Best ROLL ON Liner

ROLL ON LINER

  • Herculiner

    Votes: 6 22.2%
  • Rhinoliner

    Votes: 4 14.8%
  • Durabak

    Votes: 12 44.4%
  • Upol

    Votes: 5 18.5%

  • Total voters
    27

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 2, 2006
Threads
20
Messages
928
Location
Breckenridge, CO
I HAVE ALREADY SEARCHED. :flipoff2:I am planning on lining my flares, and will be rolling the liner on. I have searched old threads and read many opinions. I know the three most important things are 1. prep, 2. prep, and 3. prep. For those of you who used more than one roll on liner which did you like best. If you haven't used more that one liner, what type did you use and did you like it?
 
Rolling on liners look like snot and are not uniform in texture, even when the most meticulous painter does it.

By an $80 compressor, $20 water separator, and $10 inline desiccant container. The U-Pol spray makes the other brands look like sand paper. Not to mention you'll have a compressor to run air tools.
 
Last edited:
I've used Durabak, Duplicolor (not on your poll) and Herculiner

Durabak -

1. sprayed my 40 - vowed to never spray again it's a mess.

2 The sides of the top and the rear doors I brushed, with much better results. The only issue I ran into was I did some touch up too close to going off road, and the okie mud stained it - didn't have that problem on first coat - and by too close I mean hours, not days.

3. The sides of the 80. Ordered Sand, got Tan, which wasn't really tan it was the old tan which was buttersctoch - blah blah blah. Rollered it with good effect. Was surprised ti took two quarts to really coat one side. Ordered up a gallon of Dark Grey to do other side and over up baby poop tan. Trying to cover another color of Durabak is tough. I think it's the texture that makes it so tough to cover - as my 40 was yellow, and a few other colors, and all came out solid blue. Still have a quart the origonal vendor gave me to cover baby poop, so I'll come back with another coat at some time, and probably pick up another gallon to do the bumpers and sliders to match.

Duplicolor -

1. I got the stuff in the can once to use on the very top of 40. It has pretty much no texture to it, doesn't cover well, and didn't feel it was going to hold up. Didn't have it on long enough before selling to determine for sure if it was going to hold up.

2. Spray - I use the duplicolor bedliner in a spray paint can all the time. I use it like I would black paint or undercoating. My shock tower extensions are done in this. Again, not much texture, it reminds me more of rubberized undercoating that dries harder.

Herculiner -

1. I had a quart I was going to use on my sliders, and ended up using it on my front bumper to cover baby poop color. It's got more texture to it than Duplicolor - but I did already have alot of texture from the Duraback on most surfaces. I'd use it again if I had something that I wanted black. If you go to their site I believe you can get it in various colors.

U-pol -

maybe I'll try it next time....


As far as prep being the most important thing, if you're using textured bedliner, it's not as important as you might think. I actually wish I'd saved some of my time on getting stuff right on the 40 and just linered it - it's great at covering up flaws. The 80 I did what most do and used metal tape to cover flare holes. If it can hide that, it'll hide alot. It's not like paint where everything will show through, you just keep adding more till it looks right!

The one idea that I used from this forum that I regret using is the electrical tape for masking. The idea seemed good, cause it does bend easier around curves, but it really lifted on me durring coating and I had some nasty stuff to clean up because of it. In the future I'll stick with painters tape and just take the time to make the curves.

Hope that helps.
 
I Herculined much of my old 4Runner. It is tough stuff but it is impossible to get the right texture out of it and is really scratchy stuff to touch. I suggest Line-X - pay them to do the thing right. JMHO. :cheers:
 
Rolling on liners look like snot and are not uniform in texture, even when the most meticulous painter does it.

