Discussion on Brake Line Performance

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Romer

fatherofdaughterofromer
Moderator
Joined
Sep 14, 2003
Threads
560
Messages
11,998
Location
Centennial, Colorado
I was searching through the archives and lots of good info on brake lines. In several threads, people stated that the "feel" at the pedal was better after installing the stainless. Others said there is no difference. Others said they had better "feel" with new rubbber hoses.

Also, several posts on stainless failures, but i didn't see any on rubber.

Since I am going to replace the brake fluid (Probably original) I personally don't see the advantage to stainless besides the bling. They are less flexible than rubber and metal does not hold up as well to flex, reflex, and flex somemore. I thought while I am doing the fluid I would put longer lines in there. I have part numbers for NAPA longer lines (380515 ) and there are Christo's, which look great for stainless lines.

So, two questions
1) What is the specific advantage of Stainless. I know the one about they are harder to cut by your spouse:D
2) What is the better "feel" attributed too; New fluid and bleeding lines, brake lines themselves or placebo effect?
 
Last edited:
Romer said:
2) What is the better "feel" attributed too; New fluid and bleeding lines, brake lines themselves or pacebo effect?

I'll post up quick and then stay out'a this one...:D

I'm pretty convinced that the better "feel" comes simply from replacing old, worn out lines with new ones, regardless of whether the new ones are rubber or stainless.

Curtis
 
There is something called Baranek's Law that, while it doesn't apply directly, essentially explains the better "feel" IMHO. :D

Seriously though, I concur with CJF. If the old stuff is worn, the new stuff should feel more like new stuff, and that is usually "better." If the old stuff is still in good shape, then the new "feel" is probably just from feeling good about a job done.
 
There’s a two fold benefit too the SS lines. Now as to whether either of them make a difference or not I dont know, but they seem legitimate.

Stainless lines being silver and reflective dont pick up as much radiant heat from the engine compartment. This leads to longer brake fluid life and rubber decay to heat (makes a difference in New Mexico). As to the overall life expectance of rubber vs. SS due to flexibility vs. heat I dont know.

Second, the SS lines dont like flex as much yes, but they do handle being continuously pelted with road debris much better than the rubber ones. Now, that being said, I've never had a rock/stick/gravel/cat/dead body mess up any of my brake lines, but the theory seems sound.

Theres my change from a buck paid for 98 cents worth of blah blah.
Chris
 
landtank said:
I put the stainless on and it felt better and the truck was rather new at the time, around 40k on the clock. I attributed this to the fact that the stainless is less likely to expand under pressure which will give you a more positive feel to the pedal, less sponge.

So did you change the 4 hoses to the calipers as well?
 
Romer,

No direct experience here either, but I spent a number of years on the Mecedes-list with people that were as into their cars as we are (at least), and the general consensous there was that SS lines definetly reduced the 'lag time' or response time in braking, while also 'firming up' the pedal. If memory serves me correctly the reason was that the stainless does not allow expansion of the lines like rubber ones do (however slight this might be).

Robert :beer:
 
landtank said:
No, just the ones for the lift.
Slee offers the complete set now including the
ones to the calipers.

I don't have direct experience either,
but when I changed the rubber ones
on my motorcycle with stainless, I noticed
a significant improvement. No bling factor
either as they look a rather dull gray.
 
I am running JDM 7pcs SS lines for 2 yrs. Actually the SS lines don't make you stop any faster, it just makes the pedals engage sooner than usual and gives it a firmer feels, a result of the SS restricting any flex of the rubber.

The stock lines are made of rubber, so they do flex or swell ever so slightly. Flex happens when brake fluid stretches the rubber lines when the brake is applied. No air enters the lines in either case or you're in big trouble. That is why you bleed the lines, to get the air out after you flush the system. Air is less dense than fluid, and will compress within the line if trapped, and the calipers would not actuate effectively when braking,

While the SS lines, well, they don’t flex at all, they keep all air out of the lines allowing for quicker more responsive stops.
LXTREME_Front_Left.webp
LXTREME_Front_Left_01.webp
LXTREME_Front_Right.webp
 
I swapped over to the stainless a couple months ago. Really didn't notice a difference in brake responsiveness. Brake guy did recommend a complete brake fluid exchange. Said people don't change out their brake fluid as often as they are suppose to. Evidently it breaks down and should be replaced periodically. Maybe he was feeding me a line. Either way, new fluid and new lines and I didn't notice a thing.

only replaced those for lift, not the whole thing.

troy
 
New fluid is a good thing, Brake fluid is designed to absorb water. Free water in a brake system causes loss of brakes form freezing or boiling, it is good to flush out old fluid from time to time. I have seen systems corrode badly from old fluid, it comes out of the bleed pots looking like mud, corrosion will cause calipers to stick. With ABS systems it becomes even more important as a new ABS unit is very expensive.

