Diesel Engine Swap Options...?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 19, 2006
Threads
5
Messages
9
Location
East Texas
Hey Guys, just got registered here. Got a '73 FJ40 a few months ago, 350 w/ SM420 (with granny gear) all advance adapters work, 4" reverse shackle w/ 33"s...still working on it. What I'd like to do though is to swap for a diesel and put something with more gears. My dream would be to put a cummins 5.9 in with a 5-speed, granny and 4 up, but from what I can figure its just too heavy and too much torque without doing quite a bit of reinforcing. Eventually I'd like to consider setting up the diesel to run on the cooking oil stuff. Any ideas for diesel swaps that will have a good amount of power that can fit? I really appreciate it guys... Thanks.

-Patrick-

(I'll get pictures up soon)
 
since you already have a 350 you could go to a GM 6.2L diesel engine. they are basicaly a 350 converted to a diesel motor same bolt pattern on the back of the block. but you still have to figure out the electrical 24V instead of 12V system. do a search on the 6.2L chevy diesel it has been covered a bit and you should find some info, good luck!

frank
 
I still like the idea of using a VW 1.9TDI with chip, nozzles, injectors.

Here is my train of thought when using the 1.9TDI with an FJ40.
Not all that sure but I think an FJ40 with top is about 3300lbs stock. If the 2F is 700 lbs, then the FJ40 minus the 2F is about 2600lbs. A turnkey 1.9TDI engine is just under 300 lbs. Placing it into the 40 would bring the weight to about 2900lbs.

Comparitive specs between an 1976 2F and 1.9TDI:
1976 4.2 2F engine
135hp@3600rpm
200ft-lbs@2000rpm

VW 1.9TDI engine
90hp@3750
150ft-lbs@1900

1.9TDI's are rated at 90hp/150ft-lbs at the wheels. Everyone I know that has brought their VW's to get a baseline dyno is almost at 89/90hp and 148/151ft-lbs. So with a decent 20% drivetrain loss that would mean the power at the crank would be about 108hp/180ft-lbs. With an Upsolute chip you are looking at a good 33% linear gain in horsepower and torque. So at the crank its about 143hp/239ft-lbs. Add nozzles and injections its another 30% increase making it about 185-190hp and 310-320ft-lbs reliable power at the crank.

The VW 1.9TDI powerband is very similar to the 2F so I figure gearing is about the same. Plus it revs up like a gasoline engine. Our 2002 Jetta 1.9TDI fully loaded with an automatic transmission weighed in at around 3000lbs.
 
Last edited:
Bennett said:
Someone needs to do a Isuzu 4BD1T from a NPR truck. If you have ever driven an NPR .. you would be sold.

4 clyinder and won't shake your teeth out like a cummins 4bt IMO.

https://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=5378&highlight=isuzu+4bd1
I'm sold, if you've got one lying around I'll put it in my truck. I've driven one of those things. If it pulls that big old box around like that it would be a rippin little engine in a 40. Unfortunatly I am on a budget and they aren't really crowding the junk yards around here.:rolleyes:
 
Awesome guys, I really appreciate the info. I'm checkin around for those motors... this is my first TLC, so I'm lookin forward to getting some dirt on my hands. Thanks again...
 
Make freinds with your local Ryder or Penske commercial rep and they will find you an engine from a damaged truck or possibly one that needs a rebuild for really cheap.

We run the NPR on a 16' box truck here at work at they run forever with hardly any maintencance so long as you don't overheat them. The heads don't like it.


ALF
 
MiniPigg said:
I still like the idea of using a VW 1.9TDI with chip, nozzles, injectors.

Here is my train of thought when using the 1.9TDI with an FJ40.
Not all that sure but I think an FJ40 with top is about 3300lbs stock. If the 2F is 700 lbs, then the FJ40 minus the 2F is about 2600lbs. A turnkey 1.9TDI engine is just under 300 lbs. Placing it into the 40 would bring the weight to about 2900lbs.

Comparitive specs between an 1976 2F and 1.9TDI:
1976 4.2 2F engine
135hp@3600rpm
200ft-lbs@2000rpm

VW 1.9TDI engine
90hp@3750
150ft-lbs@1900

1.9TDI's are rated at 90hp/150ft-lbs at the wheels. Everyone I know that has brought their VW's to get a baseline dyno is almost at 89/90hp and 148/151ft-lbs. So with a decent 20% drivetrain loss that would mean the power at the crank would be about 108hp/180ft-lbs. With an Upsolute chip you are looking at a good 33% linear gain in horsepower and torque. So at the crank its about 143hp/239ft-lbs. Add nozzles and injections its another 30% increase making it about 185-190hp and 310-320ft-lbs reliable power at the crank.

