Lets Talk O2 sensors

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Romer

fatherofdaughterofromer
Moderator
Joined
Sep 14, 2003
Threads
560
Messages
11,998
Location
Centennial, Colorado
I replaced both Sarah's O2 sensors last month after pulling a code. I had one replaced on mine 44K miles ago due to a code and should have done both at the time. I decided to replace both on my truck today as my exhaust has been smeeling and gas mileage has gotten a little worse. The smell could also be cats.

So I have 3 O2 sensors at various points in life abd thought it would be worth posting up


Sensor 1 is out of my truck and is either the original from 144K miles or was replaced by the PO. Front Sensor

Sensor 2 is out my truck and replaced 44K miles ago. Rear sensor

Sensor 3 is the one from Sarah's truck that pulled a code with 163K Miles on it. This one was bad. Front sensor
O2 sensors 2 mine.webp
O2 sensors 3 mine.webp
O2 sensors 4 Sarah bad code.webp
 
All three together
O2 sensors 1.webp
 
Actually, Sarah's rear nuts were destroyed. Those are all off mine today.

Thanks for your insight on the obvious. I guess what your really saying is Romer has posted a stupid thread.

I didn't know if you could tell anything about how the truck is running by the look of the sensor. You know like when you look at a spark plug to see if your running lean or not.
 
When I did my exhaust repair last week, it included removing the front O2 sensor ('95 - 2 inline cats). It looked a lot blacker and sootier than any of those, but I re-used it for now as it has never set a code. The soot on it was 'dusty' and it would rub off on my finger even if slightly touching it.

New gasket, 2 new nuts and I put it back on, no MIL since then. I'm pretty sure the rear one looks the same because the tailpipe has the same sooty deposit.

Summarize my thoughts to say that I don't think it matters how it looks.

For the record, there was a lot less left of my nuts. I plan on replacing the O2 sensors and cleaning the injectors at the same time.

Dan.
 
Thanks Dan,
Figured since I had three from different points of life it was worth posting. At least to start some discussion.
 
OK, good pics.....I'm doing mine next week. My mileage is horrible. So the grommet (gasket) actually comes with the 02 sensor...or is that another part number?
airlaird
 
1 and 2 looks pretty similar to me, and both better than 3. What is the recommended replacement mileage? Maybe the PO did replace them? Are you putting either of them back on, or going new?
 
I bought new ones from Cdan.
 
Did mine with OEM Denso units last week as a pm. I was not setting any codes and mine looked similar to your first two pictures. They had a Grayish/white tint. I do not know if I will see any mileage gains as some have claimed here but the idle has definitely smoothed out a bit on my rig since the swap out.
 
Romer,
If the point of the pictures is that you're trying to visually determine if the O2 sensors are bad, it's not going to work. The sensors are electrochemical devices that sense the difference between oxygen content in the atmosphere and in the exhaust. They're built out of platinum and zirconium dioxide and a redox reaction between them creates a voltage potential. (That's all the detail I remember from my college chemistry courses - which were a very long time ago now.)

I don't know for certain what happens when a sensor goes bad, but I suspect either the platinum or zirconium dioxide get contaminated over time and the efficiency of the reaction drops way down. Regardless, you're not going to be able to see any difference between a good used sensor and a bad used sensor.
 
Last edited:
The O2 Sensors work (normally) on a chemical reaction reading the amount of fuel in your exhaust. A "Perfect" (at least for pump gas) Air Fuel ratio (AFR) is 14.7 stoichiometric (14.7 parts Oxygen to fuel). This is what is widely acknowledge as the perfect AR for Power/economy etc. there are different AFR's depending on whether you are burning Kerosese, JP3/4 or Diesel.

The O2 sensor reads what the engine is exhausting and based on the chemical reaction on too much or too little fuel in the exhaust, and it's readtion with the Platinum or other rare metal,.. changes a voltage that causes the ECU to enrich or turn down the fuel...

Sooty (ie; black) O2 Sensors usually mean a too-rich mixture,.. while a whiter/grey color is usually leaning towards too lean. Both usually add up to an improperly reading ECU. This is not that the ECU is bad,.. but that something is giving it erroneous info... it can only work on what it is 'told' by the different sensors... MAF, temp, O2 etc. you can get bad radings if there's corrosion on connectors etc.

You can test an O2 sensor on the truck and on the bench,.. there are voltages and reactions that all O2 sensors will generate and these specs are all over the web. When Bench testing you MUST use a high impedance Voltmeter as a cheaper/lower impedance one will NOT be accurate. If I remember correctly a value (in the voltmeter) of at least 1Meg-ohm/volt on the DC side is acceptable.

Bill
 
I read a post on cleaning these, by heating them up then sticking in water, Have you tried this? I wonder if you would see a difference since you plan to replace anyways.
 
Romer,
If the point of the pictures is that you're trying to visually determine if the O2 sensors are bad, it's not going to work. The sensors are electrochemical devices that sense the difference between oxygen content in the atmosphere and in the exhaust. They're built out of platinum and zirconium dioxide and a redox reaction between them creates a voltage potential. (That's all the detail I remember from my college chemistry courses - which were a very long time ago now.)

.

I know you can't tell a bad one from looking at it. The post below yours was more on target of what I was trying to see. Can you tell anything about the operation of the truck by the color of the soot, etc.


I was trying to post something different instead of "will these tires fit on my truck" threads.
 
I read a post on cleaning these, by heating them up then sticking in water.

Anyone know if this works?

I was trying to post something different instead of "will these tires fit on my truck" threads.

Man am i glad you brought that up! Do you know if I can run 35's on a stock suspension? :D:D:D

Edit: My lockers wont engage either? huh........
 
Last edited:
I can tell they're bad... you have to look very closely at the second picture, but if you do,.. you can see that they're not attached to a truck so,.. no way they're working! :)
 
I am not sure if this is a test, but mine was I think damaged by vibration when at the local exhaust fitters, they used an air chisel which buggered up the sensor, when I removed the sensor and shook it, it sounded like there was broken glass in the unit!

My mpg was crap, but since I got a new one from CDan it has been ok! :-)
 
Back
Top Bottom