Differential pattern rabbit hole.

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

so now that the last nail is in the coffin and its determined new gears are the next step I disassembled the differential and removed the ring gear. I noticed a few things before I started.
1st. there are "apprentice marks" on the ring gear bolt retainers zuke noticed this as well
2nd. There were some light "apprentice marks" on the carrier
3rd...the ring gear bolts were standard...not metric.

seems to me like someone re-geard this differential once before.
 
2b4e0918-01dc-43fc-8d1f-8a699799a0a0.webp
 
heres a good trick... or at least I thought so. I pinched the carrier in the press to hold it while I undid the ring gear bolts and worked off the ring gear with a brass drift. I used bearing drivers of just the right size to insure all the pressure was on the carrier and not on the bearings.
ba568a09-4bb0-440e-b58f-14b17c67cbd7.jpg
773c459f-245e-4e67-a289-dd21539e2d10.jpg
 
Last edited:
Same bearing separator I use....and I also tuned mine just for those same situations 👍

That ring and pinion is trash

If it isn't to much to ask Id like to hear how you discerned these gears are trash. I have my own opinion of what makes them garbage but it be a good learning tool for myself and anyone else who stumbles onto this thread to hear your play by play I think.
 
Not sure where all you have solicited Opinions...but from your original post, I did not find the responses 'conflicting'.


IMO...you have a worn gear set and it is going to be difficult for us to see enough pattern to determine a bias and give you any meaningful direction.

For what its worth...if you are going to use the worn set....I would be inclined to go with the (Pinion depth shim: 0.0725
Backlash:0.007 ) set up.

It is up to you to decide if you want/need to run the worn gear set for awhile or order new, set them up and be done with it.

If you use the vehicle infrequently....you can probably get away with the current gears, but contact is going be less than ideal between the gears, just be aware.

the conflicting information I have gathered is from various other sources out side of mud. a few defferent mechanics I know personally, a machinist who has set up a good number of differentials in his day, some old farts from my grandfathers car club and also an army of heavy duty mechanics at kenworth. you do make a good point though, the response received in my first post were unanimous
 
True, but used gear patterns is not the place to learn

Heard the term dog chasing his tail, that is exactly what is going on, get new gears or just put it back the way it was and that is all you can do. My son does machine hand scraping and people buy some chinese machine and try to bring it into tolerances of a Moore measuring machine :rolleyes::rolleyes:
 
If it isn't to much to ask Id like to hear how you discerned these gears are trash. I have my own opinion of what makes them garbage but it be a good learning tool for myself and anyone else who stumbles onto this thread to hear your play by play I think.


I am going to guess, that when you did changes and nothing changed in the right direction, and like I said you are just chasing your tail, and no shims are going to revive the lash that is needed, for a proper setting
 
I am going to guess, that when you did changes and nothing changed in the right direction, and like I said you are just chasing your tail, and no shims are going to revive the lash that is needed, for a proper setting

Not really sure were you are coming from here. I spent the time moving the pinion around to see if I could get some sort of an okay pattern out of these gears. It's been determined the gear set isnt going to make an okay pattern so the next step is new gears...seems pretty linear to me. Not much of a going in circles situation at all. Step one determine if what I had was salvageable if not move onto step 2....
 
Last edited:
Not really sure were you are coming from here. I spent the time moving the pinion around to see if I could get some sort of an okay pattern out of these gears. It's been determined the gear set isnt going to make an okay pattern so the next step is new gears...seams pretty linear to me. Not much of a going in circles situation at all. Step one determine if what I had was salvageable if not move onto step 2....

Also I agree with your assessment on how zuk decided the gears are trash, its the same as my own. Pretty easy conclusion to draw. How ever zuk is an absolute master in regards to gears, you never know he might have some gold nugget of information in regards to this gear set that might be valuable in the future to someone else.
 
Yes, time to move on to Step #2 (new gear set). You've made a good effort to see whether or not an acceptable pattern could be had. Used gears (especially those we know have appreciable wear) are difficult to set up anyway. In your case the drive side is so badly worn that I am only 'considering' the pattern there...but actually judging the ring/pinion gear relationship by the coast side pattern. That is why I said I think the best was .0725 @ .007 backlash. But even that was far from ideal.

