So far so good. Toe in made a big difference. The first pic you can see the outside edge was feathering quite quickly. Notice how the lug corners on the outside leading edges are rounded off compared to the ones on the inside. With 0 toe they would not have lasted long.
Balance- I took the weights off and put the beads in but the balance still sucks. For me it's not a big issue but if I were on the highway every day I might get tired of it. Yesterday cruising at 100kph the was enough vibration to shake the hood a bit. 80kph seemed was much more tolerable. A good shop could probably get them to balance out better by rotating the tire on the rim for the best balance the breaking the bead and popping the balance beads in. In this case I ca not say the beads don't work. I can say that they seem to work as well as the weights that they replaced.
The hum a bit but again for me it's no problem. The do pick up rocks and t grow them hard into the fenders. The BFG's also did but much smaller stones so it was less startling.
Traction is great off road. I'm not qualified to compare to anything other than the BFGs. I did notice a bit of the tire getting torn but this is the newest tire (rotated from the spare) so the rubber still seemed very soft. They clear out mud very well. Not too bad in the snow. They pull well up slopes. With the relatively solid pattern in the center the are good for a truck that sees on road use but wants to be able to grab well off road as well.
I still only have a little time on these. I'm confident that they will wear well as I've used a tire thermometer to set the toe and tire pressure and I can get even temps across the tire.
Basically it's just as the title of the thread implies. These are definitely a step backwards from a modern tire. The flat spot, vibrate, hum, probably wear faster etc. In that way they are much like the rest of the truck. Rough, leaky, loud, and tough. So for me it fits. I think they are super cool tires.
I'll update again when I have even more time on them.
Pete