Help with battery/alternator

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
May 13, 2015
Threads
20
Messages
92
Location
Northern New Mexico
For the past year or so, I've noticed the battery just isn't holding a charge for the 4-6 days that I go without driving the truck. The battery is a Duralast Gold 27F manufactured in Oct, 2013, so I'm not sure it's time for it to be replaced. However, with 169K miles I've yet to do any maintenance on the alternator (other than new belts). As I'm pretty new to the electrical system in these vehicles, I'm hoping you guys can point me in the right direction. New battery first? I got out the voltmeter and came up with these numbers, which are all pretty low to spec:

Not running, sat for 2 hours after a 20 min. drive: 12.2V
Running: 13.6V
Running with headlights and stereo on: 13V
 
For the past year or so, I've noticed the battery just isn't holding a charge for the 4-6 days that I go without driving the truck. The battery is a Duralast Gold 27F manufactured in Oct, 2013, so I'm not sure it's time for it to be replaced. However, with 169K miles I've yet to do any maintenance on the alternator (other than new belts). As I'm pretty new to the electrical system in these vehicles, I'm hoping you guys can point me in the right direction. New battery first? I got out the voltmeter and came up with these numbers, which are all pretty low to spec:

Not running, sat for 2 hours after a 20 min. drive: 12.2V
Running: 13.6V
Running with headlights and stereo on: 13V


I would look for a dead short,or an accessory item that doesn't turn off with the key (is therefore always on) then that would be the first place I would look.

If this problem just started out of the blue, and you haven't done any electrical work, then it is almost certainly a dead battery.

You are getting a charge so it is not your alternator.
 
Agree, battery is suspect, but the charging voltage is on the low side. Generally, fully charged at 2000 rpm, the voltage should be 14.0 or so.

I would swap batteries and see, but prepare to get a new alternator if yours is original. The brushes wear down and need replacement, so you may need to do that, or get a rebuilt alternator.

Your running voltage looks low too-should be 14.0. You may have 2 problems, or your dying alternator took out your battery by chronically undercharging it.
 
Forgot to test for parasitic load earlier. Getting 70mA currently, but that's not consistent and will drop to 0 for whatever reason (might be user error). The only electrical "work" I've done is cut the trailer harness and wrap it in electrical tape until I can get around to pulling the entire harness.

I'm suspecting battery at this point. I've only recently started using a battery tender jr, but before that the truck would go a week or two at a time without being driven. I know I know, why have it if I don't drive it right? Yeah but when it gets driven, it gets DRIVEN! :steer:

I'll swap the battery and test voltages again. And I'll keep alternator brushes on my to-do list. Thanks, guys.
 
Maybe 3 problems:

  1. Damaged battery that won't hold a charge
  2. Dying alternator
  3. High parasitic drain
I would start with new battery, then check volts when running. As Drew said, you should be in the 14s when engine is running, especially when everything is still cool.

Then the alternator.

Then if the battery still is getting excessively discharged after 1 week of non use, look for parasitic drain.

Along with my FJ60, I have a Subaru. EFI. Remote entry FOB etc...That car SUCKS down the battery fast while in storage.Brand new battery too. It has to be charged every 2 weeks if I'm not driving it if I don't want to wreck the battery. Sucks.
 
My order of operations when hunting down a problem:
  1. Cheap fix first - it doesn't cost anything to look for a parasitic drain, just time & effort
  2. Easy fix next - battery is a bit easier to replace than the alternator
  3. Most likely issue - if something seems suspect, and it doesnt fall under category 1 or 2, then check it next
  4. When you have eliminated all other possibilities, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be your issue

I may swap #1 and #2, depending on if I value my money or my time more on any given saturday. I get wrapped around the axle sometimes chasing #3, only to realize in the end it was something stupid/easy/cheap that I missed (and I potentially spent money I didnt need to) because I jumped straight to what I thought the problem was. YMMV.
 
Not running, sat for 2 hours after a 20 min. drive: 12.2V
Running: 13.6V
Running with headlights and stereo on: 13V

12.2V is about 50% depleted, but 20 minutes isn't enough time to charge any battery and you don't mention what the voltage was before starting the truck or how long it sat beforehand.

