pulling the block?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

High consumption could be rings or valve stem seals. Generally speaking, if it smokes more on start up its valve stem seals.

You could find a reputable engine builder and have them do tear down and assy but most people doing this kind of project strip down to block and head and take both in - as its cheaper.

If theres crosshatch left in the cylinders have a shop hone it, I would not bore it unless I had to. Inspect stock pistons, clean, measure, new rings, measure - assemble.

i didn’t quite follow that.

you are saying that i could pull the engine. take off the head and bring it in to the machine shop? and i would inspect the block myself and just clean up the tips of the pistons if things look good? and/or remove it from the rest of the engine and take it in? or is the block and the head basically the whole thing?

guess i got to go see this machine shop guy and weekend if i can wrangle something.
 
@landcruiser3DP Like you, I am burning about 1 quart every 500 miles or so. I just recently replaced the spark plug tube seals, pcv valve and grommet, even put a new gasket in the oil cap for good measure. I do think that helped some... or at least the crankcase pressure should be more normal-ish.

I ran M1 15W-50 for a while with no noticeable improvement in consumption, and could have swore I was hearing some rod knock with that heavier oil.

I'm now running M1 5W-40 (Truck/SUV Diesel oil) and the engine sounds great (275K on the odom). Not being a snake oil kind of guy, I did add Liqui-Moly Motor Oil Saver and after a few hundred miles it seems I am smoking less and consuming less (no hard data yet, sorry).

All that to say... you "might" be able to see less consumption through a seal-swelling oil additive (if valve stem seals are the main issue), but in the end you're still delaying the inevitable and will eventually need to pull the head for refresh.

nice to have some company! lol.
 
@landcruiser3DP Like you, I am burning about 1 quart every 500 miles or so. I just recently replaced the spark plug tube seals, pcv valve and grommet, even put a new gasket in the oil cap for good measure. I do think that helped some... or at least the crankcase pressure should be more normal-ish.

I ran M1 15W-50 for a while with no noticeable improvement in consumption, and could have swore I was hearing some rod knock with that heavier oil.

I'm now running M1 5W-40 (Truck/SUV Diesel oil) and the engine sounds great (275K on the odom). Not being a snake oil kind of guy, I did add Liqui-Moly Motor Oil Saver and after a few hundred miles it seems I am smoking less and consuming less (no hard data yet, sorry).

All that to say... you "might" be able to see less consumption through a seal-swelling oil additive (if valve stem seals are the main issue), but in the end you're still delaying the inevitable and will eventually need to pull the head for refresh.

thanks for the intel here @mdawg. can you help me with the difference between M1 5W50 diesel and 15W40 diesel? i’m not sure i noticed any difference in upping the oil weight to be honest.
someone else mentioned Liquid Moly. you pour it in the oil filler and run it for awhile then change the oil? i also have some sea foam here from working on my motorcycle.
 
Look at the leading edge of your rear axle. Or any other forward facing surface under the truck. If things are wet looking, it means your engine is leaking excess rust proofing.

I believe a properly working PCV might even help prevent oil from leaving an engine by keeping a slight vacuum on the crankcase. Take off the filler cap sometime while it's running. It should run a bit worse because you've created a vacuum leak on the crankcase.

What weight and flavor of oil are you running? Is it possible that with the few miles you drive you have coked up the rings?

hey man.
i just took some pics. i probably cleaned it three months ago. not seeing much. maybe something at the flange there for the bolts at the - is that the sump?
anyway, THANKS for the help. lots of pics here. starting at the back moving forward.

0CC0C7AA-A03C-4993-B2FE-0E8DDE030598.webp


FC390308-0A2A-44D9-B5F0-F7E629AD2C86.webp


C8F09714-8D6B-48CA-AA24-12F574078F05.webp


5B64AA4B-1A27-443D-A8F6-BE7CADEFAC91.webp


33256F85-211A-4560-A009-01F658B71BE8.webp
 
i didn’t quite follow that.

you are saying that i could pull the engine. take off the head and bring it in to the machine shop? and i would inspect the block myself and just clean up the tips of the pistons if things look good? and/or remove it from the rest of the engine and take it in? or is the block and the head basically the whole thing?

guess i got to go see this machine shop guy and weekend if i can wrangle something.