By an $80 compressor, $20 water separator, and $10 inline desiccant container. The U-Pol spray makes the other brands look like sand paper. Not to mention you'll have a compressor to run air tools.
I live in a condo, and don't have a garage, that's the reason I'm planning on going with roll on. Many of the old threads I looked at looked pretty good for being rolled on. Thanks for the input.
 
pictures lie! look at the current thread about trying a 2" spacer or "J" springs. There are a few shots of my wagon, the flares look NOTHING like they do in person. Also I've seen enough rolled on liner in person, they don't look anything close to stuff that is sprayed.

I'm sure you could find a club member that wouldn't mind you useing their garage for 1/2 a day. It is well worth your time but if nothing else have a pro spray line-x or rhino.
 
Last edited:
Rolled on Durabak to my flares and roof where the factory rack had been. I'm very picky and think it turned out great.

You must have read my thread about the prep work. :D
 
If you are just using black, it went on much easier for my buddy who used Herculiner compared to my Durabak. But I feel that the Durabak is a bit thicker. And for doing flares, I like what LandCrusher'70 used because it's almost like plastic and smooth to the touch.
 
I used Herculiner and I think it came out fantastic. I think the trick of course is in the details and the time, effort, energy and patience you put into it. I prepped everything in a meticulous manner, used three lines of tape (so I could pull of a line after each coat), used a drill to constantly stir up the liner, and used several rollers to apply it. I have seen many spray on applications and personally had a hard time deciding to do it myself or go the Line-X route. In the end I chose to do it myself because of the old saying "if you want it done right you have to do it yourself". I know the amount of prep-work I put into it could not have been matched by Line-X or anyone else. Opinions do vary and again...to each their own. I think the Herculiner is a great product and it seems to be extremly strong and durable.
 
i did hurculiner on the interior of my 40 (rolled) looked great right afterwards and was durable however it was very ruff texture. after using it for a few years it got dirty easily and you could never fully get it back to the original luster especially when the sun gets to it. I want to do the flares on my truck and will go the line-x route drop by there shop and see if they will cut you a deal some will allow you to pull the flares do the prep yourself and drop them off at a much cheaper price sinch they dont have to tape anything.

just a thought
 
True, but you cannont deny that when the liners are sprayed it looks better than ones rolled.

Sure I can - see my first post.

Spraying it was very difficult for me. I even had the truck torn apart to make it easier.

1. You'll never get a $80 compressor to keep up with the air draw for spraying - the guns are basically a sand blasting gun w/o the ceramic, so they flow major air.

2. Spraying is easy to stay in one spot too long and get a clump or bump in the surface.

3. The mess is 10 times as bad.

Part of it may be the experience level of the person applying it as well. I've never painted a car. But I've rollered and brushed plenty of paint on houses. Maybe if I was doing flares off the vehicle, and not covering where I removed the flares, I'd be willing to try spraying again. The overspray from doing the flare removal area though would have been horrid, or required 10 times the work to cover everything.

So I guess what I'm saying is a bad spray job is probably worse than a good roller job, and a bad roller job is probably worse than a good spray job, so figure out which you are capable of doing - good roller, or good spray.

And you gotta figure what the end use is too. Is it worth that much more to invest in the spraying gun and air compressor, or to pay the several hundred Rhino or Line-x seem to want to do it professionally? Am I going to show my truck, or does my truck already have so many scratches in the remaining paint that the lowers look 100 times better than the top anyway?
 
Last edited:
1. You'll never get a $80 compressor to keep up with the air draw for spraying - the guns are basically a sand blasting gun w/o the ceramic, so they flow major air.

2. Spraying is easy to stay in one spot too long and get a clump or bump in the surface.

3. The mess is 10 times as bad.

Part of it may be the experience level of the person applying it as well. I've never painted a car. But I've rollered and brushed plenty of paint on houses. Maybe if I was doing flares off the vehicle, and not covering where I removed the flares, I'd be willing to try spraying again. The overspray from doing the flare removal area though would have been horrid, or required 10 times the work to cover everything.

1. A 3 or 4 gallon tanked compressor is plently adaqute for the gun that comes with the U-Pol kit -- my tank is only 4 gallons and the compressor didn't have to run as much as I thought it would. Now a HVHP gun is not going to work with a tank that small.

