gears vs. SC

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Apr 26, 2009
Threads
51
Messages
189
Location
Salt Lake City, UT
On a standard LC, no lift, 237/75/16 tires am I better served by changing my gears around or getting the SC? As always, we're all looking for more go, and I'm trying to think of the best place to sink my money. I'm not going to be going 90mph on the hwy so that kind of tells me that I've got wasted HP there on the 4th gear power band. Forced induction seems to be a good way to go to add HP/torque without bobbing Paul to pay Peter. Any bright ideas out there comparing the trade off? I'm running 91 gas constantly so that doesn't scare me BTW.

At $3500 + labor, it seems like the SC option is about 50% more than new gears? Is that close on the pricing estimates?
 
with no lift,and 33 or smaller tires, sc all the way.
 
I think that if you are considering the SC there are other things to consider if you go that route.

How many miles are on the current engine?

Has the head gasket ever been done?

Has the head/valves ever been done?

Have the injectors been tested and cleaned?

And I am probably missing somethings

But I would think that the cost of also doing all those items on top of the SC should also be considered

It would suck to go through the trouble of installing an SC and then your HG takes a dump etc.

Food for thought
 
I think that if you are considering the SC there are other things to consider if you go that route.

How many miles are on the current engine?

Has the head gasket ever been done?

Has the head/valves ever been done?

Have the injectors been tested and cleaned?

And I am probably missing somethings

But I would think that the cost of also doing all those items on top of the SC should also be considered

It would suck to go through the trouble of installing an SC and then your HG takes a dump etc.

Food for thought

I completely agree here.

Gears + install - you're talking a few grand if done by a professional.

SC + install = almost 10k if you do it right.

I know because I've done both. I have 4.88's with a rebuilt top end and TRD SC.

The end result is awesome, no matter your tire size (I have 345's).
 
...

SC + install = almost 10k if you do it right.

......

Can you explain how you come up with 10k?:eek:

My cost was no where near 10K and I felt it was done right.:confused:
P4050211.webp
 
Last edited:
Can you explain how you come up with 10k?:eek:

My cost was no where near 10K and I felt it was done right.:confused:

Obviously it would differ with each rig based on their conditions, but I'd love to hear what steps you took as well since I would love to add an SC to mine. Well under 10k sounds good to me :grinpimp:
 
If I can afford the SC next year I pretty much plan to simply bolt it on so $3300 in parts:meh: If your truck is well maintained I see no need to tear it completely apart and rebuild simply because your giving it a conservative boost level.

Gears can be done for less too. I'm in the middle of it now. I'm going to be dropping of my 3rd members to the shop for the actual gear set up. The rest I'm doing myself. Saving more than half the labor costs.
 
I should also add these two mods are different in that one is purely about power (SC) and the other is more about control on the trail (gears) with a side effect of a perceived addition of power on the street.
 
Neither, 5.3l Chevy. Sorry, but no way in hell would I spend even 6k on the 4.5L.

Understandable but a engine swap done right can cost a lot more. The little things always add up. If you have the ability to do it yourself great. But paying someone is going to be over $10K IMO. I did a SBC swap in my 60 on the cheap. It worked but cost more than I budgeted. And in the end wish I would done many things differently.
 
Understandable but a engine swap done right can cost a lot more. The little things always add up. If you have the ability to do it yourself great. But paying someone is going to be over $10K IMO. I did a SBC swap in my 60 on the cheap. It worked but cost more than I budgeted. And in the end wish I would done many things differently.

We can debate that all day long. Not what this thread was about to begin with and my bad for injecting a useless comment not directly related to what the poster was asking. Sorry for the hijack.
If your only running a 33" tall tire I would go S/C any thing bigger, re-gear and do the S/C.
 
We can debate that all day long. Not what this thread was about to begin with and my bad for injecting a useless comment not directly related to what the poster was asking. Sorry for the hijack.
If your only running a 33" tall tire I would go S/C any thing bigger, re-gear and do the S/C.

I agree with that entire post.
 
