Motor rebuild vs. Replacement

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 7, 2009
Threads
192
Messages
1,549
Location
Pensacola, Fl.
I recently purchased a 96' 80 with blown head gasket. I haven't torn into the bottom end yet to check it's condition. I'm try to decide if it's more cost effective to rebuild or replace? Where would be the best place to purchase a motor? Many Thanks!
 
How many miles are on it? The bottom ends are pretty stout. It's probably more cost effective to just re-do the head, especially if you DIY.
 
Seems like most of the time a new HG and head inspection/repair does the trick with these engines...
 
with only 155k on it, pull the head, clean it up and put a new gasket on it and put it back together and you're good for another 155k. no nead for a rebuild, just have the head resurfaced.
 
What about with 225k. Head is starting t leak and I have a leak coming from the bottom some place maybe? I have priced engines. They have a 88k one around here for $2000, 125-145k for 1k+ and rebuilts the best I have seen are around 5k unless I am missing something. I could pull and swap the motors myself, but not machine any of it and for time wise I would think that engine swaps would be all I could afford time wise to have the truck down. The engine is fine now, but you can tell over the last few weeks is starting to get unhappy haha. Or do I just do the head gasket and if the bottom goes just do that when that happens?
 
any engine going into that truck should have the newer style HG IMO. So take that 2000.00 engine and add the cost of doing the HG.

I'd just fix the one in there.

I bought a truck with a rod knock. Right now I'm just planning on doing the HG and replace the bearing if possible.

There's really no need of getting all kinds of "while I'm in there" crazy with these things.
 
Personally...I have had 2 bad experiences with rebuilt engines in the past, one being a Ford V6 and the other a 22RE which developed a great thirst for oil and a rattling timing chain at around 5k miles. These were bought from what I thought were reputable rebuilders in my area.
I have heard other horror stories about rebuilt engines and how they just aren't the same and don't have the longevity of the one that Mr. T put together.

I guess my advice would be do your research on the rebuilder....do they use only OEM parts in their build ...are they familiar with this particular engine etc...maybe some members on here could suggest a builder that they have had success with....but even then you are taking a slight risk I think.

Personally I would go for the used engine with around 100K on it, especially if you could hear it run in the truck......and a headgasket change on an engine stand would sure be a lot easier!


my $0.02
 
Well, my logic to getting a used engine is this...

I pull and swap the motor. The I have a spare motor to rebuild over time and have a spare motor. I have become a pack rat with parts that I have pulled off that can be rebuilt. It's nice to have spare parts ready to go since I will keep the truck for some time and I am sure they will only get harder to come by. Maybe I am over thinking it, but its fun to rebuild things and it will give me a good how to on rebuilding a engine.
 
Back
Top Bottom