You should be seeing about 14.4 volts across the battery with the engine running, but if the battery has a bad cell it could drag down the voltage.

70 mA is about twice what I'd expect to see with everything off, but I don't know what you have in your truck. Make sure you're reading it correctly with your meter.

Most retailers will load test the battery for free or you could get a replacement if it is still covered under the warranty.
The OEM alternator can be rebuilt with a kit from Toyota.

The Duralast Gold appears to be a standard flooded cell battery. Typically, they don't recover well after being severely discharged.

Change your fusible links when you change the battery.
 
12.2V is about 50% depleted, but 20 minutes isn't enough time to charge any battery and you don't mention what the voltage was before starting the truck or how long it sat beforehand.

You should be seeing about 14.4 volts across the battery with the engine running, but if the battery has a bad cell it could drag down the voltage.

70 mA is about twice what I'd expect to see with everything off, but I don't know what you have in your truck. Make sure you're reading it correctly with your meter.

Yeah, unfortunately I just don't have the data for what happened before today. But my wife left one of the doors cracked and it killed the battery overnight. After that, I jumped it and drove around for 45 minutes. That was yesterday, and it might have been the final nail in the coffin for this battery. I've got fusible links in the mail and when they arrive I'll replace the battery and run the tests again.

For whatever reason when I attempt to test for parasitic load using the 10A setting on my meter (new meter btw), one node on the negative cable and the other on the negative battery post, it will go to 0.07A (70mA) then come back down and hover between 0 and 0.02A. When I test in the 200mA range, I get nothing. Not sure how to proceed there, maybe the meter I bought was just too cheap.
 
when I attempt to test for parasitic load using the 10A setting on my meter
That is too high a setting to check for low current. You should be on the lowest setting to check for low current. The higher the setting, the less sensitive the reading, which is why you get 0 when you're on the higher setting.

If this battery has been severely depleted then the best course of action is to replace it.
 
it will go to 0.07A (70mA) then come back down and hover between 0 and 0.02A.
When you first attach a battery (through the meter or in general) there is inrush current as all the devices charge up capacitors. This should stabilize after a second or 3. The reading of 20mA (not quite accurate with your meter) is not far off. I would expect a draw of around 35mA. IMO, anything close to that is well within the normal range.

Also consider that you could have a failing alternator that in turn killed the battery, but my first thought would be to replace the battery. 5 years is a typical lifespan, but there are many variables that effect battery life, not to mention a possible bad batch from the factory.
 
As I mentioned, when I use the lower setting (20mA or 200mA) it doesn't register above 0, which is suspect to me since it should at least see the clock. Maybe I'll return this meter and get a different one.

I'll be adding alternator to the list of things to do, and I'll take measurements as soon as I get a new battery. I suspect this one didn't last long for me because it's not my daily driver and I likely didn't keep it topped off as I should have. Thanks for your input.
 
I've got similar symptoms on my truck. Slightly lower than normal charging voltage, 85mA parasitic drain. If you don't drive it for days on end and have a high (+40mA) drain, I suggest getting a AGM battery and use a desulfating smart charger like a Battery Minder or NOCO. I put my truck on that for 48 hours or more and the battery holds a charge much better after. Do that every couple weeks. Not an end all solution, but finding a parasitic drain isn't always the easiest thing to do.

Also like Jon said above, battery and alternator go hand in hand. If you buy a new battery but the alt is not performing correctly, the battery won't be at full potential and have a short life span. Never hurts having a backup Alt anyway. Try brushes first tho. It Can be done at your next oil change when you take the oil filter out.
 
I'm cheap and lazy. I'd try either of these ideas first:

Disconnect one of the battery cables. Charge the battery using a battery charger to fully charged. Remove charger. Let it sit this way (battery cable disconnected) for the amount of days that it used to fail. Connect the battery back up. If it doesn't start like before, battery is dead. If it starts just fine, battery seems to be holding charge.

OR

Swap in know good battery from another rig. If the symptoms return, then battery is not your issue and you should look at charging system or parasitic draw.
 
Back
Top Bottom