I see now why it stopped running

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Sep 28, 2004
Threads
284
Messages
2,121
Location
Spokane, WA
Well, you may remember my $400 Piggy that I bought. The guy said that it just quit running on the freeway. Well, I opened up the valve cover tonight to pillage some 2F push rods from it for my other project, and the first four are missing!!

My guess:
Broken cam, lifters and pushrods are now in the oil pan :rolleyes:

It's not a big deal to me, I have another cam. But why would the cam break?
 
well then, that make it rare............put it on Ebay :D

65swb45 said:
Tonkota, I have been wrenching on Cruisers for 19 years and torn into almost a hundred I-6s and I have NEVER SEEN ANYTHING LIKE THAT BEFORE. Seen half a dozen with rods thru the side of the block. Seen 3 or 4 broken cranks. A couple of broken cam gears, but NOTHING like what youve got there.

Truly a freak accident.
 
fj40charles said:
Don't know why a cam would break, but reading posts like this certainly takes away the argument that a F/2F motor is SO much more durable than an SBC.

I love chevy's but let's be honest, they're just as likely to twist off a bump stick as the next guy.
 
KliersLC said:
More likely..........they have more rods to break :D


Well if we get picky, less likely ... shorter cam in a v-8. :D
 
fj40charles said:
Don't know why a cam would break, but reading posts like this certainly takes away the argument that a F/2F motor is SO much more durable than an SBC.


yeah, I've never seen a jack ass mechanic blow up a small block with a crappy rebuild...

Whatever :rolleyes:
 
Just stopped running on the freeway huh? Did the PO mention a godawful noise just prior to it stopping. That mess must have sounded terrible. :eek:
 
Landpimp said:
well then, that make it rare............put it on Ebay :D

I think I see the Fist of God on that camshaft....
 
I had this happen with a Chevy I-6 235 in 1983.

The number 3 piston rod snapped just under the piston, and sawed the block in half. The debris in the oil pan looked just like those pictures <*shudder*>.

Kirk
 
There is really nothing unusual about that block I have seen a handful that look basically like that and worse. And it probably was not a faulty assembly either.

I've described the events that result in this in the Trails. Basically the rod bolts are the weak point in the motor. Too much RPM stretches them. When the crank start downward on the intake stroke, there is A LOT of stress on these bolts. The piston and rod are moving upward FAST. There is no compressed gases or igniting fuel air mixture trying to slow it or push it back down, just an open exhaust valve letting the contents of the cylinder get out of the way. At the top, the crank suddenly changes direction and yanks it all downward. All of the force involved is transmitted through the rob bolts. Add in the suction pulling fresh fuel/air into the cylinder. Like I said, a LOT of force. The higher the rpm, the faster the piston speed and the higher the stress. And it is not a linear relationship (The stress at 2000 rpm is not just double the stress at 1000 rpm). Once one of the 12 bolts is stretched beyond it elastic limits it is longer than it used to be. The nut is no longer torqued down. It will work loose, putting all of the load on the other rod bolt. It too will stretch. One of the bilts will usually actuall come all the way off. The remaining bolt will ben or snap. If it doesn't snap, the rod cap will snap at one side from the assymetrical loading. It might separate from the rod at the top of the stroke, leaving the rod and piston to slam into the head and valves. It might separate at the bottom of the stroke. Either way the cap stays with the crank until the crank starts back up. The cap continues downward, hits the pan, and rebounds. off of the flexing sheetmetal. When it does, it encounters the spinning crank again. The crank takes the cap with it until the cap reaches the camshaft. The cap can't fit through there. The cam snaps where the cap hits it and at the adjacent journals. Usually you blow a hole or at least a major crack in the block. The lifters and pushrods fall into the pan. Depending on just how quickly it all jams to a stop these parts may actually survive or they may get beat to pieces too. I saw one which jams so hard and stopped so quick that the crank pulled the first, second and third bearing caps off of the block (the bolts pulled out of the block, shattering that area around the threads).

Like I said I have seen this a few times. Enough to figure out exactly what has happened by examining all the parts in the various piles of scrap iron. One sent enough shrapnel through the oil pan that it looked like it was hit with a shotgun from the inside.

2Fs will live forever if you keep the RPM reasonable. They don't like 6000 rpm shift points. ;)


Mark...
 
I havent seen that happen to a F/2F before, but I sure had a good laugh behind my friend in his 78 Merc. Monarch one day at a stop light. anyway, he yells out the window to me that his car "started running a little rough" as he pulls away, I was a little slow on the gas and saw some stuff on the ground under where the car was stopped at the light. It turned out to be a chunk of block, a 5" long section of cam with 3 lobes(so at least two of the six cylinders down) and the better part of a connecting rod, a mangled rod bolt and the con rod cap. All came out of a 3" x 4" hole by #5. He contiuned to drive it until it finally succumb to the constant loss of oil flying out of the hole when driving about two weeks later. granted, it didnt get anywhere fast, or without a serious case of the shakes.
 
cruiserbrett said:
I havent seen that happen to a F/2F before, but I sure had a good laugh behind my friend in his 78 Merc. Monarch one day at a stop light. anyway, he yells out the window to me that his car "started running a little rough" as he pulls away, I was a little slow on the gas and saw some stuff on the ground under where the car was stopped at the light. It turned out to be a chunk of block, a 5" long section of cam with 3 lobes(so at least two of the six cylinders down) and the better part of a connecting rod, a mangled rod bolt and the con rod cap. All came out of a 3" x 4" hole by #5. He contiuned to drive it until it finally succumb to the constant loss of oil flying out of the hole when driving about two weeks later. granted, it didnt get anywhere fast, or without a serious case of the shakes.

