Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 vs Cooper SST

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Sep 6, 2014
Threads
22
Messages
211
Location
Medford, OR
Website
www.hunttractor.com
Hello Mudders!! I'm glad to be a part of the community!

I have been building my first FZJ80 for the last few months and now it is time to get tires. I have been back and forth with what tire I want to go with. Actually, more like all over the place! I think I have it narrowed down to the Pro Comp Xtreme MT2's or Cooper SST's. Unless someone can sway me another direction. I'm leaning more towards the Pro Comp.

I have searched the net and this entire site from top to bottom and can't find any feedback on the newer Pro Comp MT2's or much feedback on the SST's. I am looking at getting a complete set of rubber for moderate off road duty and some street duty. Hopefully about 50/50.

I am sitting on Slee 4" coils with 1.5" spacers. I may remove the spacers after it is all said and done, but for now they are staying. I will be buying 35's to go with my build. I will also eventually be regearing to 4.88's. Shooting for sooner rather than later.

I have 35x10.50x16 Swamper Boggers for the hard core mud / trails but I want to get a tire I can leave on the 80 most of the time. I'll be trailering the 80 behind the motorhome to various locations around the country and using it to get me, the wife, and the dog out to remote trail heads or other remote areas. I will be driving asphalt to get to dirt/gravel roads and also taking some trails less traveled so I am looking for a fairy aggressive and durable tire. I don't want to get a tire that has rubber that is too soft and will wear quickly. I will also be driving the 80 on the street on weekends to give it some exercise. :) I'm not interested in an A/T. I also like the narrower tires better than the wider tires.

I really liked the Interco SSR Radials I had on my CJ7, but I'm afraid the tread will wear very quickly with the heavier rig. I have been looking at the Pro Comp Xtreme MT2's and the Cooper SST's. Both have a fairly aggressive tread pattern and have fairly good reviews- although very limited.

I am interested in hearing from anyone / everyone that has experience with these two tires- good or bad. Also interested in other options if someone can give some good real world reasons why another tire would be the way to go. At this point I am still open to suggestions, but I need CONCRETE reasons one tire is better than another. Not just "my buddy likes his ____ tires". Real world comparisons are what I am looking for.

Price is / isn't an issue. I am willing to spend a little money to be happy while in the 80. Obviously I would prefer to spend less on tires so I can spend more on other mods, but a difference between a $300 tire and a $400 tire won't break the bank. I will probably be buying 5 though. I may also be going to 17" wheels for this set of tires. Not sure yet.

The first big trip the 80 will go on will be to Glacier N.P. this July where we will spend 8 days driving all over the park. There will be other excursions into the Southern Oregon mountains in the meantime. I'm not sure where else we will go at this point. We went to Death Valley a year ago in the CJ7 and Moab the year before. We will probably hit Bryce and Zion next year if not sooner. I'm a working stiff so it is hard to get away very often. :(

One other thing that would be helpful would be pictures and real world mounted height measurements. From what I can tell the manufacturers have a hard time giving the actual height. For example: My brand new interco 32x11.50x15 SSR radials mounted on 8"x15" wheels measured at pretty much exactly 32" but interco says they measure 32.5". I would really like a tru 35" tire so I may have to go with a 36 or 37 to get a 35. I also can't seem to find weights for the Coopers or the Pro Comps.

Thank you for reading my long winded post. Your replies will be appreciated.
 
I've driven the MT2's on multiple JK's and they are a very capable tire and well behaved on the road also.
 
I had the cooper SST in the 35x12.5x15 size on my TJ. They performed well on the trail and in snow and mud. There was one huge flaw. They wore out shockingly fast. I think I got less then 20k before they were almost bald. I was very unhappy with that. I also ran the Hankook DynaPro MT on my Titan (35" size) and they wore MUCH better. My all around favorite tire for the trail and pavement was the Goodyear Kevlars I ran on my XJ. They were awesome. Handled fantastic on the trail and pavement and wore very nicely.
Edit: I forgot to add my neighbor has the Pro Comp Xtreme MT's on his YJ (35" in size) and loves them. They have been on his rig for over 5 years and show almost zero wear. Pro Comp often does the "Buy 3 Get 1 free" deal through 4 Wheel Parts. If it was me, I would wait for the twice a year deal and go with the Pro Comps.
 
Last edited:
No sidewall issues in everything from moab to the rubicon.

I'm currently running 35" Atturo Trail Blade M/T tires on my 80. I'm running them because of a recommendation of a friend. They have been performing very well on and off road.

I have taken them to the sandy/rocky steep hills of Tierra Del Sol and just recently did the Easter Jeep Safari in Moab and never had any issues with traction even running close to street pressures.
 
