I've used Durabak, Duplicolor (not on your poll) and Herculiner
Durabak -
1. sprayed my 40 - vowed to never spray again it's a mess.
2 The sides of the top and the rear doors I brushed, with much better results. The only issue I ran into was I did some touch up too close to going off road, and the okie mud stained it - didn't have that problem on first coat - and by too close I mean hours, not days.
3. The sides of the 80. Ordered Sand, got Tan, which wasn't really tan it was the old tan which was buttersctoch - blah blah blah. Rollered it with good effect. Was surprised ti took two quarts to really coat one side. Ordered up a gallon of Dark Grey to do other side and over up baby poop tan. Trying to cover another color of Durabak is tough. I think it's the texture that makes it so tough to cover - as my 40 was yellow, and a few other colors, and all came out solid blue. Still have a quart the origonal vendor gave me to cover baby poop, so I'll come back with another coat at some time, and probably pick up another gallon to do the bumpers and sliders to match.
Duplicolor -
1. I got the stuff in the can once to use on the very top of 40. It has pretty much no texture to it, doesn't cover well, and didn't feel it was going to hold up. Didn't have it on long enough before selling to determine for sure if it was going to hold up.
2. Spray - I use the duplicolor bedliner in a spray paint can all the time. I use it like I would black paint or undercoating. My shock tower extensions are done in this. Again, not much texture, it reminds me more of rubberized undercoating that dries harder.
Herculiner -
1. I had a quart I was going to use on my sliders, and ended up using it on my front bumper to cover baby poop color. It's got more texture to it than Duplicolor - but I did already have alot of texture from the Duraback on most surfaces. I'd use it again if I had something that I wanted black. If you go to their site I believe you can get it in various colors.
U-pol -
maybe I'll try it next time....
As far as prep being the most important thing, if you're using textured bedliner, it's not as important as you might think. I actually wish I'd saved some of my time on getting stuff right on the 40 and just linered it - it's great at covering up flaws. The 80 I did what most do and used metal tape to cover flare holes. If it can hide that, it'll hide alot. It's not like paint where everything will show through, you just keep adding more till it looks right!
The one idea that I used from this forum that I regret using is the electrical tape for masking. The idea seemed good, cause it does bend easier around curves, but it really lifted on me durring coating and I had some nasty stuff to clean up because of it. In the future I'll stick with painters tape and just take the time to make the curves.
Hope that helps.