The VW 1.9TDI powerband is very similar to the 2F so I figure gearing is about the same. Plus it revs up like a gasoline engine. Our 2002 Jetta 1.9TDI fully loaded with an automatic transmission weighed in at around 3000lbs.

I think a FJ40 with a top would weigh much more than 3300 lbs. While 1.9L TDI motors are good for a Jetta or beetle, I don't think it will do well for an FJ40. The torque does not come on until about 2500 rpms on my 06 Jetta (rated for 177 ft/lbs of torque). Also, many have suggested that the bottom end on the TDI is not capable of more than 200HP with a ECU reprogram and injectors. It would be very difficult to convert/mount a tranny for a 4 wheel drive. Jettas are front wheel drive with CV shafts.

One more thing, you would have to plumb a intercooler and get a larger turbo at the hp you suggest. VNT15/17 turbos suck for reliablity. I'm glad my 06 does not have a VNT turbo.

I think a 1.9TDI engine would be a good option on a tube chassis rig if you could find a adapter to mount a 4x4 transmission to 1.9L TDI.
 
Last edited:
fj40charles said:
I think a FJ40 with a top would weigh much more than 3300 lbs. While 1.9L TDI motors are good for a Jetta or beetle, I don't think it will do well for an FJ40. The torque does not come on until about 2500 rpms on my 06 Jetta (rated for 177 ft/lbs of torque). Also, many have suggested that the bottom end on the TDI is not capable of more than 200HP with a ECU reprogram and injectors. It would be very difficult to convert/mount a tranny for a 4 wheel drive. Jettas are front wheel drive with CV shafts.

One more thing, you would have to plumb a intercooler and get a larger turbo at the hp you suggest. VNT15/17 turbos suck for reliablity. I'm glad my 06 does not have a VNT turbo.

I think a 1.9TDI engine would be a good option on a tube chassis rig if you could find a adapter to mount a 4x4 transmission to 1.9L TDI.

Not sure on the actuall weight of an FJ40 with a hardtop. Was just using information provided and it doesnt state vert or hardtop. I do know my old FJ55 with mods was weighed in at 4200 pounds on the scales both times it was weighed while in the military. Folks thought the FJ55 weighed a lot more. As did I until I got mine weighed. The key thing to find out is the actual weight of a complete turnkey 2F engine.Thats a huge amount of weight when compared to the TDI engine. Even a 4BT or 3B or 3B-AXT.

Like the conversion of the Samurai with a VW diesel... you make an adapter to mate the engine to the 5speed and then machine the flywheel and mate the ring gear. Yes other things are done as well. You do not use the VW/AUDI transmissions. Yes they are front wheel drive. I was raised on the racetrack. I owned my first watercooled VW in 1981 and my dad helped me modify it for racing. Engine took a hell of a beating and was running when I sold it. I also loved driving our 2002 Jetta 1.9TDI with auto. It was my wifes' car but I drove it often. Really fun car to drive and had excellent acceleration (just like a gasser). Ive raced it a few times and became very impressed with its performace. I shouldnt advocate street racing but I can say a number of times when up against mildly moded honda's, acuras etc.... the TDI pulled ahead and won. One of the guys I worked with had a new Golf 2.0 5speed. We would race to work at times when there were barely any cars on the highway. I would allow him to catch up at times and then leave him. No issues when fully loaded and driving in Cascades in Washington State. Vehicle still pulled well and got excellent fuel economy. Still over 50mpg loaded down with 5 people and weekend gear.

I know a number of people that have dyno'd their TDI's to 300ft-lbs. The only complaints we have seen associated with lower ends are the clutches. The torque kills a factory clutch in a short period of time. I havent seen any issues with cranks or rods. I think many people have issues when they hear Volkswagen and Fullsized 4x4's used in the same sentence. Maybe its not manly enough for them... not sure. There were some arguements about using the TDI in Sidekicks as some zuk people thought the sidekick was to dam heavy. A mid to late 1990's 4door sidekick has a curb weight between 2800-3000lbs. Im sure they think a newer VW jetta or golf is 2000lbs or something.

In a modified TDI Usable torque appears around 1500rpm ( 140ish) and then hits 200ft-lbs at 2000rpm and peaks out around 2500rpm. Im not interested in running a stock TDI. The power band is different. Also have seen several turbo'd 4x4's with intercoolers. To me its not an issue.

