Chronically loose wheel bearing?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
May 7, 2005
Threads
303
Messages
2,353
Location
South Jordan, UT
Checking front wheels for loose bearings today, got a very slight wiggle out of the left front at 12 and 6 o'clock.

No big deal, but this is the third time in the last year I've encountered loose bearings on this wheel.

-I replaced the bearings a little under two years ago when I repacked knuckles and also replaced the trunion bearings.

-Each time I found a bit of play in the front wheel, I popped off the flange and tightened up the hub nuts a bit. No more play.

Three times on the front left, once on the right, over a one year period.

My questions:

1. Am I finding my wheel bearings loose often enough to be concerned?

2. Can anyone quantify "how much play" one typically finds with a loose wheel bearing?


Maybe I just didn't to a very good job seating the races in that wheel?
Maybe this is not abnormal anyway?
Maybe I have a problem with my trunion bearings?

What do you folks think?

Thanks.

Hayes
 
Are you certain you are seating the outer nut against the star washer/inner nut per the FSM torque and benting the star tabs over both nuts? It is not uncommon for them to loosen, but it sounds like yours are doing so excessively. How many miles are you driving before they loosen up? I have 25,000 on my driver's side since they were set and they are still tight. The PS I had to tighten after 5,000 because I did not bend the tabs...:whoops: They have not gone lose in the past 20,000 miles.
 
Well, the standard preload procedure didn't work for me, so I just followed the torque specs as much as I could and snugged 'em up--with no obvious signs of overheating or initially loose bearings.
But...my torque wrench is a P.O.S. and my experience with tightening 80 hubs by feel is nonexistent. I guess it is entirely possible that I just haven't tightened them enough--although there is initially no play.

I folded the star washer, but I'm not certain it folds over both nuts--I thought it just locked the outer nut...

Hayes
 
it is kind of hard to duplicate the force that an 80 has on it's wheel bearings with your biceps. Because you didn't feel any movement doesn't mean there wasn't any there.

You might try my method of torqueing the inner nut to 10 ftlbs, rotate the wheel a few times and the retorque to 10 ftlbs, repeat until little to no retorqueing after wheel rotation is needed. Then torque the outer nut to 43 ftlbs and bent the locking tabs over.

This has worked for me for quite a few miles now on two LCs.
 
You need to fold tabs over both nuts...that keeps all three pieces locked together.
 
Hayes said:
I folded the star washer, but I'm not certain it folds over both nuts--I thought it just locked the outer nut...

Hayes


Therein lies your problem. Once the outer nut is torqued you need to bend one tab over on the inner nut and one tab over on the outer nut.
 
Big nuts

Well, that's an easy fix...

I figured the outer nut locked the inner nut, and the washer locked the outer nut. Guess that's what I get for figuring...:o

Thanks for illuminating the dim regions of my brain.

Hayes
 
landtank said:
A locked outer nut still won't allow the inner nut to back off.

I must beg to differ....if you just wrap the star washer tabs around the outer nut basically that allows the inner to loose tension & slowly back away putting all force on the outer nut.

Try locking tabs over both inner & outer nuts then recheck.
 
Now that I think through this a little more, I'm not certain I DIDN'T fold the washer around both nuts.
s***e. My memory is failing quicker than [insert auto of choice here].
I'll check it out and torque things tomorrow morning.

Hayes
 
Clutchee said:
I must beg to differ....


Go right ahead, I just don't see much room for the inner nut to back out against a locked nut that has been torqued to 45 ftlbs against it.

My math might be off but I think you would need to apply more than 45 ftlbs to that inner nut before it would move. That inner nut rests against a keyed washer which has minimal rotation movement so I'm not sure where that kind of force is coming from.

One area that might be of some problem is if he's reusing the lock washer. Putting in a used washer, regardless of how flat you think it is, will create some space between the nuts that will get pounded out by driving the truck and allow the nuts to become loose. This is especially true if the inner nut isn't locked and that nut is completely free to rotate. As that washer gets flatter and flatter the nut continues to turn and loosen.
 
Hayes said:
Now that I think through this a little more, I'm not certain I DIDN'T fold the washer around both nuts.
s***e. My memory is failing quicker than [insert auto of choice here].
I'll check it out and torque things tomorrow morning.

Hayes


Please also report back to this thread either way so we know whether the unlocked inner nut may or may not have had a role. Thanks. :cheers:

I can see both sides of the argument about whether or not the unlocked inner nut might matter.

Another thing to think through is do you lock the inner washer before torquing the outer washer or after torquing the outer washer. I torqued the inner, then locked the inner, then torqued the outer, then locked the outer. Hmmm???
 
