seal.
 
Mine's leaking 2qts per 1200. I figure I can buy a lot of oil for the PITA factor of dropping the trans and fixing the rear seal.
OK. THANK YOU. i’m learning here so i really appreciate the help. not sure i had intended on learning this much but whatever.
anyway, mine does not seem to be leaking. and from what i can gather it is 50/50 (or maybe just unlikely?) i will solve it by just doing the valve seals and cleaning the baffles.
but in thinking about it i guess i /could/ just go in and do sparks plug tube seals and clean the baffle and send the head off for machining (and do injectors etcetera etcetera) and see if that does it.
i just kind of hate to open it up and roll the dice if i am going to close it back up without doing the full monty i guess.
the other issue i have is i am told if it is burning that much you are clogging your catalytic converters and your o2 sensor?
 
thanks to @retrofive for the link

it reminds me i have another question. PCV valve was changed.

spark plug tube seals can leak oil in some way when they get hard? what are valve seals and how do they leak? are they bronze or some kind of metal? also a clogged baffle can cause high consumption.

ALSO is there a way to know if you get high consumption on starting every day and driving a couple miles and then turning it off and then coming back - 5 miles total with some around town driving - to take it out on the highway and do a full 200 mile trip to see how you do on the highway? i mean would that help diagnostically in any way.
 
thanks to @retrofive for the link

it reminds me i have another question. PCV valve was changed.

spark plug tube seals can leak oil in some way when they get hard? what are valve seals and how do they leak? are they bronze or some kind of metal? also a clogged baffle can cause high consumption.

ALSO is there a way to know if you get high consumption on starting every day and driving a couple miles and then turning it off and then coming back - 5 miles total with some around town driving - to take it out on the highway and do a full 200 mile trip to see how you do on the highway? i mean would that help diagnostically in any way.


OK. here’s valve stem seals: 1fz-fe valve stem seal replacement. <edit: link not working. here’s a pic.>

52AEFFDC-F55A-47A3-B38C-36833FA836E2.webp


18F6E5CF-4C5D-4976-AFD3-790901A6C7A7.webp
 
Last edited:
Look at the leading edge of your rear axle. Or any other forward facing surface under the truck. If things are wet looking, it means your engine is leaking excess rust proofing.

I believe a properly working PCV might even help prevent oil from leaving an engine by keeping a slight vacuum on the crankcase. Take off the filler cap sometime while it's running. It should run a bit worse because you've created a vacuum leak on the crankcase.

What weight and flavor of oil are you running? Is it possible that with the few miles you drive you have coked up the rings?
 
Look at the leading edge of your rear axle. Or any other forward facing surface under the truck. If things are wet looking, it means your engine is leaking excess rust proofing.

I believe a properly working PCV might even help prevent oil from leaving an engine by keeping a slight vacuum on the crankcase. Take off the filler cap sometime while it's running. It should run a bit worse because you've created a vacuum leak on the crankcase.

What weight and flavor of oil are you running? Is it possible that with the few miles you drive you have coked up the rings?

thanks for that. i will check tonight and take pics. i cleaned the whole freaking engine bay after i bought it. and i did the area you mentioned about two or three months ago. so now would be a good time to take a look. it was dirty back there and now that you mention it maybe it was oil i was taking off. then again it may not have been cleaned it 25 years i guess....
also, the consumption was like thus when i bought it. i didn’t catch it prepurchase and oddly enough the prior owner i found out of pure detective work didn’t let on there was an issue either.
 
The only place the spark plug tube seals can leak to is the spark plug wells. If you pull a spark plug boot and its oily, the seals are leaking, another tell-tale is if you are getting misfire engine codes.
When you change the valve cover gasket, the spark plug tubes seals are part of the kit.

You're not putting many miles on it, the system isn't getting to full temp, that is exceptionally tough on engines. Do frequent oil changes as the oil will get gasoline saturated. How do your plugs look?
 
Last edited:
What weight oil are you running? I never saw how much oil you are actually burning. Like every else said most of these rigs use or leak oil.
I have have very good success with Marvel mystery oil in every Toyota I have ever had. Marvel will not help your consumption but really smooths things out.
Its cheap and easy to use.

Depending on your area temps, lots of people have had success running 15w40 diesel oil. Its cheap, easy to find, has lots of vitamins and minerals and should slow consumption.
 
The only place the spark plug tube seals can leak to is the spark plug wells. If you pull a spark plug boot and its oily, the seals are leaking, another tell-tale is if you are getting misfire engine codes.
When you change the valve cover gasket, the spark plug tubes seals are part of the kit.

You're not putting many miles on it, the system isn't getting to full temp, that is exceptionally tough on engines. Do frequent oil changes as the oil will get gasoline saturated. How do your plugs look?
hey RM. THANKS. it’s going to be a tad slow going as time allows here. also i need to sit down and read the FSM some morning for most of this stuff and/or ask dumb questions.
so the boot is the red thing that goes from the lead to the top of the plug?
do i pull the air intake and check all of them?
same question for the plugs. i get all the boots off and get a long socket down there? i don’t have to pull the head to check the plugs do i?

10635E92-400D-4E82-86E4-416403566F64.webp


60BC99CC-5CBE-491E-95C6-BCD819E69A53.webp


128B661B-E464-4198-819D-C706F0A1116F.webp


CD1AA31D-BA45-4AD7-9336-B4432BBBF23F.webp
 
What weight oil are you running? I never saw how much oil you are actually burning. Like every else said most of these rigs use or leak oil.
I have have very good success with Marvel mystery oil in every Toyota I have ever had. Marvel will not help your consumption but really smooths things out.
Its cheap and easy to use.

Depending on your area temps, lots of people have had success running 15w40 diesel oil. Its cheap, easy to find, has lots of vitamins and minerals and should slow consumption.
20w50. a quart every 500 miles.
 
High consumption could be rings or valve stem seals. Generally speaking, if it smokes more on start up its valve stem seals.

You could find a reputable engine builder and have them do tear down and assy but most people doing this kind of project strip down to block and head and take both in - as its cheaper.

If theres crosshatch left in the cylinders have a shop hone it, I would not bore it unless I had to. Inspect stock pistons, clean, measure, new rings, measure - assemble.
 
@landcruiser3DP Like you, I am burning about 1 quart every 500 miles or so. I just recently replaced the spark plug tube seals, pcv valve and grommet, even put a new gasket in the oil cap for good measure. I do think that helped some... or at least the crankcase pressure should be more normal-ish.

I ran M1 15W-50 for a while with no noticeable improvement in consumption, and could have swore I was hearing some rod knock with that heavier oil.

I'm now running M1 5W-40 (Truck/SUV Diesel oil) and the engine sounds great (275K on the odom). Not being a snake oil kind of guy, I did add Liqui-Moly Motor Oil Saver and after a few hundred miles it seems I am smoking less and consuming less (no hard data yet, sorry).

All that to say... you "might" be able to see less consumption through a seal-swelling oil additive (if valve stem seals are the main issue), but in the end you're still delaying the inevitable and will eventually need to pull the head for refresh.
 
Back
Top Bottom