Lean in first three cylinders, cause?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 24, 2015
Threads
2
Messages
13
Location
VT
96 Lx450, 190k. Knocking and loss of power under load at low rpm. First three plugs have a crazy amount of white ash build up, other plugs look great. Timing is at 3 degrees, no cel. Good power at mid to high rpms, significant loss of power under load at low rpms.

Question is why ash (lean condition) on only first three plugs? Where to start troubleshooting?

Thanks for any advice you can give.
 
Sounds like a wiring harness failure. Could be down around #3 injector, or all the way up around the EGR tube . wiggle the wires around to see if there is a change in performance?
 
any water on the floor in front lately ? Water dripping on ECU?

On a 2F, this would be a disintegrating distributor.

Front camshaft bearing gone could lead to lobe wear, and poor seal on valves. Would show on a vac test.
 
Most likely 'oil ash' from worn valve guides or valve guide seals. I wouldn't think a lean condition.

A lean condition can certainly produce a 'white' residue on the plugs but normally the engine sound will manifest as a 'ping'. The 'knocking' sound you describe is something you definitely want to look into.
 
Last edited:
Sounds like a wiring harness failure. Could be down around #3 injector, or all the way up around the EGR tube . wiggle the wires around to see if there is a change in performance?
Wiring harness looks and feels sound. Moved it around while running, no change.
 
Most likely 'oil ash' from worn valve guides or valve guide seals. I wouldn't think a lean condition.

A lean condition can certainly produce a 'white' residue on the plugs but normally the engine sound will manifest as a 'ping'. The 'knocking' sound you describe is something you definitely want to look into.
Up here north of the wall we call preignition detonation "knocking". It's definitely detonation noise, as if the timing or mixture were off.
 
any water on the floor in front lately ? Water dripping on ECU?

On a 2F, this would be a disintegrating distributor.

Front camshaft bearing gone could lead to lobe wear, and poor seal on valves. Would show on a vac test.
Replaced valve seals last summer, no more blue smoke on start-up, cut oil consumption drastically. Didn't mic anything, but everything looked and felt good when I put it back together. Vacuum is good, I chased down a leak recently. Distributor and plug wires are two years old, look great.
 
Up here north of the wall we call preignition detonation "knocking". It's definitely detonation noise, as if the timing or mixture were off.

Then advance or retard your timing and see if it makes a difference.

Also, a little more 'history' would be helpful...so we aren't going down rabbit holes you've already addressed (I.E. replaced valve seals, had engine apart, etc).

Are you running any fuel additives?

plug-troubleshooting-guide.webp
 
Then advance or retard your timing and see if it makes a difference.

Also, a little more 'history' would be helpful...so we aren't going down rabbit holes you've already addressed (I.E. replaced valve seals, had engine apart, etc).

Are you running any fuel additives?

View attachment 1716652
I ran some Seafoam through it last month when I first noticed the detonation. No effect. I pulled the distributor cap; looks fine. I checked the timing; 3 degrees on the money. I changed the plugs, which is when I discovered that the first three had a white ash build up. Looks like the "deposits" plug in your illustration. Can oil entering the cylinder cause detonation, or maybe two issues going on? I pulled the intake plenum a couple months ago to clean the EGR ports to fix the EGR CEL. Followed instructions from ih8mud thread. Cleaned everything, put it all back together, no CEL, ran great. The original Cat disintegrated two years ago, my local exhaust shop put in a single large cat. Haven't had any problems with it. I replaced the valve seals without pulling the head using the "rope down the cylinder" trick. The blue smoke I had at start-up is gone.

If I retard the timing below 3 degrees and the detonation goes away, do I just run it like that? Or is that a troubleshooting technique that will help diagnose the issue?

I have run the truck for the last 60K, four years. Has the same fuel filter and O2 sensors I bought it with. Burns a quart of oil a month, a bit more if I spend a bunch of time on the highway, seems in line with my two previous Land Cruisers. My main concern is the loss of power at low RPM under load. Had 800lbs of payload to haul up a steep hill last week and the truck was very unhappy. I'm running 295/75's, but still...it should pull like a tractor and doesn't. I will post pics of the plugs I pulled when I get home this afternoon.

Thanks for your help!
 
If I retard the timing below 3 degrees and the detonation goes away, do I just run it like that? Or is that a troubleshooting technique that will help diagnose the issue?

I wouldn't recommend this, its a band aid method and likely wouldn't work. Even in warm weather and using regular 87 octane fuel I can run 8 degrees initial timing on mine without any knocking so 3 degrees (spec) should not be an issue. Going below 3 will only reduce power and fuel economy.

I'd refocus my efforts on the injector wiring harness, it can be very hard to spot issues without fully opening it up. I had a difficult to diagnose misfire and lack of power at low RPM and after trying everything in the book it ended up being wiring harness damage where is passes by the EGR. From the outside of the wiring loom it was not apparent, only once I opened it up.
 
I wouldn't recommend this, its a band aid method and likely wouldn't work. Even in warm weather and using regular 87 octane fuel I can run 8 degrees initial timing on mine without any knocking so 3 degrees (spec) should not be an issue. Going below 3 will only reduce power and fuel economy.

I'd refocus my efforts on the injector wiring harness, it can be very hard to spot issues without fully opening it up. I had a difficult to diagnose misfire and lack of power at low RPM and after trying everything in the book it ended up being wiring harness damage where is passes by the EGR. From the outside of the wiring loom it was not apparent, only once I opened it up.
I will look more closely. What am I looking for? Was it obvious once you opened the harness? Did you have a misfire code? The lack of CEL is mystifying to me!
 
I had no CEL, which was also a mystery to me. Where the harness passes the EGR remove the loom and the fabric heat wrap to look at the wires. I immediately saw two or three wires that were missing insulation and shorting against each other.
 
Back
Top Bottom