I am going to take the fifth from the start and say IMHO! I find that a slider does two things. It protects while reducing ground clearance. You want strong protection with minimal clearance issues. I will choose the one that is strong but is as slim as possible. It should hug the rocker tightly. It should have an outrigger that is high on the rocker, but wide enough to push most obstacles away from the rear wheel. It needs to be solidly mounted, not just a step. If it is useful as a step, it usually hangs out too far and too low to provide clearance. If you need a step, get a step stool! They are sold at a low price at Walmart. I have one in my truck.
There are two kinds of metal applied to the area under the doors. One is a real "rocker bumper" and the other is a running board. The running board has no place on the trail. It will be torn off. A slider is for sliding against rocks or trees. It is not a step.
I have looked at all of the sliders on the market. I prefer to build my own.