Last edited:
I'm sidin' with Landtank on this. A jack nut torqued to 43 ft pounds isn't moving. Plus, that star washer has a tab that's sitting inside that broached slot of the spindle. So it doesn't spin, and so the only movement allowable by Hayes forgetting to bend the nut over on the innner nut is the whole mess getting tighter. And that ain't happening either.


I think you didn't seat your races enough (did you use a press or a drift?) or you've got worn bearings and/or spindles. Or your spindles have a little worn spot from a moderately loose bearing, so the wear surfaces have, well, worn.
 
Another possibility is a locktab washer with a damaged or missing inner "key" or a worn slot in the spindle where the key indexes.
 
Races were seated with a brass drift.
It was my first time ever pounding on a bearing race, so I wouldn't be surprised if I didn't get it just right. I did the driver's side first, then the passenger--so maybe I did it better the second time--and that's why my right side has stayed tight.

The tabbed washer was replaced during the service, and I know the "key" is fully functional.

Never seen what a worn spindle looks like, but I don't recall seeing anything that looked "worn" when I had it all torn apart.

Turbocruiser, now you've got me really questioning my recall of the whole thing. I don't think there is another tabbed washer between the two nuts--or am I misinterpreting?

Happy to see that I'm not the only one who presumed that the outer nut locks the inner one...
 
Hayes said:
Races were seated with a brass drift.
It was my first time ever pounding on a bearing race, so I wouldn't be surprised if I didn't get it just right. I did the driver's side first, then the passenger--so maybe I did it better the second time--and that's why my right side has stayed tight.

The tabbed washer was replaced during the service, and I know the "key" is fully functional.

Never seen what a worn spindle looks like, but I don't recall seeing anything that looked "worn" when I had it all torn apart.

Turbocruiser, now you've got me really questioning my recall of the whole thing. I don't think there is another tabbed washer between the two nuts--or am I misinterpreting?

Happy to see that I'm not the only one who presumed that the outer nut locks the inner one...


Some thoughts in the hope they help ...

It is easy to completely confirm that the races are really seated by simply flipping the hub over and looking at the bottom of the race and the top of the seat - they should sit super snugly together around all the circumference of the race and the seat. One of those little tiny inspection thingy mirrors can make it even easier to confirm.

No, I'm not saying there's two lock washers just that the one lock washer has many tabs and you should bend one of the tabs down to lock the inner nut and another one of the tabs up to lock the outer nut. If yer lucky like I always am you'll get one tab in particular that is perfectly parallel to one face of the inner nut, and then you'll get one tab in particular that is perfectly parallel to one face of the outer nut. Try to pick those parallel tabs if possible; if you pick a tab that is at an angle to the face of the nut that you are locking onto it is indeed possible to "torque" that nut a little tight or a little loose as you force the tab to touch the face of the nut. It is easier than it sounds, but again, no i'm not saying there's two lock washers, sorry for causing that confusion. HTH. :cheers:
 
OK.

Re-torqued my hub nuts this morning.
Popped off the flange and realized how distorted my recall of the nut-washer assembly was. Somehow I had a vision of the tabbed washer being on the top of both nuts--which doesn't really make any sense at all. Hopefully I haven't come across as too large an idiot in this thread ;p

Anyway...
I only had one tab folded up to the outer nut--as suspected. I don't think it is reasonable to conclude that this is the reason for the loose bearing--I did the other side the same way (no, I didn't check, but I'm SURE)--and I just can't see how the inner nut could back off even 0.0001 degree with the outer nut torqued down and locked.

After applying the torque wrench (10 lbs inner, 45 outer, but the piece of s***e reads 10 lb*ft with zero applied torque :rolleyes: ) I got the impression that I didn't do quite enough work on either nut when I did it without the torque wrench, last time.

My unqualified conclusion is that the tabbed washer dosen't have anything to do with the chronic slack, rather, I probably didn't get the bearing race(s) fully seated when I replaced the bearings two years ago.
In all likelyhood, I'll be torquing the nuts again in a few months.

Thanks again for the discussion.

Hayes
 
Hayes,
If it's been 2 years since the birf job you should be doing wheel bearings anyway. I think Toyota recommends wheel bearing repacks at 30k miles.

-B-
 
Beowulf said:
Hayes,
If it's been 2 years since the birf job you should be doing wheel bearings anyway. I think Toyota recommends wheel bearing repacks at 30k miles.

-B-

Yeah, a bearing/birf repack has been creeping up in my consciousness lately. Need to do the rear bearings too (not done since the 80's been mine)...

Hayes
 
Back
Top Bottom