I should have made it more clear as to what I was actually comparing the TDI. A 3B with AXT or even a 4BT. You get a better power to weight ratio and longevity with the TDI or even a TD using a mechanical pump. A VW diesel weighs a fraction of what a B series diesel does. AXT's site shows the dyno of a 3BAXT. I am positive they are bolting the engine to a dyno rather then getting it at the wheels. The numbers I have for the TDI are at the wheels. I still think it would make a good swap. Or you coupld find a 2.0TDI or larger TDI from overseas. Im currently talking to a guy in Germany about a 1.2TDI for 300USD. I intend on using this diesel in my LJ20.
 
There are two times where I have really had my 4BT tweaked up and running really well and pretty darn powerfully. Right now (but still pretty damn quiet) and one time I had so much power going through it was not even funny but it was pretty damn loud. It is slightly loud but not bone jarring in my opinion at all... Sounds like a 91' Dodge Cummins, too to bad at all :) One time I really had it cranked though and 1) It is not even funny how powerful it was (got pulled over going 83 uphill on a 5 mile steel uphill freeway grade) but 2) that was in fact bone jarring. Sounded like the loudest Dodge 24 valve you've ever heard. But that was really cranked. I think you can get 160 hp (400 ft/lbs - same as a stock 6BT in early Dodges) out of it pretty easily and not be too bad at all...
 
Txram99 said:
Hey Guys, just got registered here. Got a '73 FJ40 a few months ago, 350 w/ SM420 (with granny gear) all advance adapters work, 4" reverse shackle w/ 33"s...still working on it. What I'd like to do though is to swap for a diesel and put something with more gears. My dream would be to put a cummins 5.9 in with a 5-speed, granny and 4 up, but from what I can figure its just too heavy and too much torque without doing quite a bit of reinforcing. Eventually I'd like to consider setting up the diesel to run on the cooking oil stuff. Any ideas for diesel swaps that will have a good amount of power that can fit? I really appreciate it guys... Thanks.

-Patrick-

(I'll get pictures up soon)

Congrats on the rig.

13BT+H55F? If you want more power, maybe a 1HD-T etc... All Toyota... www.gscruiserparts.com

B
 
I am surprised in this diesel engine discussions that nobody mentions the engine found in Mercedes Sprinter Vans. I have been in these vans and the engines seem quite. Obviously they are truck engines so should have lots of low end torque. The Sprinter vans get 22-25 mpg which would be a miracle in a gas-powered cruiser.
 
Exiled said:
Unless a 4BT has been tweaked, the noise/vibration is not bad at all.


:confused:



compared to...say.....a JACKHAMMER?





Have spent pleanty of time operating equipment powered by and working on the 4bt....



To each their own.




:beer:
 
rgentry said:
I am surprised in this diesel engine discussions that nobody mentions the engine found in Mercedes Sprinter Vans. I have been in these vans and the engines seem quite. Obviously they are truck engines so should have lots of low end torque. The Sprinter vans get 22-25 mpg which would be a miracle in a gas-powered cruiser.




Where is your money tree? ;)


10K+ for that engine complete is what I have been quoted....and that is just the engine...no tranny.





:beer:
 
Poser said:
Where is your money tree? ;)


10K+ for that engine complete is what I have been quoted....and that is just the engine...no tranny.

Damn. I have seen the sprinter vans for sale for around $18,000 used. Poser, you are great mechanic so here's the challenge. Make a kit to transplant a 2F engine into the sprinter van. Sell the "upgraded" sprinter van as having a time-tested Toyota engine instead of the noisy diesel. Cost of the upgrade, $10K. Put the Sprinter diesels into Landcruisers, charging us guys $10K for the swap. Now we're talking money tree.
 
lone gunman said:
since you already have a 350 you could go to a GM 6.2L diesel engine. they are basicaly a 350 converted to a diesel motor same bolt pattern on the back of the block. but you still have to figure out the electrical 24V instead of 12V system. do a search on the 6.2L chevy diesel it has been covered a bit and you should find some info, good luck!

frank

A quarter century after they were first released and people STILL think that a from-scratch Detroit Diesel big block diesel is a converted small block chevy. The only thing those engines have in common is the rigs they went into and the bellhousing bolt pattern.

The 350 that was converted into a diesel wasn't even a chevy, and wouldn't have bolted to a chevy transmission.

Back to the original topic, the diesel in the heep liberty looks like it'd be a good swap.

Edit: When my 2F was first built and not-totally-tuned, it was running super lean with the timing very advanced, getting 22mpg.
 
Back
Top Bottom