No, what he's saying is: if you take the engine out, break it down into its two basic halves; Head and Block, then take them both to the machine shop. Let the shop do the inspections. You do the grunt work of pulling the engine and taking it apart, let the shop do the specialized work.
You seem quite fixated on the piston faces; cleaning them doesn't address the underlying cause of why they have carbon on them. That comes from oil burning, and where that oil is coming from needs to be addressed. Is it bypassing the rings (the rings are stuck inside their grooves and not scraping the cylinder walls), or is it coming down from the head by leaking past the valve seals. Leaking past the valve seals isn't a big deal, IF and only IF you run it at speed for a good 15-20 miles to burn off the residue. Puttering to work 2.5miles away will make tar and won't burn the oil residue off. Heck, a mile or more down the road on a cold morning and my engine is just up to Over Dive shift temp what's that, something like 126 degrees if I recall.
Its possible you have sticky rings now that we know something of the rigs travels, have you done or had anyone do a "leak down" test? My guess is no, as it takes some specialized equipment not many peeps have it as personal equipment.
Do you have a compression gauge or can you borrow one? There's a quick and dirty test that will tell if you have ring issues. Pull all the plugs and with the engine cold check each cylinder's compression. Then put a squirt or two of oil in each cylinder and run the starter for a couple of engine revs to spread it around. Then recheck the pressure on each cylinder. It will be higher on each cylinder, but it shouldn't be a drastic change, a couple of psi difference if the rings are working normally. if you get a 20psi or more increase you have ring problems. If the pressure is low and you have zero change you have valve problems.

edited to add link: wet compression test, Wet Compression Test Results Explained
 
Last edited:
Your ACIS* isn't working nearly as well as mine!:p

*Automatic Corrosion Inhibiting System...oil leaks
 
No, what he's saying is: if you take the engine out, break it down into its two basic halves; Head and Block, then take them both to the machine shop. Let the shop do the inspections. You do the grunt work of pulling the engine and taking it apart, let the shop do the specialized work.
You seem quite fixated on the piston faces; cleaning them doesn't address the underlying cause of why they have carbon on them. That comes from oil burning, and where that oil is coming from needs to be addressed. Is it bypassing the rings (the rings are stuck inside their grooves and not scraping the cylinder walls), or is it coming down from the head by leaking past the valve seals. Leaking past the valve seals isn't a big deal, IF and only IF you run it at speed for a good 15-20 miles to burn off the residue. Puttering to work 2.5miles away will make tar and won't burn the oil residue off. Heck, a mile or more down the road on a cold morning and my engine is just up to Over Dive shift temp what's that, something like 126 degrees if I recall.
Its possible you have sticky rings now that we know something of the rigs travels, have you done or had anyone do a "leak down" test? My guess is no, as it takes some specialized equipment not many peeps have it as personal equipment.
Do you have a compression gauge or can you borrow one? There's a quick and dirty test that will tell if you have ring issues. Pull all the plugs and with the engine cold check each cylinder's compression. Then put a squirt or two of oil in each cylinder and run the starter for a couple of engine revs to spread it around. Then recheck the pressure on each cylinder. It will be higher on each cylinder, but it shouldn't be a drastic change, a couple of psi difference if the rings are working normally. if you get a 20psi or more increase you have ring problems. If the pressure is low and you have zero change you have valve problems.

edited to add link: wet compression test, Wet Compression Test Results Explained


THANKS. i’m trying to piece it together slowly. i have these but plan to buy the HF version tonight so i can screw it in.

i was only focusing on the piston tops because i was reading a noob HG thread and when i saw the pistons in his rig i realized how much work that was. and since he did it with the engine still in the vehicle i realized i was going to have to pull the engine. so at that point i am thinking i just need to ship it out to the machine shop. so i was/am trying to wrap my head around what that looks like.

compression test is 1. pull all the plugs 2. screw the gauge into one cylinder 3. try to start the vehicle 4 take reading 5. info tester and pour a tablespoon of oil in there 6. redo reading?

to get the block to the shop i am removing conrods (and wrist pins?) and leaving pistons in the block?

was there a bushing in the block that the machine e shop needs to be careful about? someone was saying you need to make sure they don’t use some kind of solvent or other?

