How does it get this bad?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 30, 2016
Threads
24
Messages
99
Location
Camarillo, CA
Finally back to wrenching on the 40 (life got in the way for awhile...) Anyhow, I removed the radiator and had it thoroughly cleaned at a shop. I figured I would replace the thermostat while I was at it. When I removed the hose, this is what it looked like (see photos). What causes it to get this bad? Anything else I should do or be concerned about?

I'm still trying to remove the top half of the thermostat housing. I got the factory bolt out with heat and Kroll. However, the PO had a bolt/nut in the other bolt hole that won't budge... probably try to weld the nut on tomorrow.

20201128_203705.webp


20201128_204325.webp


20201128_203833.webp
 
That's the worst I have ever seen. You might have had a mix of incompatible antifreeze brands, but all coolant gets cruddy if it hasn't been changed in years. Also could be some really bad water quality especially if the previous owner used tap water instead of distilled.
 
there was a thread a few months ago with similar pictures, unfortunetly you may need to remove the engine and have the block cleaned/checked.
 
A commercial engine flushing pump could probably do the trick. They are various flush liquids that could most likely dissolve whatever remains. They hook up a hose to either side of the system and it just circulates through over and over until the liquid comes out clear.

If it was me, I would try to have that done, and if it goes off without a hitch call it a day. If your engine is obstructed, it probably won't work.

Out where I live, there's products called "BG" that are sold basically in shops to mechs, and they sell them the machines to go with the products. I don't know what you've got on the west coast, but I would assume there are similar things.
 
Did the lower radiator hose look as bad? How about the heater hoses?..... And was that same....junk....in the radiator?

Before you condemn the engine, pull the upper and lower thermostat housing from the block and pull the water pump....get an ‘eye-ball’ on the condition of the cast iron block internals.

And hope like hell the issue is localized to the aluminum components.

Older phosphate based antifreezes weren’t ‘kind’ to aluminum.
 
Did the lower radiator hose look as bad? How about the heater hoses?..... And was that same....junk....in the radiator?

Before you condemn the engine, pull the upper and lower thermostat housing from the block and pull the water pump....get an ‘eye-ball’ on the condition of the cast iron block internals.

And hope like hell the issue is localized to the aluminum components.

Older phosphate based antifreezes weren’t ‘kind’ to aluminum.


This link...https://www.streetmusclemag.com/tech-stories/fuel-cooling-ignition-tech/antifreeze-chemistry/....explains the issues of what you’re seeing.
 
Did the lower radiator hose look as bad? How about the heater hoses?..... And was that same....junk....in the radiator?

Before you condemn the engine, pull the upper and lower thermostat housing from the block and pull the water pump....get an ‘eye-ball’ on the condition of the cast iron block internals.

And hope like hell the issue is localized to the aluminum components.

Older phosphate based antifreezes weren’t ‘kind’ to aluminum.


I will dig in a bit more next weekend... thanks for the input... my wrenching on the 40 got interrupted by a broken water heater...
 
When iron steel aluminum and coolant with either salt or phosphate in it mix you get what happened to your engine. If you pull your water pump off and look into it I bet the impeller is just as trashed. I would suggest removing the thermostat completely disconnecting the radiator completely and running water through the block with the radiator hoses (clean them out) still attached and to see if you have any flow at all through it.
If you don't you are going to have to flush the block out with a commercial descaling solution. I would suggest letting it sit for 30 mins then flushing then repeating. If that does not work start planning on pulling the engine to disassemble and have it hot tanked.
I do a lot with pumps that are used around salt water environments and it is not a easy clean up. Here are pics of what I see In some cases

CB3780BD-9191-4EE6-960B-D386AC137C72.webp


DC315B61-28CB-4399-9ACC-6DF5342686D3.webp


E94DAC57-1AB5-4524-BFCF-422197FA4DC9.webp
 
Last edited:
Any updates? My 75' was like this after sitting for 20 years but it was isolated to the t stat housing and the water pump. The block still had green liquid coolant in it. I replaced the water pump, t stat housing, t stat, and used some rad flush and all is well.

