Why does my fuel mileage suck?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 28, 2007
Threads
371
Messages
5,884
Location
San Diego
Last tank I netted 9.8 mpg and the three before that ~10.2. I know that 80s get bad mileage, but I expect to be up in the 13-15 range.

Some history:

I recently had a major tune-up (all filters, secondary ignition), drive like an old lady (most of the time) and have skinny tires. It has a 3" lift and MT tires. I have been running the AC ~50% of the time and have been having starter troubles. Just replaced the starter before this last fill up (doubt this is relevant, but just being thorough). The resonator and tail pipe are bent (whistles on acceleration). The O2 sensors were tested: both are good, but one is marginal. Had the fuel injector service done recently as well.

It does idle a little rich based on what I smell out of the tailpipe.

What else could it be? Could the AC compressor be going south and causing a drag on the engine? O2 sensors? I'm at a loss here and just looking for suggestions. I have searched, but nothing obvious that I missed.
 
you do own an 80 right?.....:doh:

nothing really constructive to add... just sarcasm!!
 
How many miles? I ask because most find that the stock O2 sensors will "check" fine, but anything over the 100k mark is questionable. They may still work, but they get "slower", therefore not as responsive. If all of the other basics are covered, that is where I would head. The LX I used to own (105k miles) suddenly went from 13-14 to 10 mpg, no codes or anything. Changed the O2's and back up to 14-15.

My current 80 with 160k, had a check engine light come on for the front sensor, I changed them both. By the way, lifted, geared, armored, 35's and average 14mpg.

Jack
 
Your rich condition may also be due to a dirty TB. Thoroughly cleaning mine helped lean mine out a little. "Smells" normal now:meh:
 
May be this doesn't help much,but you live in SD, i live in TJ, and got bad MPG, i blame that there are plenty of hills around here , so that doesn't seam to help MPG, my 4.0 taco doesn't get much over 14 mpg's, so 9.5 for a lifted FJ80....sound kinda normal....i guess someone in flat land may be able to get much better mpg....

my .02
 
X2 on cleaning the throttle body. Also, clean the IAC/ISC.
You say you did an injector cleaning, how about the valvetrain? Seafoam is highly recommended. I've used it a few times and tore one engine down a few thousand miles later and found very little buildup. It works.
A clean engine breathes better.
If the AC compressor were going bad, thered be signs. Noise and/or dark matter in the sight glass. I'd check your idler pullesy though.
Change (not "flush") your tranny fluid.
Does the torque converter clutch lock up in overdrive?
How much air do you run in your tires?
Is your tuna can full of dust and dirt?
Is your intake hose starting to crack?
 
How many miles? I ask because most find that the stock O2 sensors will "check" fine, but anything over the 100k mark is questionable. They may still work, but they get "slower", therefore not as responsive. If all of the other basics are covered, that is where I would head. The LX I used to own (105k miles) suddenly went from 13-14 to 10 mpg, no codes or anything. Changed the O2's and back up to 14-15.

My current 80 with 160k, had a check engine light come on for the front sensor, I changed them both. By the way, lifted, geared, armored, 35's and average 14mpg.

Jack


It has 208k. I have been suspecting the O2 sensors for some time, so I should probably replace them.

I have tall tires (~33.3") and stock gears. Perhaps it is lugging the engine?

X2 on cleaning the throttle body. Also, clean the IAC/ISC.
You say you did an injector cleaning, how about the valvetrain? Seafoam is highly recommended. I've used it a few times and tore one engine down a few thousand miles later and found very little buildup. It works.
A clean engine breathes better.
If the AC compressor were going bad, thered be signs. Noise and/or dark matter in the sight glass. I'd check your idler pullesy though.
Change (not "flush") your tranny fluid.
Does the torque converter clutch lock up in overdrive?
How much air do you run in your tires?
Is your tuna can full of dust and dirt?
Is your intake hose starting to crack?

Haven't used seafoam. I am leery about using any of the "snakeoils" in my engine. Not saying that seafoam is, but there are a lot of them out there.

My AC is not blowing as cold recently and I plan to have it pressure tested and recharged.

I take the 80 to a very reputable shop to have the fluids changed. I have had them drain and replace the fluid every oil change because I was concerned about the condition of the internals. Is this the same as "change"?

The torque converter seems to lock up. How would I tell if it didn't?

I run 40 psi in the tires

My tuna can has about 1/4" of stuff in it (dust, dirt, a few pieces of small misc debris)

My intake hose was replaced about 10k miles ago and is still in good condition.

Thanks for the input everyone. Any other suggestions? Someone in another post mentioned a grounding issue, but I dont understand the context or how it could be related to mileage.
 
I just did the math. At $4.50 a gallon, and assuming the O2 sensors cost $250 from cdan, and I'll gain just two MPG (from 10 to 12), it will take me 3333 miles to get a 100% return on my investment.

One oil change!! Seems like a no-brainer.
 
SDnative,

Can't offer much help here. I live in north county (Encinitas) bought my 80 in late march, it's currently totally stock with 135K on the odo and and the best mileage I've gotten is around 11mpg. O2 sensors were changed around 85k by the PO.

In my daily driver, a 2001 Celica with 150K, I have noticed a considerable difference in gas mileage from different gas stations in the area. Specifically when I fill up at Shell I gain about 3mpg, an improvement of roughly 10% compared to filling up at Costco or ARCO. i always run premium in the Celica however, I thought all the gas in CA was the same I may be wrong, maybe try a new gas station for a tank or two. Could be different ethanol content, ie. less at shell

Ross
 
The O2 sensor and egr modulator and new vacumm hoses made about 2mpg increase for me, This was after an intital 1mpg increase from a full fluid change and wires and plugs. Went from 10 to 13 mpg plus or minus depending on driving habit. I of course had a CEL code. I hope to get another 1 MPG with a throttle body and injector clean for a goal of 14 mpg.

