Overfilled front diff?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 15, 2007
Threads
126
Messages
1,134
Location
Los Angeles
Drained and put in new Mobil 1 gear oil in the front/rear diff and transfer case today. Front oil was really really bad. Black, lots of junk in it...slight green color? Thick as sludge. I'll post pics in a little bit after I clean up.

Anyway, did the front diff and transfer case then went for a 10 mile drive to see how it sounded and also to warm the rear diff up since it had been sitting for a while. Got back, drained/filled the rear diff and moved up the front diff to just check the oil level. Pulled the plug out and it just started FLOWING. Not as bad as draining your engine oil, but definitely coming out with authority.

My question is: Is this normal and ok?:confused:

ps- even with all new mobil 1 in the front there was still enough of the old junk in there to make is look black when I pulled the plug and it started flowing out. Will probably repeat next weekend.
 
Ditto; lots of threads, old and current, on that phenomenon; knuckle grease getting sucked into the diff versus leaking in via the axle seal (worn, missing spring, etc). I have stopped using synthetic in my front diff for now, and use a good quality conventional grease, and change it often. It takes quite a bit of either changing the gear oil or flushing to get out all the grease contamination.
 
Ok, cool. I know the dark color and sludge was the grease getting in there, but I didnt know if it should flow out so quickly.

Ran out of time to do the breather tubes.

Thanks guys
 
pics
1) front diff plug
2) metal off the front diff plug
3) metal off the rear diff plug
Front-rear diff & transfer case 002 copy.webp
Front-rear diff & transfer case 011 copy.webp
Front-rear diff & transfer case 012 copy.webp
 
Bpenn;
In the top photo; are those chunks on the magnet? Can you post a larger photo so that it will show up better? Almost looks like a pile of chunks as tall as the plug??
Ditto regarding putting new longer breather lines on the axle and by-passing the stock breather.
 
Was the rig on level ground when you drained/refilled or did you jack it up?

Both times?

Yep. Very very slight slope towards the rear of the truck, but sat exactly the same both times.
 
Bpenn;
In the top photo; are those chunks on the magnet? Can you post a larger photo so that it will show up better? Almost looks like a pile of chunks as tall as the plug??
Ditto regarding putting new longer breather lines on the axle and by-passing the stock breather.

haha, no kidding, I pulled it out and almost cr@pped myself. The chunks and funk is surrounding the magnet, but not built up super tall.
Front-rear diff & transfer case 001 copy.webp
 
Bpenn;
In the top photo; are those chunks on the magnet? Can you post a larger photo so that it will show up better? Almost looks like a pile of chunks as tall as the plug??
Ditto regarding putting new longer breather lines on the axle and by-passing the stock breather.
The drain plugs have big magnets on the end, that is just a coated magnet. I'd say a little chia-pet is normal (during normal intervals or first time changes, not the little 1-4k intervals I do with mine) but I'm not so sure about those big chunks.
 
I think ?Idahodoug showed a Toyota engineer similar chunks, and was told it was normal.
The chunks are a bit big for me to be comfortable, and larger than I have ever found in any of my LC's. At a 90K drain (total 240K on the truck) I found some signifiicant "beard" of filings/dust, and some extremely tiny flakes like the size of those sparkly cookie things, but no chunks. Suggest multiple short drain cycles until your front diff is clean. I used 1 qt solvent based engine flush (as grease is very hard to clean out) with 2 qts gear oil x 10 miles, then drain and fill with gear oil only x 10 miles, then drain again and add the final fill. I'm not recommending that as it is not in any book anywhere, just the solution I came up with for my truck. I now drain my front axle much more frequently than the rear or transfer; they stay clean.
 
Those clunks aren't normal. But that's the deal with used rigs, you just don't know the maintenance history with them. Diff's and birf's were probably neglected items.

Post up pics of your knuckles.
 
I think ?Idahodoug showed a Toyota engineer similar chunks, and was told it was normal.
The chunks are a bit big for me to be comfortable, and larger than I have ever found in any of my LC's. At a 90K drain (total 240K on the truck) I found some signifiicant "beard" of filings/dust, and some extremely tiny flakes like the size of those sparkly cookie things, but no chunks. Suggest multiple short drain cycles until your front diff is clean. I used 1 qt solvent based engine flush (as grease is very hard to clean out) with 2 qts gear oil x 10 miles, then drain and fill with gear oil only x 10 miles, then drain again and add the final fill. I'm not recommending that as it is not in any book anywhere, just the solution I came up with for my truck. I now drain my front axle much more frequently than the rear or transfer; they stay clean.

Those clunks aren't normal. But that's the deal with used rigs, you just don't know the maintenance history with them. Diff's and birf's were probably neglected items.

Post up pics of your knuckles.

Gray, I agree, I am not happy to have found those bits of metal. This is possibly the first time the diff oil has been done since the truck has 93,000 miles. I would like to think they did them, but I have no evidence. On a positive note, the transfer case oil and rear diff looked like a normal slightly dark tea color. See below, but I wont be doing the flush and clean until I get my front axle job complete. This oil change was a temporary bandaid fix just to make sure I wasnt running the front diff dry.

Mkfour, the birfs are leaking, I need a front axle job. Knew this buying the car, so it wasnt a surprise. Passenger side is leaking pretty good, not dripping a lot, but tons of gunk caked on there. Driver side isnt perfect, but much better looking than passenger side.
 
BPenn,

Normal. Every single 80 diff I've been the first changer on has looked like that, some with even bigger chunks along with the normal fuzzy looking finer filings. I took a baggie of them to work one day and showed the LandCruiser engineer back in '93. Declared normal and from the final processing, and that's why the magnets are there. They hit the magnet in the first few hours of operation and never move. Don't worry a bit, and yes it appears this is the first changeout.

DougM
 
Back
Top Bottom