Good thing I am already on the floor. That is too funny. ;p
 
Back in like 1991 when I had my first fj40 I had a catastrophic engine failure. Not quite like this though. I had been out on some trails near where I was working in Mass. about 75 miles from home. I apparently broke the rust barrier between the oil pan and it's skid plate while out at night on my 76. The next day, I hopped in my rusty and muddy 76 and headed back to NH. Stopped at a buddy's house about halfway home for an hour, then drove back the rest of the way. The next day I was out in the local sandpit and the engine just loses power and dies. Hit the starter, motor's seized. So a friend pulls me out, and then said his father (my boss at the time) had mentioned a huge puddle of oil where I parked the truck in Mass. Another puddle was reported at the halfway stop. So we dumped some oil in it, dragged it around in 4high and dumped the clutch. Dragged it for a while, then it started running again. It had super low oil pressure (wonder why) and was gushing from a hole in the drivers side of the block. As well as leaking profusely from the pan. Ran really rough, knocked like hell, and had no oil pressure, but I drove it for a month after it happened. I then sold the truck and kicked myself for the next 10 years until I got another one. You do silly things when your 18.
 
rgentry said:
So Mark (W). What is your recommendation for rod-end bolts. OEM. Aftermarket.
Some kind of specialty alloy?


If you put new OEM in there they will not be a whole lot better than the old OEM you are taking out. It is a fairly beefy rod bolt, which is actually larger than many applications that you might first consider swapping from.

One of the guys on the List talked with me about this a couple of years ago. He found some Toyota rod bolts for a 3.4 under the TRD line from the factory. Just a tiny bit shorter (on the order of a millimeter IIRC) with the same diameter. These might be the ticket. I haven't tried them though. Since the 3.4 has a lighter rotating assembly with a shorter stroke, even though it is used at higher rpm, the bolts *might* not be expected to see much more stress than the 2F pieces do. ??? I've never (attempted) to do the math and compare them.

I would like to find an aftermarket, high performance rod bolt (ARP) for an american big block (454, 460, 440 or similar) which could be adapted. It seems like I may have found on that was just a fraction of a millimeter larger in diameter which I assumed could be fitted. But it was an almost an "in passing" observation, and I don't remember what the application was.
It should be easy enough to find something if you put any effort into it. I just have not had call to build a real all out 2F for a while.

I think that if you could improve the rod bolt situation, a 2F would be happy and comfortable at 5000-5500 on a very regular basis. I turn built (and balanced) 2Fs to 5000 and *maybe* beyond occasionally. But I'd be a lot happier doing it with stronger rod bolts. I *might* even purposely go to 6000 if I could address this weakness. Maybe. I think that the (stock) valvesprings would be a limiting factor before that point, but they could be upgraded (something I don't worry about for a sub 5000 rpm motor). The pistons themselves would be the next failure point I would expect. I probably would still keep the redline at about 5000-5500 even with upgraded bolts. But it would be a much more secure feeling that I'd have as I approached it. ;)


Mark...
 
Last edited:
Mark (W) - I remember reading your comments on this phenomena in TT. Question though about rpm and a stock 2F. On longer hills, which require me to be in 2nd or 3rd, I have enough power to run above 3000 rpm. But, I self-limit to 3000 because of the rod-bolt issue. Same issue actually on the freeway in 4th - I don't go faster than 3000rpm.

ON a stock 2F, what sustained rpm limit do you suggest?

Thanks.
 
3000 rpm is extremely conservative unless you are talking about very long duration. The 2F is rated for peak horse power at 3600. I've cruised a 300,000 mile FJ60 at 3000 rpm from Anchorage to Faibanks and back (about a 600 miles round trip). The biggest concern in that kind of situation is good oil and good oil pressure. I worry most about general wear and tear and heat generation (leading to oil breakdonw) when turning the engine high for long periods. The rob bolts are not a concern at all at this rpm.

For long hill climbs (I assume that you mean long highway grades, not steep off road hills?) I would probably not be comfortable over 3500 with a 2F that was not in fairly new condition. For short duration (like an off road hill climb or running through the gears) I am perfectly comfortable turning just about any 2F to 4000. These numbers are based on concern for worn bearings, worn out oil and (again) general increased wear. I don't worry about the rod bolts 'til around 5000.

I have also seen a couple of engines which stretched rod caps and spun bearings. These *seemed* to be attributable to routine, sustained operation on the highway in the 3500-4000 rpm range.

This is all based on experience, first hand examination of damaged engine, grilling the owners/operators of failed engines, successful use of engines that have (so far at least) survived and educated guesses. ;)
I can't really quantify it or show you numbers to prove it.
 
Back
Top Bottom