Difficult to flush coolent?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 26, 2004
Threads
116
Messages
1,282
Location
Oregon
Website
www.brian894x4.com
I do most of my own work, but I can't flush the coolent as I live in an apartment and even with a garage I have no way to flushing out the radiator, so the dealer did this for me.

The PO had green coolent and I wanted Toyota red. Got it back and I "think" I saw red coolent in it, but a few days later it was green...I mean bright green, just like it looked before it was changed. Checked the next day, same thing, bright green. I began to assume that they either used green coolent or didn't flush it at all.

My paperwork shows they charged me for 2 gallons of red coolant. Call the dealer and the mechanic swears that he flushed it and put red in it. But then says something about it being hard to flush because the thermostat wouldn't open, but then after he let it sit and cool off it did open and flushed out OK? Which didn't make any sense to me.

Anyway, they are willing to redo it for on their dime, which is fine, except for the hassle, but I'm just curious if something special has to be done to properly flush that they didn't do or was the mechanic just lazy and changed out the radiator coolent, but didn't do a proper flush?

I'm still learning about these 80s, but with two heater cores (right?) and a weird thermostat system, is there something they need to do different to get all the green out and do it right?

I really hate it when others work on my rigs.
 
There should be a block drain on the engine, make sure they open it and get as much coolant out of the system as possible.
 
Unless you can do it yourself (it is not that hard at all) take it back to the dealer and make sure they flush everything and the coolant is completely red. It is bad to mix coolant types.

Riley
 
I'm willing to bet, they didn't actually flush it and won't. Dealers get subject to careful inspection by the various state run environmental agencies. Coolant is considered hazardous waste and dealers have to recapture it all. So what they will typically do is drain is as well as they can by pulling all the plugs, then refill it. This does not get all the old coolant out.

You are either going to have to watch, or find a place to do it yourself to be sure that it really gets flushed.
 
Brian, if you ever get over to Central Oregon (Bend) I could help you. I just did a full coolant flush on my '94 about a month ago so it is fresh in my mind and I have all of the fittings that e9999 recommended. Have you changed out your hoses (esp. PHH)? It is a great time to do it. That way you have everything open and you can get pretty much all of the old coolant out.

Riley
 
But then says something about it being hard to flush because the thermostat wouldn't open, but then after he let it sit and cool off it did open and flushed out OK?

Well, I'm not sure how they do a flush, but if you tee in by the heater valve and do a back flush, the water pressure opens the thermostat. I suspect they are not doing a real flush where you hook up a water hose and let it run with the motor on, heater full blast until the water runs clear.

:beer:
Rookie2
 
I was afraid of that. I had thought that they put it on a machine or something, that cycles out all the coolant. I'm going to have really ask them about it when I take it back. This ticks me off, because not only am I now running mixed coolent, but I have to waste my time to bring to back and that's at least a few hours....not cool at all.

I mainly just wanted to get rid of all the green and go to red. My hoses are all good at 90K miles, but once a flush is done, it will be much easier to drain and repair if needed in the future. I can drain into a container, I just can't flush where I'm at.

Any dealer folks know what they typically do in this situation? You'd think I'd learn my lesson from past experience from other mechanics with bearings not being replaced when they said they were or starters being reinstalled with only one bolt, etc, etc.

I just need to get me a better place to work on my rig.
 
I was afraid of that. I had thought that they put it on a machine or something, that cycles out all the coolant. I'm going to have really ask them about it when I take it back. This ticks me off, because not only am I now running mixed coolent, but I have to waste my time to bring to back and that's at least a few hours....not cool at all.

I mainly just wanted to get rid of all the green and go to red. My hoses are all good at 90K miles, but once a flush is done, it will be much easier to drain and repair if needed in the future. I can drain into a container, I just can't flush where I'm at.

Any dealer folks know what they typically do in this situation? You'd think I'd learn my lesson from past experience from other mechanics with bearings not being replaced when they said they were or starters being reinstalled with only one bolt, etc, etc.

I just need to get me a better place to work on my rig.

Take care of it ASAP. Like other said, bad to mix coolant.
 
