Drivetrain Clunk

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

"Symptoms: start the truck up, everything sounds normal till I put it in drive or reverse. It sounds like two gears are grinding up front, perhaps like one of the birfs let go. Seemed to be louder on the right side.

In gear it would not move, until I put it back in park and pushed the cdl switch, then noise GONE!"

Boy that sounds like a drive flange to me. There's a pretty good amount of force being transferred through that interface.
 
x5 drive flange. I agree with Rick, no human can apply enough force to check for a stripped flange...
 
OK, if it is the drive flange, then why no metal shavings or filings? or is this one of those mysteries of the LC?

BTW, I put the whole thing back together, sans front ds. No ugly sound until I try to put it in park, but not the same as the previous sound. I can't put it in park while the engine is running. Other shifting OK.

In any case, it just may be the flange. It certainly has some wear, as do the splines on the birf shaft.

Thanks for all your input.

Dennis
 
BTW, I put the whole thing back together, sans front ds. No ugly sound until I try to put it in park, but not the same as the previous sound. I can't put it in park while the engine is running. Other shifting OK.

The tranny/TC will make a really funny sound if this sequence of events takes place:

1- front d/s is removed OR TC in "N" AND CDL NOT locked
2- tranny put in drive
3- tranny put back in park

Lock the CDL FIRST. Otherwise you will continue to make funny sounds and not be able to go anywhere.
 
take the flange from the PS and check the play on the DS birf against the play of the DS flange on the DS birf.

In the cases where I saw a flange issue there were ribs still there and the metal worn off just mixed into the grease and was hard to detect.

Look closely at the splines on the PS birf. The tops of the splines should have flat spots and the amount of wear can be gauged by how wide those flat spots are. If they are pointy then it's definitely toast.
 
OK, if it is the drive flange, then why no metal shavings or filings? or is this one of those mysteries of the LC?
...

They wear slowly, over time, so there are usually no large shavings or filings, more like dust. The best way to test for a stripped flange is; remove the dust caps, have a helper hold the brake, shift drive, then check for one of the stub shafts spinning in the flange.
 
Decisions, Decisions

I can finally concentrate on fixing this thing.

I drove the truck with the front ds out and the drive flanges removed to feel for vibration. There is a bit of vibration that I suspect is the rear ds ujoints, but no other noises that would leave me thinking that I have another big problem lurking in the shadows.

I'm pretty sure that the problem is the right side drive flange and the birf. The splines on the birf shaft are rather pointed with no flats. The joint itself seems good and smooth by feel. There was grease in both birfs, but no oil in the knuckle housing......problem???

I'm down to choices now.

Do I buy only one birf and the associated drive flange for the right side, or do I bite the bullet and buy a pair of birfs and flanges so I don't have to mess with it again?

I have seen chrome moly birfs and axles offered as a set.

I have also seen some aftermarket birfs in the neighborhood of $100.

I would like to keep the expense down, but I don't want to go through another breakdown and repair just because I was cheap, err ..... frugal:D. I want to repair it right, yet not spend a fortune.

Any vendor reccommendations? The OEM birfs are pretty expensive. I am planning to get the flange(s), gaskets, snap rings, etc from CDan.

Advice please, so I really don't screw it up.

Thanks, Dennis
 
Back
Top Bottom