Answer to a possibly evident question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

dnp

Supporting Vendor
SILVER Star
Joined
May 2, 2004
Threads
306
Messages
6,091
Location
Jackson, MS
Just ordered a new ARB for the front of the '95 (by the way, I did a lot of price searching, so for those of you who have been following a recent thread asking "what's the best price for one," my searching ended up at Oconee Off Road - $832 delivered for a winch bull bar), and a question has come up for which I can't find a good answer: I'm sure the answer to this is probably staring me in the face and I'm just not seeing it, but why would it ever be preferable to use a Hawse fairlead over a roller fairlead? It seems to me that any time you could reduce friction under such extreme stresses, you'd want to. However, Hawse fairleads are available and used by many for some reason, so that's the source of my question.

I'm probably an idiot (and I'm sure I'll get called out for my question), but I thought I'd ask anyway. Thanks.
 
Overhang could be one reason, as hawses don't stick out nearly as far as a rollers do. Another reason could be that there is no risk of the rope/cable pinching in the corners between rollers. Weight might be another reason (for those crazy weight weenie types).

I don't have a winch, or tons of experience with one, but those are a few reasons I could think of. I'm sure someone with oodles of experience will chime in soon!
 
Rollers do have a higher chance of failure. Not much you can break on hawses.....
 
Thant's right. Hawse failead is for rope and rollers are for cable.


Wrong. Both hawse and roller fairleads were around long before synthetic cable was available for use on winches. Hawse was the original fairlead that came out and rollers were an improvement at the time when wire rope was the only choice. Hawse is simpler, but wears out wire rope faster and can be useless in a hard pull that is hard to one side. Even wire rope can bind in the corners of a roller fairlead, especially when it is worn. Winching is not a spectator sport and by that I mean you can't take your eyes off it, while your doing it, or it can become lethal. I haven't used the synthetic yet and understand it's advantages, but all things being equal and being old school, I think I'd prefer a well maintained wire rope in good condition, with a roller fairlead, especially in real world conditions. My .02 FWIW
 


Wrong. Both hawse and roller fairleads were around long before synthetic cable was available for use on winches. Hawse was the original fairlead that came out and rollers were an improvement at the time when wire rope was the only choice. Hawse is simpler, but wears out wire rope faster and can be useless in a hard pull that is hard to one side. Even wire rope can bind in the corners of a roller fairlead, especially when it is worn. Winching is not a spectator sport and by that I mean you can't take your eyes off it, while your doing it, or it can become lethal. I haven't used the synthetic yet and understand it's advantages, but all things being equal and being old school, I think I'd prefer a well maintained wire rope in good condition, with a roller fairlead, especially in real world conditions. My .02 FWIW

He never said which came first, just that as a generalization for application: hawse for rope, rollers for cable.
 
He never said which came first, just that as a generalization for application: hawse for rope, rollers for cable.


His post, to me, indicated that hawse was designed or developed for the newer synthetic rope. And that is WRONG. That's all I meant. It happens to work better for synthetic, so it is the preferred fairlead for synthetic. And most off roaders are jumping for the synthetic, nowadays. I'm old school and still not convinced that it will hold up in the severe off road environment when exposed to sunlight, rocks, mud, oil, freezing weather and the like. I know you can get it jacketed and it seems to absorb shock better, but I've broken too many tow straps and seen too many damaged synthetic ropes for other applications to make me feel comfortable about relying on it as a winch rope. Wire rope has it's drawbacks, I know. PM is necessary on any winching system and PM is usually the part that gets neglected. I just feel more confident that wire rope would be more dependable in real world off roading. Again, IMHO & FWIW.
 
His post, to me, indicated that hawse was designed or developed for the newer synthetic rope. And that is WRONG. That's all I meant. It happens to work better for synthetic, so it is the preferred fairlead for synthetic. And most off roaders are jumping for the synthetic, nowadays. I'm old school and still not convinced that it will hold up in the severe off road environment when exposed to sunlight, rocks, mud, oil, freezing weather and the like. I know you can get it jacketed and it seems to absorb shock better, but I've broken too many tow straps and seen too many damaged synthetic ropes for other applications to make me feel comfortable about relying on it as a winch rope. Wire rope has it's drawbacks, I know. PM is necessary on any winching system and PM is usually the part that gets neglected. I just feel more confident that wire rope would be more dependable in real world off roading. Again, IMHO & FWIW.

Thanks for your opinion on why you like steel cable but that has absolutely nothing to do with the OP's question. Neither of us said that a hawse fairlead was "invented" for synthetic cable. That's a ridiculous thought. Hawse fairleads have been around as long as winches and I think everyone knows that.

However, today, for the most part, as a general concensus, people to the right of the bell-curve use hawse fairleads for rope and roller fairleads for steel. In fact, I specifically said you NEED to run a hawse fairlead for rope. I also said I would use a roller fairlead for steel. I never said you have to.

Now could you get away with running a roller fairlead with rope? Maybe, but I wouldn't do it. Can you use a hawse fairlead for steel? Of course, winches were that way for years. But a roller fairlead is better with steel.
 
Thanks for your opinion on why you like steel cable but that has absolutely nothing to do with the OP's question. Neither of us said that a hawse fairlead was "invented" for synthetic cable. That's a ridiculous thought. Hawse fairleads have been around as long as winches and I think everyone knows that.

However, today, for the most part, as a general concensus, people to the right of the bell-curve use hawse fairleads for rope and roller fairleads for steel. In fact, I specifically said you NEED to run a hawse fairlead for rope. I also said I would use a roller fairlead for steel. I never said you have to.

Now could you get away with running a roller fairlead with rope? Maybe, but I wouldn't do it. Can you use a hawse fairlead for steel? Of course, winches were that way for years. But a roller fairlead is better with steel.

WarDamnEagle is correct.
 
Thanks for your opinion on why you like steel cable but that has absolutely nothing to do with the OP's question. Neither of us said that a hawse fairlead was "invented" for synthetic cable. That's a ridiculous thought. Hawse fairleads have been around as long as winches and I think everyone knows that.

However, today, for the most part, as a general concensus, people to the right of the bell-curve use hawse fairleads for rope and roller fairleads for steel. In fact, I specifically said you NEED to run a hawse fairlead for rope. I also said I would use a roller fairlead for steel. I never said you have to.

Now could you get away with running a roller fairlead with rope? Maybe, but I wouldn't do it. Can you use a hawse fairlead for steel? Of course, winches were that way for years. But a roller fairlead is better with steel.


Just trying to be helpful. We may know some things about winching, but it was obvious to me that the OP didn't. After your correct post #5, I thought the OP might be mis-led about the hawse fairlead's origin and limits of use. Sheeeesh:doh:
 
Back
Top Bottom