IMG_0452.webp


IMG_0459.webp
 
Finally back to wrenching on the 40 (life got in the way for awhile...) Anyhow, I removed the radiator and had it thoroughly cleaned at a shop. I figured I would replace the thermostat while I was at it. When I removed the hose, this is what it looked like (see photos). What causes it to get this bad? Anything else I should do or be concerned about?

I'm still trying to remove the top half of the thermostat housing. I got the factory bolt out with heat and Kroll. However, the PO had a bolt/nut in the other bolt hole that won't budge... probably try to weld the nut on tomorrow.

View attachment 2509658

View attachment 2509659

View attachment 2509660

Wow. How long has that coolant been in there?
This makes me think about the coolant in my 40. It has been "inactive" for a while...
 
A commercial engine flushing pump could probably do the trick. They are various flush liquids that could most likely dissolve whatever remains. They hook up a hose to either side of the system and it just circulates through over and over until the liquid comes out clear.

If it was me, I would try to have that done, and if it goes off without a hitch call it a day. If your engine is obstructed, it probably won't work.

Out where I live, there's products called "BG" that are sold basically in shops to mechs, and they sell them the machines to go with the products. I don't know what you've got on the west coast, but I would assume there are similar things.

BG products are some good stuff! They do have a cooling system cleaner product. I am less familiar with the flushing machine, but I think most general repair shops have them.
 
That’s pretty bad!!

THIS is a great thread... read it and the @Mark W “muriatic acid” suggestion thoroughly.

Here is the Mark W post:


If you want to try to attack the blockage at the Drain plug with muriatic acid, a way to do this and use a lot less acid is to insert a fitting where the drain plug goes, attach a hose to that, raise the other end of the hose and put a small amount of acid in the hose... give it a while to become exhausted, lower the hose to drain it out, and do it again... possibly several times.

If the acid is doing anything you will have some fumes appearing at the top of the hose most likely... and the acid will be heavily discolored yellow as it drains.


Mark...
 
Another @Mark W post on the topic:



Muratic acid will not hurt steel or iron or brass or rubber or plastic. It will not hurt anything in the block. It will attack rust and mineral deposits. It WILL eat aluminum.

Kerosene won't do squat to any of the materials involved here... or to anything that would be forming any sort of blockage. Absolutely pointless to use.

The blockage in the area of the drain plug is usually not rust or minerals but various sediments introduced in small quantities over the years as water is added to the rad. it is common for muriatic acid to not affect this stuff. manual removal is usually called for. I have encountered a couple of blocks where even that was unsuccessful with the block in the rig. :(

If you use muriatic acid to flush the block, you will want to remove the water pump and if you have a manifold pre-heater installed, take that out of the loop. Some external tank heaters have AL in them, so make sure they are not involved either.

I use muriatic acid all the time. a little common sense and there is no reason to be afraid of it. It is not all that nasty.


Mark...
 
Any updates? My 75' was like this after sitting for 20 years but it was isolated to the t stat housing and the water pump. The block still had green liquid coolant in it. I replaced the water pump, t stat housing, t stat, and used some rad flush and all is well.

View attachment 2523268

View attachment 2523269

No update yet... wrenching has taken a back seat to work and home repairs once again. My vehicle sat idle for 10-15 years in a field before I got it. The water is extremely hard where the PO and I live. I'm sure he probably filled it full of tap water before he parked it. I pulled the radiator and had it professionally cleaned. The guy at the shop said it had a lot of scale in it.

I'm contemplating buying a small Harbor Freight electric pump and making a DIY 5- gallon bucket flush system. Now it is just a matter of figuring out what to flush it with... muriatic acid, BG product, CLR, or another similar product...
 
When you are done please add a coolant filter, goes in the heater core hose, it catches anything left over that comes loose, you will be amazed what it catches when you cut the filter apart..


Local Napa had it for 30$, plus 8$ for the filter..
 
No update yet... wrenching has taken a back seat to work and home repairs once again. My vehicle sat idle for 10-15 years in a field before I got it. The water is extremely hard where the PO and I live. I'm sure he probably filled it full of tap water before he parked it. I pulled the radiator and had it professionally cleaned. The guy at the shop said it had a lot of scale in it.