The Goodyear Kevlar MTR's are also on the short list. I didn't mention them in the original post to see if anyone brought them up. Would you go with the Goodyear over the Pro Comps? I know you don't have any experience running the Pro Comps, but based on your experience with the Goodyears and what you have seen with your neighbors rig what would you recommend? What are you planning on installing on your LX470 when it comes time to put on new rubber?
 
Does anyone have an opinion on load range? The Goodyears Kevlar MTR's in a 35 are load range D and the Pro Comps are load range E. I drive an F350 daily and like the feel of the load range E tires on it, but I am not sure how they would feel on a rig 2k lbs lighter. I guess it somewhat depends on the air pressure I run in them. I have the F350 for towing, so I don't plan on towing or hauling heavy loads with the 80.
 
The Goodyear Kevlar MTR's are also on the short list. I didn't mention them in the original post to see if anyone brought them up. Would you go with the Goodyear over the Pro Comps? I know you don't have any experience running the Pro Comps, but based on your experience with the Goodyears and what you have seen with your neighbors rig what would you recommend? What are you planning on installing on your LX470 when it comes time to put on new rubber?

Goodyear Hands down. They were awesome when I ran the Rubicon and the Hammers. Never had one pop or even chunk. They also balance really well and wear slow and evenly. Best offroad tire I have ever ran.
 
Many of us around here are running the Cooper STTs. Great on the trail, good on the street. They are a little softer than some other ties, but that is one of the features that make them good on the trail. Cooper has a $70 rebate on a set of 4 tires thru 4/15. I just bought a set. Really like them.
 
Two things that keep me away from Goodyear MT/R's, how fast they wear and they get noisier as they wear. Not to mention they always seem to be on back order.
 
Two things that keep me away from Goodyear MT/R's, how fast they wear and they get noisier as they wear. Not to mention they always seem to be on back order.
I've had GY MTRs (in 315/75R16) on the K5 from '03 to '14, first the regular ones, and then the Kevlar version. The Kevlars wear faster, but also offer better grip in dry rocky conditions. Never liked the wet traction properties of either version of the MTR. My truck lives in Phoenix year-round, and I seem to start getting sidewall cuts about 3-4 years into the lifetime of the tires. Getting replacements has been somewhat of an issue with the old MTR; with the Kevlars, it had become a real problem - so much so that I don't want to go with GY MTRs anymore now that I need 37s for that truck.
The other reason why I've become leery about GY MTR Kevlars is that my truck sits for 2 months at a time, and the Kevlars appear to flat-spot - resulting in a tire vibe that won't go away, even with heat and/or extended use. I really do like the grip of the Kevlars, though. A lot, in fact.

The Tonto Recreation Alliance guys in Arizona/Phoenix appear to have made Cooper STT in 37/12.5R17 their standard equipment; I've seen those tires work really well, and take a beating without much complaint. I haven't seen a ProComp on the trails out there.
 
Thanks guys for the input. I'm still hoping to hear some more experiences with these tires. I'm headed to the tire shop tomorrow to talk with the owner to see what he has to say. They sell Cooper, Pro Comp, Good Year, and others. I'll report back after we talk.

Has anyone else had the flat spot issue with the GY MTR Kevlars?
 
I have the STT and liked them so much I got my second set last fall. I got a lot more miles on mine than the guy above. They are great in the snow, mud, rocks and not terribly loud on the highway. I get them siped at Discount tire when I buy them. They also have the extra ply in the sidewall.
 
Another vote for the Kevlar's here. Have had three sets of MTR''s, one being the original sort, and have beat them on the Rubicon mercilesslywith zero issues. As for tread life, noise and chunking: Any MT will eventually chunk if you wheel on rocks, any MT will get noisier as it wears (rotate often), most off road tires that are mounted on weekend recreation rigs are dry rotted and ready for replacement as a precautionary measure before the tread wears out. Can't have it all in one tire.
 
Cooper STT max will be my vote and my next set of tires......if mine ever wears out at the current rate.

Great reviews, new technology and compound, good grip in just about any condition without the down side of mud tires. Probably one of the best all around tires right now.
 
The MT/R's usually only exhibit the flat spot issue in really cold weather with low tire pressure.
 
The Tonto Recreation Alliance guys in Arizona/Phoenix appear to have made Cooper STT in 37/12.5R17 their standard equipment; I've seen those tires work really well, and take a beating without much complaint. I haven't seen a ProComp on the trails out there.

Even those of us who started with sled tires have made the switch! :p
 
Cooper STT max will be my vote and my next set of tires......if mine ever wears out at the current rate.

Great reviews, new technology and compound, good grip in just about any condition without the down side of mud tires. Probably one of the best all around tires right now.


Word has it that Cooper is redesigning the STT in the near future. They still have the $70 rebate thru April 15, also
 
Back
Top Bottom