Another thing when checking patterns on used gear sets is the importance of introducing some resisting force before checking the pattern. With new gears..not much is needed, you can hold the pinion and turn the ring gear. With used/worn gears you might need 30-40 lb. ft. of pressure. In which case I will jam a piece of wood against the ring gear and turn the pinion.

It appears there is a lot of wear on the drive side teeth biased toward the top land. You might also check to see if the pinion and ring gear have matching 'set numbers'. Someone might have put a ring gear in there...not from a matched set. In any case....I don't see what you have now as being a viable gear set if you want reliability. I think you know that as well.

Going to be much easier to start with new.

A little reading (for a primer)...that involves a Dana 60, but the principles are sound and apply to setting up any differential:

 
Yes, time to move on to Step #2 (new gear set). You've made a good effort to see whether or not an acceptable pattern could be had. Used gears (especially those we know have appreciable wear) are difficult to set up anyway. In your case the drive side is so badly worn that I am only 'considering' the pattern there...but actually judging the ring/pinion gear relationship by the coast side pattern. That is why I said I think the best was .0725 @ .007 backlash. But even that was far from ideal.

Another thing when checking patterns on used gear sets is the importance of introducing some resisting force before checking the pattern. With new gears..not much is needed, you can hold the pinion and turn the ring gear. With used/worn gears you might need 30-40 lb. ft. of pressure. In which case I will jam a piece of wood against the ring gear and turn the pinion.

It appears there is a lot of wear on the drive side teeth biased toward the top land. You might also check to see if the pinion and ring gear have matching 'set numbers'. Someone might have put a ring gear in there...not from a matched set. In any case....I don't see what you have now as being a viable gear set if you want reliability. I think you know that as well.

Going to be much easier to start with new.

A little reading (for a primer)...that involves a Dana 60, but the principles are sound and apply to setting up any differential:


you have been a massively help full resource I really appreciate it. In regards to putting resistance on the ring gear it would seam I obviously wasn't putting enough on it. In all the initial photos I posted all the resistance put on the ring gear was by hand, in the later postsI held the pinion flange with a rag, put a wrench on the ring gear bolts and really leaned into it.

I will definitely give not only the thread you recommended a read but also spend some more time on ZUK's website.

for what its worth the pinion reads 8604 250

and the ring gear has a 41 (i think indicating ratio) in a circle. there is also a stray "1" punched in a different spot
WhatsApp Image 2019-08-04 at 12.36.46 PM.webp
WhatsApp Image 2019-08-04 at 12.36.29 PM.webp
WhatsApp Image 2019-08-04 at 12.37.03 PM.webp
WhatsApp Image 2019-08-04 at 12.37.03 PM(1).webp
 
Crusty,
You'll never get a decent pattern out of that used set......it looked like it had a deep ridge near the root of the ring gear....I saw weird hammer marks on the tooth contact surface. That thing was run "out of position" for way too long and the original pattern kinda went away. It will have a whistle or chirping sound if anyone tries to use it.
Nitro is certainly a good one. 😎

ya...that's oem factory gears with the "41"
 
and what do you make of those ring gear bolts? regardless I ordered new bolts with the new ring and pinion just because I didn't want to run the risk of the bolts I pulled out of this differential not being the same as what the nitro ring gear requires
 
and what do you make of those ring gear bolts? regardless I ordered new bolts with the new ring and pinion just because I didn't want to run the risk of the bolts I pulled out of this differential not being the same as what the nitro ring gear requires

You'll always want to use new ring gear bolts, so that was a 'must have' anyway.
 
I'm just curious about what was done to this differential. It has been rebuilt once already I know that much. The threads fit properly in the ring gear. And before the question pops up my 17mm sockets and wrenches are not worn out or damaged
 
Last edited:
I'm just curious about what was done to this differential.

No telling, but you gave it every chance to work for you and just won't. So you are on the right path now.

The money and effort will be worth it.
 
Back
Top Bottom