I'm contemplating buying a small Harbor Freight electric pump and making a DIY 5- gallon bucket flush system. Now it is just a matter of figuring out what to flush it with... muriatic acid, BG product, CLR, or another similar product...
Is it in the block though?
 
Now it is just a matter of figuring out what to flush it with... muriatic acid, BG product, CLR, or another similar product...

Well, if time isn't of the essence, you could try white vinegar. It's a lot more mild than something like muriatic acid or flush products. You could fill the system and let it sit for awhile. I've heard people will do that for a month or so. If you're in a hurry, oxalic acid is a common solution for heavily crapped-up engines. Most often the procedure involves running the engine up to temp if you can and then neutralizing the acid with some kind of base solution (dissolved soda) afterwards. It's also possible that the chemical reaction inside can effect sealing areas (or something is already compromised) and you will start getting a leak from somewhere afterwards.
 
Update: Finally got around to wrenching on the FJ today. Let me start by saying that we (my son and I) are learning as we go and are by no means experts.

I broke our cooling system flush up into three separate components- the heater core, the block, and the radiator. (Also, the vehicle is up on blocks and not running at the moment.) Since I had the radiator professionally cleaned I took that off the table and did not mess with it. I did not think it made sense to introduce gunk from a flush into a clean radiator.

When I tried to remove the top half of the thermostat housing from the lower, I snapped one of the bolts. So, I figured I would just remove the lower housing from the block. Well, as luck would have it, I snapped a bolt off in the block. (Yes, before trying to remove both bolts, I prepped them with heat, penetrating oil, and light impact). Nothing is ever easy!

I told my son, who is learning to weld, to thread a nut on the end of the broken bolt and weld it into place. The heat from the welder did the trick and the bolt came out with a few turns of the socket wrench. We removed the thermostat housing, but kept the water pump in place, as I installed it not long ago.

Since the radiator is not in the vehicle, we made a flush system with a small Harbor Freight pump, tubing, and a 5-gallon bucket. We used the same system for both the heater core and the block. However, the heater core and block were flushed independently. We added a pvc valve to the system when flusing the HEATER CORE which enabled us to reduce the pressure to around 10 psi. We removed the pvc valve and added an OTC power flush gun to the system when flushing the BLOCK, which gave us bursts up to around 80 psi.

Before flushing the heater core, I tested the system with a sprinkler/hose bib pressure gauge. The Harbor Freight pump generated approximately 20 psi. I dialed the pvc valve down until I had approximately 10 psi.

I filled the bucket with water and began the flush. Every so often I would open the valve to give a slight burst which resulted in more gunk being dislodged. We swapped buckets multiple times until the water ran completely clear. We then ran a bucket with water and "Prestone Flush and Clean" throughout the day. This was followed up with a distilled water rinse (our tap water is horrible) before a final run with coolant.

We performed the same procedure for the block. However, when flushing the block we removed the restrictive valve and added the OTC power flush gun (Amazon). Using a piece of scrap steel and metal pipe, we made a hose attachment to fit onto the block in place of the thermostat housing.
(It was another excuse for my kid to use the welder- it worked perfectly...)

On a sidenote, the OTC product was awesome! It hooks up to your hose and air compressor (not to exceed 100psi). With clear tubing you can see all the crap that was dislodged with every burst of the gun.

The good news is when we were done, both the heater core and block were flowing totally clear water. Bad news is when I sent a bore scope into the block through the thermostat hole, it didn't look great. I will try to post some of those pics shortly.

I know this was certainly NOT the most efficient way to go about this, but we had fun and learned a lot along the way...

20210101_151729.webp


20210101_154108.webp


20210101_154113.webp


20210102_102147.webp


20210102_102152.webp
 
The two jugs in the photo with the rust colored water came from the heater core. The green colored jug came out of the block...

20210102_103130.webp


20210102_143129.webp


20210102_143607.webp


20210102_101907.webp
 
Back
Top Bottom