BG Oil

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 9, 2006
Threads
101
Messages
513
Location
Alpharetta GA
Hey guys, has anyone tried BG motor oil? My rep came by today and they make a 0w 30 full synthetic he says is better than everything else out there. They have "tested it" against m1 and everything else and it supposedly outlasted all of them on a bench test. They recommend changing the filter every 8k miles with it and then changing the oil every 15k. I have always been a m1 fan but he said he would give me the oil for free to try out. What do you think?
 
Try it out!!

Be the guinnea pig for us. Chart all your findings, MPG, oil temp, engine temp, etc., document everything and tell us what you think.

I would be very skeptical of 15K mile oil changes.
 
Ask him the following:

1) How exactly was it "bench tested"?
2) What Group of Basestock's does BG use for their "sythetic"?
3) How do they come up with their proposed interval?
4) Is the oil API rated? Is is ACEA approved A5 or A3 (and if so which one)? Is it approved as BMW LL-01 or LL-04, MB 229.5, Porsche OE, or and of the VW standards?

I'm going guess the answers to above are I don't know and no. Stick with oils developed by companies that have a lot of experience like Mobil, Shell, Chevron, etc.
 
Try it out!!

Be the guinnea pig for us. Chart all your findings, MPG, oil temp, engine temp, etc., document everything and tell us what you think.

I would be very skeptical of 15K mile oil changes.


None of that tells us how well the oil is performing. You need to perform a UOA against other oils in the same engine to establish if an oil is performing better by lessening wear.
 
I wouldn't use a zero weight oil either. Unless I was in like the Anarctica. 10w30 is a good range for a used DOHC motor. You go too thin on the oil and the motor will burn it.:eek:
 
I wouldn't use a zero weight oil either. Unless I was in like the Anarctica. 10w30 is a good range for a used DOHC motor. You go too thin on the oil and the motor will burn it.:eek:


Well its a good thing he's not using a 0 weight oil. He is talking about a 30 weight oil, same as your recommendation for a 10w-30. BTW, how do you come up with your cart blanc recommendation of a 30 weight oil for a DOHC motor? Does that mean I should be using it in my old Mercedes M110 DOHC engine? What about a BMW M42 engine?
 
I wouldn't use a zero weight oil either. Unless I was in like the Anarctica. 10w30 is a good range for a used DOHC motor. You go too thin on the oil and the motor will burn it.:eek:

Uhm friendly word of advice: do a little research before jumping in and making statements which could be construed in an unfavorable light. There is a ton of info on oil in the FAQ and it makes for a really good read.

Well its a good thing he's not using a 0 weight oil. He is talking about a 30 weight oil, same as your recommendation for a 10w-30. BTW, how do you come up with your cart blanc recommendation of a 30 weight oil for a DOHC motor? Does that mean I should be using it in my old Mercedes M110 DOHC engine? What about a BMW M42 engine?

I think I just said the same thing above albeit in a slightly nicer manner. Most of the oil info found in the FAQ is research done by Cary who has been kind enough to provide his expertise and personal research time to the rest of the board. There are some pretty smart fella's here and I as have learned it always pays to learn from ones elders, alot of whom have already done your homework for you and are actually providing you with the answers to the test. Just 02.
 
Ummm, just to respond to the last post. I'm a mechanic for a living and have probably done a few thousand oil changes. There is nothing out there that calls for a zero weight oil in the owners manual except the newer cars. Right now the late model Fords are 5w20. The late model Gms are 5w30. Now everything DOHC for the most part is 10w30. As I mentioned "good range" Did you know that Ford posted a bulletin on the Triton motors that if you consistently run anything heavier than 10w30 that they would not be responsible for failed oil pumps. Anyway,the only time I see a zero weight spec'ed is for severe climates.
 
Ummm, just to respond to the last post. I'm a mechanic for a living and have probably done a few thousand oil changes. There is nothing out there that calls for a zero weight oil in the owners manual except the newer cars. Right now the late model Fords are 5w20. The late model Gms are 5w30. Now everything DOHC for the most part is 10w30. As I mentioned "good range" Did you know that Ford posted a bulletin on the Triton motors that if you consistently run anything heavier than 10w30 that they would not be responsible for failed oil pumps. Anyway,the only time I see a zero weight spec'ed is for severe climates.

Glad your a mechanic, but you don't know squat about oil. The first number in a multi weight oil refers to what cold start pumpability test it meets and has nothing to do with its thickness at operating temperature (usually considered to be 100c). The second number denotes an oil's thickness in centestokes at 100c. Whether an oil is 0w-30, 5w-30, 10w-30 or straight 30 weight, it must be between 9.2 and 12.5 centestokes in thickness at 100c in order to be labled as a 30 weight. A 0w-30 oil is no more a "0 weight" oil than is 20w-50. Once again, thanks for playing, now perhaps would be a good time to read the FAQ.
 
I tried cary.......................

Do you not even have a Land Cruiser any more? :confused: I go build a house for 6 months and come back what happened?

Oh carry on Cary...:popcorn:
 
I tried too....

Are you reading, and if the answer to that is yes are you comprehending?

Do you not even have a Land Cruiser any more? :confused: I go build a house for 6 months and come back what happened?

Now I'm confused I am the one who just built a house.

And as far as owning a Landcruiser..................:flipoff2:

300 dyno'd horses of 80 baby.:cool:

So eat your heart out.:grinpimp:
 
Do you not even have a Land Cruiser any more? :confused: I go build a house for 6 months and come back what happened?

Oh carry on Cary...:popcorn:


I hope I have a cruiser. If not some prick stole it since I parked it in the parking structure here are the office about 45 minutes ago.

Shoot, now I have to go google 'centestokes'...

Hah! It's 'centistokes' ! http://www.sizes.com/units/centistokes.htm

Does that make me smarter than cary? ;)

You should know, everyone is smarter than me. I'm an idiot savant, I know about oil, lights, and a few other things. Other than that I can barely tie my shoes, hence the reason Woody stuck me with the "Velcro Shoes" as part of my user profile a few years ago. Fortunately, he seems to have deleted it and forgotten about it.
 
I downloaded the recommendations by the American Petroleum Institute for you guys and couldn't find any zero weight oil in the specs. You'll see that 10w30 is spec'd for temps from 0F to 100+F. And again,thanks for playing.
API.webp
 
I downloaded the recommendations by the American Petroleum Institute for you guys and couldn't find any zero weight oil in the specs. You'll see that 10w30 is spec'd for temps from 0F to 100+F. And again,thanks for playing.


Keep digging. The API does not specify what weight oils should be used in an engine (notice the word typical, and the specific language that says "follow your vehicle manufacturer's recommendations on SAE oil viscosity grades" in big bold letters), that is done by the individual manufactures. BTW, the API is the minimal standard for oils. If you want to start looking at some real standards, check out ACEA, MB 229.xx, BMW LL, Porsche OE, etc.
 
Now I'm confused I am the one who just built a house.

And as far as owning a Landcruiser..................:flipoff2:

300 dyno'd horses of 80 baby.:cool:

So eat your heart out.:grinpimp:


No I just built a house...weird eh? Oh ok...thought you used to have it listed in your sig line and now it is blank...except for the good Mr. Eastwood.


Cary...that was purely directed at Reffug.


I hope no one tells the oil manufactures that the API doesn't call for "0 weight" :rolleyes: oil...they might stop making it.
 
Back
Top Bottom