2. Obiviously you shouldn't assume this. Yes experience in using spray helps but a few minutes on a pratice pice is fine. Also I've found the liner spray works better in long full length passes, not the broad stroks used in paints.

3. :rolleyes: speak for your self, plastic drop cloths are cheap and unless your a completely lazy douch it's cake to tape the floor off.

Your opinion might be that the quality of the job doesn't matter since the use will most likely damage the finish. However, I think ANYTHING you attempt to do should be a top notch job, regardless how it will be used.
 
Thanks for all of the replies, anyone else have an opinion ?

I planned to go with the U-pol for my flares because I thought I wanted a very low texture similar to the snorkel. I ended up using Herculiner after getting some “leftovers” from someone doing a bedliner. It was very difficult to keep it from clumping and as a result I have a very course texture.:crybaby: At first I was disappointed but I think it will be far easier to fix any damage that might occur than if I had a more “attractive” finish. I'm the only one that seems to notice how rough it is (except for the poor soul that rubs it accidently ;) )

If you come down out of the hills PM me and you can take a peek.:D

 
I have used Herculiner on all of rigs and like it really well. Just don't take a leak without washing your hands. Your lady will enjoy the extra texture for about a month. I know from experience about the first part, just bs'ing about the second!!!:doh:
 
I don't have much experience with roll on liners other than Herculiner. I've used it inside the tub of my 40 and the rear cargo area of my Suburban. It was very easy to apply. Pretty tough stuff and very rough. It actually has chunks of rubber in it. I've thrown concrete blocks in the back of the Sub. Some small scrapes/rips, but nothing major.

FWIW: I've also used the U-Pol and really like it. Much smoother than Herculiner. Check out MSGGrunt's truck. He used tintable U-Pol and sprayed the whole rig!
 
Last edited:
I used the Herculiner on my 40 and will never do it again. It just had to much texture. It has held up well as has been in for 6 years plus. There are e few areas that have torn but I have abuesd it .
 
Your opinion might be that the quality of the job doesn't matter since the use will most likely damage the finish. However, I think ANYTHING you attempt to do should be a top notch job, regardless how it will be used.

No, my oppinion is you have to decide if the difference between rolled and sprayed and professionally sprayed is worth the money to you. Actually, for this thread, weither it's worth it to me or you doesn't matter - only to sno bored. He just wants to know our various experiences. I have experience doing SPRAY, ROLL, and BRUSH, with 3 different kinds of liner, and have shared those experiences. You have experience with one way with one kind of liner and have shared that. There is no need to argue about what our experiences have been, and how we felt about them. NOT EVERYONE HAS THE SAME EXPERIENCES! Some people pick up spraying paint or liner very easily. Some don't. Some pick up Arc welding very easily, some don't. Myself, I never picked up arc very well, oxey accetalene - I can make beautiful beads, MIG easy for me, not so much for my brother cause he had problems seeing through the shield even with an auto darkening helmet. Me saying "Come on, unless your a completely lazy douch this is easy", doesn't make welding any easier for him. Doesn't make it any easier for me to strike an arc either. So, if I have a gas welding set-up in front of me and a stick welder, and even though stick might be the better choice for a given project, I'll take the gas - cause I'll do better with gas than I will with stick. Others might do better with the stick than they would with gas because it comes easier to them.

I'm certainly not going to spend the money to do a top notch job on paint on a vehicle that is going to get scratched up, that's just a waste of money. Top notch job for paint is several grand - and would be a waste on a truck that is really used. Top notch professional for bedliner can be $500-600 from some of the quotes people have posted off and on. I've got $150 into mine, and have very respectable results and plenty of complements on it.



Sno Bored - Sounds like U-pol or Durabak would work fine for you. As far as spray or roll, do what YOU are most comfortable with and can afford.
 
Back
Top Bottom