LandCruiserPhil said:
Can you explain how you come up with 10k?:eek:

My cost was no where near 10K and I felt it was done right.:confused:

Every install is unique. I had to tackle a few issues for peace of mind. When installing the SC, my truck had 204k and it's original HG. Rebuild, blower and install was 8k along with a few other items; water pump, radiator, thermostat etc. I'm sure a full rebuild and install like Nlxtacy was closer to 10k if not more.

I'm sure yours was done right. Again, this is all subjective.
 
Last edited:
I did the engine swap thing and yes, the power increase is dramatic to say the least. It cost me about $6k in parts. I did my own work so no labor costs. Corbet is correct that if you were to pay someone to do a swap, it would be in the $10-12 range for parts and labor. However, if you have the ability, the swap to a modern V8 is highly recommended. It's a completely different ride now with power to spare and getting up to speed is effortless.

On the flip side, I still feel my 80 needs a bit lower gear in the axle for two reasons:

1. crawl ability on the trail. The 4l60e has a low first gear, but it's still not enough.
2. keep the trans in OD on steeper grades at high speed. This would reduce the shifter in and out of OD and reduce wear and tear on the trans.

I am running the stock 4.10s and 315s. A switch to 4.88s would be a perfect match of power, but I would probably lose about 1mpg in economy due to the increased engine speed. 4.56s would be a good compromise for the current tire size but I may go to something bigger down the road.

So OP, I would do both. Start with the gears, and then do the SC. This was you can evaluate the performance of just the gear change below and it's a lesser expense. You also gain a little bit better crawl ratio as well. If the performance is not where you want it, then do the SC.

Plan on addressing the HG when you do the SC. It would be better to do it as a preventative measure rather than slapping the SC and then blowing the HG afterwards and potentially doing damage to the engine that would require a full rebuild.
 
I did the 4.88's and 315's earlier this year. It cost me a total of about $1200 in parts (including front axle rebuild kit, brake caliper rebuild, lines, ect.) and $500 for the 3rd member regear.

I like the way the "power" is compared to the 4.11's since I stay more in the "power band" it just makes he drive ability better.

However just like adding a SC there is always those "while I'm in there parts" that start adding up. So all in all my front axle has over $1600 alone with new OEM spindles and I was fortunate enough to have factory lockers. And I haven't torn into the rear axle yet. I just did a R and R on the third member. Waiting for winter to do my seals and bearings.

So either way if you have OCD like me and others either way it will add up.

If I do a SC i would probably also do a HG job and head rebuild "while I'm in there" more so for peace of mind and to satisfy my OCD.
 
Aside from the swap talk & back to original question - since you have factory lockers, you should pay to get the gears done, the open diffs a good mechanic can do, but the e-lockers are a little more complex & the shim pack alone can cost you right into what would be labor at a good shop - Slee isn't too far away, so a little road trip for gears would put you into whatever you figure the cost to be once you call Christo & see what the charge would be, then the cost of there & back.

As for a supercharger, if you are fairly comfortable with toolset & have the time to do it, the instructions they include are really straightforward, so you could do it yourself - but I would make sure your motor has a updated headgasket, otherwise it'll be a house build on a shakey foundation. So really ~$3300 for the charger, but add another ~$1500 for parts & getting new stem seals in the head (will take care of any oil useage if you have any)

I'd do the gears first, as that makes any tire size you want to play on a possibility without drivetrain strain. Skip 4.56's - they aren't worth it as the jump isn't much - I have 4.88's & they aren't all that much either - I really wish I jumped to 5.29's - but then unless you want to run 35's minimum they are a bit much.

I personally did gears first, and my supercharger is still waiting to install. I'm buying a 2nd 80 that has airlockers & 5.29's right now, so the fan can wait until I get the new one all PM'ed.

Gears. and it'll be a good ~$2K+ buy the time all is done & you are spinning rubber again.
 
It depends on where you are trying to get more "go." If you re-gear with stock tires, you're going to be winding your engine up trying to just keep pace on the freeway.

Both options will improve performance around town. Re-gear will be better for off road, SC will be better on the freeway.

If freeway cruising isn't a problem, i think gears are a better bang for the buck.
 
Back
Top Bottom