In my experience, if your coolant is 'bright green' there is no way in hell they put Toy Red in there, although on the bright side they probably flushed the system well. Most coolant with a significant number of miles on it doesn't look 'bright green', and if you mix damn near any quantity of red coolant with green coolant you get 'mucky' coolant. 'Bright green' indicates to me that they flushed it well and then put green coolant in.

-Spike
 
In my experience, if your coolant is 'bright green' there is no way in hell they put Toy Red in there, although on the bright side they probably flushed the system well. Most coolant with a significant number of miles on it doesn't look 'bright green', and if you mix damn near any quantity of red coolant with green coolant you get 'mucky' coolant. 'Bright green' indicates to me that they flushed it well and then put green coolant in.

-Spike

Ya, that's what really baffles me. I just checked it again today...BRIGHT green.

Just as if they either never changed it or used green coolent. They claim they only use Toyota red and my service receipt shows they charged me for 2 gallons of red with the red part number 00272-1LLAC-01.

I'm starting to think it was never done in the first place. It was bright green before. I think it was changed in the last year or so and the PO didn't put many miles on it. It only has 90K on it now. I just wanted to flushed out the green and go to red. Ya, that worked out well.
 
I don't think they did a damn thing.
Watch them do the whole thing next time.
You should make it habit to change the thermostat and coolant about every 2 years or so.
 
I'd take it to the service manager then. Along with having them actually do the flush they said they did, try to get some kind of compensation for your hassle, like the bill for service refunded.

-Spike
 
pull it up to the service department, pop the hood and make them explain why there is green coolant in there when you paid and have a receipt showing coolant flush and 2 gallons of red! That's what i would do. Show them a pic of what happens when you mix coolant and ask them if they would cover a motor replacement once the motor blew from gunk buildup because they slacked!
 
When I flushed mine, it had green in it. I decided to stay green because I did not want any mixing and was not sure if I would get everything out. I did get ~ 3.5 gallons out and I believe the system holds 3.75 gallons. I flushed everything except the rear heater (forgot to open it until I was done), but went back and flushed it the next weekend.

I know it is still not much use, but my offer still stands if you can get to Bend. Personally, I would print out e9999's flush walkthrough and go back to the dealer and have them schedule a time when you could supervise and possibly assist with the flushing. They will not want you to be in the service area, but explain to them that if they would have done it right the first time, this would not be required. Do not leave until the vehicle, once at operating temperature, has only red coolant running through, period!

Once again, this all depends on if you have the time to do it and an alternate vehicle to drive in the mean time. Many people on here have driven their "new to them" Land Cruisers for x amount of miles before realizing that they have mixed coolant and that it is bad. Just try to get it done as soon as possible to minimize the sludge.

Riley
 
Given that you already have green in there, and it appears in good condition, I would strongly suggest that you stay with the green for the time being. There is little to no chance the dealer will do a full flush (pull all the plugs, and flush the systems to get it all out of the block and heater cores). The result if you have them switch to the red will be that you have mixed coolant.

What I would do is go and get your money back, it is obvious they didn't do the repair you paid them for, and if they argue with them, simply tell them you are going to report them to the local DA's office for fraud. Then do a drain and fill with the green yourself and keep using that until you have the time and the place to do a complete flush to switch over. It really takes about 20+ gallons of water to fully flush the system, something no dealer is going to be willing to do.

Both Raventai and I have spent a great deal of time researching coolant types (see some of the past threads where we discuss the engineering). While I believe that the red may be better, there is no conclusive proof that it is. You are at far more risk of having problems because of an incomplete flush than because you have continued to use the green changed at a regular interval.
 
The question is, what color is the coolant in the overflow tank. If they followed their own procedure then it should be red. If it's green then they didn't flush or change anything or they refilled with green. some green left in the block and heater would never turn the entire overflow green if it was drained and filled with red!
 
Overflow tank? Ha! It looks like they didn't even look at the overflow tank. It still has dirty coolent in it that's probably a few years old.

All good points from everyone. Thanks. Yep, I'm sure it was never done.
 
I just flushed my system out yesterday and used 2 new gallons of toyota red. After mixing it, I ended up with a little less than one mixed gallon left over. If they charged you for 2 gallons red, once they mixed it, they should of had about one gallon mixed left over after filling up your system also.

Good Luck, and give'm hell
 
Back
Top Bottom