ECT setting for Longetivty?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 15, 2007
Threads
24
Messages
101
Any input on what the smartest tranny setting is for a truck with 185K on it? At first, I didn't want to stress the trans so I left it off power. However, my education has taught me that quicker firmer shifts are easier on the trans. Since trying out the Power setting I might be thinking this is the best for the truck, all else?!?!?
 
Is the ECT button the same as the PWR in newer trucks? If it is, then I have the PWR switched on all the time. Why? Read on...

When the PWR is OFF the tranny treats you as if you were retarded. You stomp on the gas and the tranny says 'are you sure'? One second passes and you keep on pressing the pedal to the floor. Tranny still waits and says 'are you really sure you want to accelerate'? Truck runs like crap on low RPMs and you keep on waiting and waiting. Suddenly the tranny disengages the current gear and the RPMs go up. While they climb to redline the tranny downshifts and boooom, you get a kick in the butt. You probably know that it's not good to engage a gear while the engine revvs really high. A very non-responsive tranny.

When the PWR is ON, the transmission treats you like an adult. You press the gas and the tranny shifts immediately and smootly. No kicking, no jolting. I guess that it is better for the transmission to have the PWR on as you change gears faster and smoother.
 
When the PWR is OFF the tranny treats you as if you were retarded. You stomp on the gas and the tranny says 'are you sure'? One second passes and you keep on pressing the pedal to the floor. Tranny still waits and says 'are you really sure you want to accelerate'?

:D lol .. pretty nice .. I would remember next time when someone ask me about it ..
 
Is the ECT button the same as the PWR in newer trucks? If it is, then I have the PWR switched on all the time. Why? Read on...

When the PWR is OFF the tranny treats you as if you were retarded. You stomp on the gas and the tranny says 'are you sure'? One second passes and you keep on pressing the pedal to the floor. Tranny still waits and says 'are you really sure you want to accelerate'? Truck runs like crap on low RPMs and you keep on waiting and waiting. Suddenly the tranny disengages the current gear and the RPMs go up. While they climb to redline the tranny downshifts and boooom, you get a kick in the butt. You probably know that it's not good to engage a gear while the engine revvs really high. A very non-responsive tranny.

When the PWR is ON, the transmission treats you like an adult. You press the gas and the tranny shifts immediately and smootly. No kicking, no jolting. I guess that it is better for the transmission to have the PWR on as you change gears faster and smoother.

Hmm...I think you may have a tranny kickdown cable that is out of adjustment. It's not supposed to "rev and kick" in either setting.
 
I can't imagine the PWR button will negatively affect the longevity of the tranny. If anything, PWR makes it s***ft less often because it holds each gear longer so over the course of many miles/years of driving, less shifting should mean less wear. Either way, I get better mileage around town driving with the PWR on at all times (something about keeping the RPMs within the power curve for greater efficiency).
 
The tranny is not a weak point. I don't think having the ECT/PWR button engaged or disengaged, will have any appreciable effect on the longevity of the tranny.
 
The tranny is so strong that I press the pwr button on and off while shifting gears manually with the shifter. But that prevented me from having any hands on the wheel - so I had to stop doing that....:steer:
 
I can't imagine the PWR button will negatively affect the longevity of the tranny. If anything, PWR makes it ****ft less often because it holds each gear longer so over the course of many miles/years of driving, less shifting should mean less wear. Either way, I get better mileage around town driving with the PWR on at all times (something about keeping the RPMs within the power curve for greater efficiency).


What mileage are you getting ?



Thanks,
Fred
 
Frankly, I cant tell the difference between the two, and I have a supercharger.

Karl
 
PWR or NORMAL setting on the ECT switch will make absolutely no difference in the longevity of the transmission. It only affects the shift schedule (upshifts and downshifts) of the transmission. It doesn't affect shift duration (slower or faster shift times) at all - wasn't intended or designed to do that.

You're right, firmer quicker shifts if tuned correctly are better for durability because they build up less heat during the shift, but as mentioned, the ECT switch doesn't alter that.

MikePL, if you're having that kind of problem, it's not the ECT switch that'll save you. First I would check the kickdown cable, then have a trans service. If the problem still exists, it may be time for some serious trans PM.

Dan.
 
The kickdown cable is OK. What I meant by jolts and revving was that if you go slow (on 3rd or OD) with PWR off and you press the pedal to the floor, the tranny waits a lot and then suddenly downshifts to 2nd or even 1st gear.

With PWR on the tranny is more responsive to any pedal movement, so if you go slow on 3rd or 4th gear and start pressing the pedal, the transmission gradually downshifts gear by gear as the pedal goes down, thus avoiding sudden shifts from extreme gears.

Absolutely no difference in mileage and no noticeable changes in shift points. There is a slight tendency to retain the RPMs before changing to a higher gear, but it only happens under stronger acceleration and is barely noticeable. Maybe it contradicts the general opinion about the PWR switch but I have quite a sensitive foot and ear and this is how I feel it. Of course I would be grateful if any of you (or all) tested the PWR switch and confirmed or denied my opinions.

And yes, if you drive in a delicate manner, there will be no difference in the longevity of the transmission, but if you have a heavy foot you will benefit from the PWR setting. Smoother gear changes and a whole lot of response to pedal movement.

Anyway, can't wait to see your findings and conclusions.
 
Hmm, I cant say that I have observed the same modified gear changes in the pwr mode. Perhaps its more subtle than I can perceive. I was wondering if my kickdown cable had anything to with its operation because I had to adjust mine after the sc install. I dont get any revving between gears shifts - the rpm change and gear shift are simultaneous. I will pay particular attention and get back with my findings.

Karl
 
Back
Top Bottom