Aircraft soft lines in the hydraulic, pneumatic and fuel systems have stainless braiding; sometimes they will have fabric or heat resistant silicone over the braid depending on where it is. It is for pressure from the inside and mechanical protection from the outside. bare rubber and hoses are only used for low pressure, drains and alike

Do these same things apply to auto brake systems? Maybe not as critical but if you need new lines weather due to age or longer lines stainless braid makes sense. .

Tight fitting Spiral loom is used in places where more chafe protection is needed. Might be a good idea here, if clamped at the ends might provide some extra strain relief also

Pic, braided brake and truck tilt hydraulic lines with a blue fabric covering over the braid, foreword of that electrical harness covered with braid to protect the harness from flying debris thrown by the tires.
757-lines.webp
 
Last edited:
Romer said:
Also, several posts on stainless failures, but i didn't see any on rubber.

The original brake line on the RHF caliper let go after attempting a hard line on one of the hills at Land Cruiser Mountain Park. The front wheel came up in the air and after a panic stab of the pedal the brake line let go and I started rolling out of control to the bottom of the hill. NOT FUN. I had a brake line clamp in my tool box so I had to use that to be able to drive home. Made braking interesting to say the least.

When I got home I fitted new OE brake lines all round.

I have fitted S/S braided lines to the motorbike I used to have, the difference in braking feel was awesome. It might be different on an 80 though.

Brake fluid absorbs moisture from the air and it should be replaced every 12 months whether the vehicle is used regurly or not. The water will corrode your brake system making for expensive repairs not to mention potentially dangerous.
 
In my experience there is not a whole lot to be gained from SS lines on a truck unless you are running manual brakes with a small bore MC. The brake booster in the LC is the equivalent of 2 extra legs on the pedal and pushes a lot of fluid to fill those fancy 4 pot calipers. Any swell of the brake lines is going to be neglible at the pedal when moving that amount of fluid.

The motorcycle camparisons are not really valid because you are taking a very small bore MC pushing a much larger caliper piston... i.e. mechanical advantage, so you don't have to have Popeye forearms. In this situation, even slight swelling of the lines will be noticeable as increased travel at the lever.

All that said, I have SS lines on my VFR. I have rubber lines on my trucks.

One more word on SS lines for the trucks... when the SS brake lines flex at the caliper or frame, the outer braid will slide over the inner teflon liner. If you do manage to get any mud/dirt/etc worked into the braid it will 'sand' right through the inner liner. Get the high quility SS braided lines that have the sealed outer poly jacket to keep the mud and grime out of the braid. I have seen a few SS lines fail and it is always at the sharpest bend where the most sliding will occur.
 
I have the Slee stainless lines and they are covered in a plastic sheath (sealed at both ends) so no abrasives can get into them.
I noticed a little firming up of the pedal but I did it more for line extension. I assumed SS would last longer but it's not a big issue for me either way.
 
After Golf I dropped by Christo's. life is so rough here in Denver. I picked up the set of the stainless lines. I did not get the 4 to the calipers. The way he described it is they are covered in Kevlar, then the stainless braid and they are then encapsulated with the plastic coating. The coating is tapered near the plugs and the look well built. I will install these tomorrow and post results. I also bought the Valvoline synth Brake fluid that exceeds DOT 3 specifications.
These are nice looking brake lines and I am not concerned about dust or dirt getting into the braid.

Good discussion guys, thanks. Hopefully, I'll have time to flush the power steering as well. I bought the synthetic for that too.
 
Most of my experience with SS lines has been in Autocross cars. However, I have found that you can modulate (sp?) your breaks better. If you were coming into a turn too hot and on your breaks, you only have 1/8" of pedal movement to go from a fast lap to a butt puckering save. The "feel" of SS line would help in knowing where that 1/8" is. I have found that I'm able to do that in my LC on rocks. Not saying you can't do this with rubber lines, I just find it easier IMO.
 
RavenTai said:
New fluid is a good thing, Brake fluid is designed to absorb water. Free water in a brake system causes loss of brakes form freezing or boiling, it is good to flush out old fluid from time to time.

And you can buy a lot of brake fluid for what those SS lines run. My conclusion when I was looking into getting some.... no tangible benefit. I think it's one of those things that was developed for use in race car driving, that's made it's way into the passenger vehicle industry, originally targeting the more "elite" car enthusiast. You know the guy... Porshe Jacket, black jeans, white socks, black sneakers.
 
Last edited:
Well I swapped out the brake lines from Slee and flushed the fluid with a vacuum bleeder kit from Harbor freight. These brake lines are fully encapsulated so they won't collect dirt. I did notice a better feel, not sure if thats from the brake line, new fluid or the synthetic type fluid I am using.

I recommend these vacuum bleeder kits.
Brake Lines 001.webp
Brake Lines 002.webp
 
Back
Top Bottom