SDnative, Thanks again for the slee pole, got it installed yesterday, but still need lugs and a way to istall the Co2 bottle and fire exting. Does take up alot of room but the clearance from below the bumper looks much better.
 
SDnative,

Can't offer much help here. I live in north county (Encinitas) bought my 80 in late march, it's currently totally stock with 135K on the odo and and the best mileage I've gotten is around 11mpg. O2 sensors were changed around 85k by the PO.

In my daily driver, a 2001 Celica with 150K, I have noticed a considerable difference in gas mileage from different gas stations in the area. Specifically when I fill up at Shell I gain about 3mpg, an improvement of roughly 10% compared to filling up at Costco or ARCO. i always run premium in the Celica however, I thought all the gas in CA was the same I may be wrong, maybe try a new gas station for a tank or two. Could be different ethanol content, ie. less at shell

Ross

Thanks for the input. I usually only fill up at the major brands (Mobil, Shell, one other?). Maybe I'll try using only shell and see what happens. Seems a little voodoo, but I'll give it a try.


The O2 sensor and egr modulator and new vacumm hoses made about 2mpg increase for me, This was after an intital 1mpg increase from a full fluid change and wires and plugs. Went from 10 to 13 mpg plus or minus depending on driving habit. I of course had a CEL code. I hope to get another 1 MPG with a throttle body and injector clean for a goal of 14 mpg.

SDnative, Thanks again for the slee pole, got it installed yesterday, but still need lugs and a way to istall the Co2 bottle and fire exting. Does take up alot of room but the clearance from below the bumper looks much better.

I am pretty diligent about replacing things like hoses, etc when they are suspect. I'll take a look at the egr modulator.

Glad to hear you got the pole working.
 
I looked at your signature and saw "BFG MT 255/85R16"

Are those tires larger than stock...seems like I can't remember what stock was/is anymore when it comes to trucks.

What percentage larger are those tires than the ones that came on the truck new?

I ask because the larger the tire, the fewer miles are registered by the odometer and the trip meter. So in my case I see around 200 miles a tank, but that is actually 220 miles because of the size of my tires (approximately 10%.)

200 miles is 10mpg uncorrected or 11mpg corrected (I fill up when the light comes on which leaves 5 gallons +/- in the tank.)

So, let me know if this helps you a little bit. The others were right too about it being lifted and such. The truck is already not very aerodynamic, but add height and more wind drag only makes it worse.:cheers:
 
your tires are close to 5% bigger, so you need to add that percent to your miles per tank calclus is what you think i mean:D

if you are not already.....
 
id say if your exhaust sounds restricted then it probably is.
if the air cant get out of the engine then it is not efficient and you will lose economy
i agree with throwing a new 02 sensor at it, i think they are kinda like a fan belt no sense driving it till it is totally dead
new tailpipe and 02 sensors thats my 2bits
 
wondering if im running rich but not sure how to tell? I do smell the gas when first starting the car. But then again i dont have a cat just a straight pipe. Would the second O2 sensor do anything for the MPG ? Or do you just need to replace the one before the cat? I always thought the second 02 was just to monitor the cat.
 
I guess an obvious question would be: How are you calculating you fuel mileage? The "I have a 20 gallon tank and I'm only getting 200 miles before the light comes on" method is not accurate. I know most people know that but it still bugs me when people use the capacity of their fuel tank to figure mileage and not the amount of gas they actually burned.
 
Just as a data point, the wife's LX pretty consistently gets 15-16mpg on 265/75-16s. It's got 170K, ~30K on a rebuilt motor, but I don't think the O2 sensors were changed. The resonator whistles and it smells rich at idle as well. We just got back from a camping trip and got 14.8mpg towing a small trailer 70+mph over multiple mountain passes.

I keep thinking I ought to look into why the exhaust smells rich, but apparently my mileage isn't suffering much.
 
I looked at your signature and saw "BFG MT 255/85R16"

Are those tires larger than stock...seems like I can't remember what stock was/is anymore when it comes to trucks.

What percentage larger are those tires than the ones that came on the truck new?

I ask because the larger the tire, the fewer miles are registered by the odometer and the trip meter. So in my case I see around 200 miles a tank, but that is actually 220 miles because of the size of my tires (approximately 10%.)

200 miles is 10mpg uncorrected or 11mpg corrected (I fill up when the light comes on which leaves 5 gallons +/- in the tank.)

So, let me know if this helps you a little bit. The others were right too about it being lifted and such. The truck is already not very aerodynamic, but add height and more wind drag only makes it worse.:cheers:

I understand this. I haven't done exact calculations, but my shoot from the hip estimation is 7%-8% off.

id say if your exhaust sounds restricted then it probably is.
if the air cant get out of the engine then it is not efficient and you will lose economy
i agree with throwing a new 02 sensor at it, i think they are kinda like a fan belt no sense driving it till it is totally dead
new tailpipe and 02 sensors thats my 2bits

I am going to lop off my resonator and tail pipe anyway because mine is pretty bent up and I have a undamaged one waiting to replace it. Maybe I'll run it off for a month or so and see if it makes a difference.


I guess an obvious question would be: How are you calculating you fuel mileage? The "I have a 20 gallon tank and I'm only getting 200 miles before the light comes on" method is not accurate. I know most people know that but it still bugs me when people use the capacity of their fuel tank to figure mileage and not the amount of gas they actually burned.


I reset my trip odometer at every fill up. I keep a running log of date, odometer reading and gallons pumped. Unfortunately I have only been doing this for the last 4 or so fill ups. It would be valuable to have that data from when I first bought the truck stock. Lesson learned. :bang:
 
Back
Top Bottom