THANK YOU

C44C4DD6-E609-4570-83DE-82C3130063CF.webp
 
Your ACIS* isn't working nearly as well as mine!:p

*Automatic Corrosion Inhibiting System...oil leaks

lol. yeah. i have been having a hard time wrapping my head around this.

blackstone /loved/ the oil sample i gave them. no metal no coolant nothing. grade of oil was a little messed up (i guess heavy) but it was not my oil. then i finally realized it was burning this much.

a couple more questions please? is this red thing the spark plug boot? also, how do i pull the plugs? long socket extension?

can i try to free up the rings with liquid moly? or sea foam?

also. compression test tells me if it might be rings? but leak down would tell me if it is valve seals?

are there also valve seats in this engine?

C6F7E95A-E236-4B15-99E6-BE9C71811607.webp
 
Look at the leading edge of your rear axle. Or any other forward facing surface under the truck. If things are wet looking, it means your engine is leaking excess rust proofing.

I believe a properly working PCV might even help prevent oil from leaving an engine by keeping a slight vacuum on the crankcase. Take off the filler cap sometime while it's running. It should run a bit worse because you've created a vacuum leak on the crankcase.

What weight and flavor of oil are you running? Is it possible that with the few miles you drive you have coked up the rings?


hey man. pcv valve is new.
what is the rationale for a new oring on the oil cap? it keeps the engine from sucking in air where it shouldn’t?
and pulling the gas cap will show a rougher idle and if it doesn’t i know air is getting in somewhere?
 
No, what he's saying is: if you take the engine out, break it down into its two basic halves; Head and Block, then take them both to the machine shop. Let the shop do the inspections. You do the grunt work of pulling the engine and taking it apart, let the shop do the specialized work.
You seem quite fixated on the piston faces; cleaning them doesn't address the underlying cause of why they have carbon on them. That comes from oil burning, and where that oil is coming from needs to be addressed. Is it bypassing the rings (the rings are stuck inside their grooves and not scraping the cylinder walls), or is it coming down from the head by leaking past the valve seals. Leaking past the valve seals isn't a big deal, IF and only IF you run it at speed for a good 15-20 miles to burn off the residue. Puttering to work 2.5miles away will make tar and won't burn the oil residue off. Heck, a mile or more down the road on a cold morning and my engine is just up to Over Dive shift temp what's that, something like 126 degrees if I recall.
Its possible you have sticky rings now that we know something of the rigs travels, have you done or had anyone do a "leak down" test? My guess is no, as it takes some specialized equipment not many peeps have it as personal equipment.
Do you have a compression gauge or can you borrow one? There's a quick and dirty test that will tell if you have ring issues. Pull all the plugs and with the engine cold check each cylinder's compression. Then put a squirt or two of oil in each cylinder and run the starter for a couple of engine revs to spread it around. Then recheck the pressure on each cylinder. It will be higher on each cylinder, but it shouldn't be a drastic change, a couple of psi difference if the rings are working normally. if you get a 20psi or more increase you have ring problems. If the pressure is low and you have zero change you have valve problems.

edited to add link: wet compression test, Wet Compression Test Results Explained

i see. leaking valve seals over time with short trips can cause the rings to stick inside the pistons because the oil gets tarry and doesn’t burn off?

and this could happen if it isn’t driven for a period of time as well?

“ Leaking past the valve seals isn't a big deal, IF and only IF you run it at speed for a good 15-20 miles to burn off the residue. Puttering to work 2.5miles away will make tar and won't burn the oil residue off. Heck, a mile or more down the road on a cold morning and my engine is just up to Over Dive shift temp what's that, something like 126 degrees if I recall.
Its possible you have sticky rings now that we know something of the rigs travels, have you done or had anyone do a "leak down" test? ”
 
Its not possible to remove the con rods and leave the pistons behind, unless you were to reinsert them after taking every thing apart... not sure why you would do that. You would pull the main bearing caps, then the crank, then each rod-wrist pin-piston assembly.
Yes the red part is the boot, You pull the plugs with a special cushioned spark plug socket and an extension. the cushion grabs the spark plug and with draws it out with the socket, other wise it will fall out of the socket and you retrieve it with a magnet.
A leak down test is a more sophisticated version of the wet compression test. It looks at it over time and as you are pressurizing the cylinder with shop air you can listen to where the air is leaking from, top end or bottom end. Google it.

If the engine has sticky rings you can attempt to free them by running ATF as engine oil for a 100 or so miles. if that doesn't fix it, its rebuild time.
You can also pour a bottle of Marvel Mystry oil in the tank and a bottle in the engine oil. Run it till you need to refill the tank and change the oil. Its not generally used any more as pouring in the tank is rough on the cats.
I really don't know what to think about Seafoam, my gut tells me its snake oil.
Yes this engine has valve seats.
 
Its not possible to remove the con rods and leave the pistons behind, unless you were to reinsert them after taking every thing apart... not sure why you would do that. You would pull the main bearing caps, then the crank, then each rod-wrist pin-piston assembly.
Yes the red part is the boot, You pull the plugs with a special cushioned spark plug socket and an extension. the cushion grabs the spark plug and with draws it out with the socket, other wise it will fall out of the socket and you retrieve it with a magnet.
A leak down test is a more sophisticated version of the wet compression test. It looks at it over time and as you are pressurizing the cylinder with shop air you can listen to where the air is leaking from, top end or bottom end. Google it.

If the engine has sticky rings you can attempt to free them by running ATF as engine oil for a 100 or so miles. if that doesn't fix it, its rebuild time.
You can also pour a bottle of Marvel Mystry oil in the tank and a bottle in the engine oil. Run it till you need to refill the tank and change the oil. Its not generally used any more as pouring in the tank is rough on the cats.
I really don't know what to think about Seafoam, my gut tells me its snake oil.
Yes this engine has valve seats.


THANK YOU.

so was it still worth it to inspect the plugs? i guess i may as well. seems like it would be a bitch to reinsert them when they are so far down?

sounds like my task is 1. marvel mystery oil in the oil and also on the gas tank 2. compression test with tablespoon of oil 3. new oil cap o ring. 4. test idle by removing oil cap 5. get staged for rebuild.

how’s that sound?
 
Sure, inspect the plugs they will tell you all kinds of info, if you can translate it, Google is your buddy for this.
I'd do the compression test while doing the plug inspection, have them out any way.
Then do the MMO treatment and re-examine the compression. Take that thing out and drive it like you stole it. Work that engine, get it hot and keep it there for an hour or more at a time.
The other stuff won't hurt.

I'm going to bed..night Hotwheels.
 
Sure, inspect the plugs they will tell you all kinds of info, if you can translate it, Google is your buddy for this.
I'd do the compression test while doing the plug inspection, have them out any way.
Then do the MMO treatment and re-examine the compression. Take that thing out and drive it like you stole it. Work that engine, get it hot and keep it there for an hour or more at a time.
The other stuff won't hurt.

I'm going to bed..night Hotwheels.


THANKS A TON DUDE.
 
thanks for the intel here @mdawg. can you help me with the difference between M1 5W50 diesel and 15W40 diesel? i’m not sure i noticed any difference in upping the oil weight to be honest.
someone else mentioned Liquid Moly. you pour it in the oil filler and run it for awhile then change the oil? i also have some sea foam here from working on my motorcycle.

This is the oil I am running now: Mobil 1™ Turbo Diesel Truck 5W-40| Mobil™ Motor Oils. It has a higher zinc content, so it's good for keeping engine internals clean. I think it is considered a "fleet" oil, meaning it has broad usage in both gas and diesel engines. The LiquiMoly Oil Saver is an oil additive that is supposed to rejuvenate and swell seals, it is not an engine flush like SeaFoam.
 
Get a factory oil cap. You have some s***ty aftermarket one. Get right one for your VIN. Surprisingly, it will tell you what harder of oil you should be running also.
 
Back
Top Bottom