Water Pump questions??? Please help

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 22, 2003
Threads
30
Messages
401
Hi,

I'm wrenching on my 94 LC, and just replaced the radiator with a new Toy one. New Toy hoses, belts, and now ready to put it back together.

My big question is would you replace the water pump, even if it seems fine? It's got 165K miles, and coolant has been changed out regularly but I've got some grey sludge I've found. I've been using Toy red coolant for a couple of years, and will be putting all new Toy red coolant. Looking for long term reliability.

If you say replace, is it crazy to trust anything but Toyota? I can get a new Toy pump for $130, but have seen an O-Reilly's one for $60 from previous old post.

Thanks a bunch!

Bryan
 
Thanks Corbet,

That's been my feelings exactly although I've had three mechanics that do a lot of LC stuff, say don't worry about it until it needs it. I'm still thinking, man, it's just right there. 6 bolts or whatever, and it's off, boom, new one, on, back up and button up this project.

I'd sure be kicking my own ass a year from now if it started leaking, or growling.

Thanks,
Bryan
 
Hi,

I'm wrenching on my 94 LC, and just replaced the radiator with a new Toy one. New Toy hoses, belts, and now ready to put it back together.

My big question is would you replace the water pump, even if it seems fine? It's got 165K miles, and coolant has been changed out regularly but I've got some grey sludge I've found. I've been using Toy red coolant for a couple of years, and will be putting all new Toy red coolant. Looking for long term reliability.

If you say replace, is it crazy to trust anything but Toyota? I can get a new Toy pump for $130, but have seen an O-Reilly's one for $60 from previous old post.

Thanks a bunch!

Bryan

Did you replace the fan clutch? If it's not a blue hub, I would replace it way before think about a pump. The 80's water pump is way reliable, I can only think of a couple that have failed.
 
I would vote not to do it until it is leaking. Water pumps don't just dump the total contents of the cooling system when they go bad. It starts as a slow drip and will spot your driveway first. Besides, now that you have pulled your radiator before, the next time you need to it, the job will go much faster. :D
 
At 165K if its the original I'd replace with OEM while you have it disassembled.


I would also at 175k miles mine seemed fine but when i removed it the bearings where shot although it still worked fine it wass excess drag on the belts. You have the radiator off with 165k miles on it. Its less than a 5 minute job now.
 
Ok, you talked me into it

Did you replace the fan clutch? If it's not a blue hub, I would replace it way before think about a pump. The 80's water pump is way reliable, I can only think of a couple that have failed.

After reading your reply, and others that were replacing fan clutches, I decided to go ahead and change this as well, since mine wasn't a blue hub. It was a black hub, but seems to work just as good in the hand anyway. The new one didn't have any more turning resistance and both feel like the oil is thick molasses inside when you turn them. It sure is prettier though, so hope it does actually work better and not just for looks.

Thanks for the tip to replace it.

Bryan
 
Replaced the water pump and fan clutch

I would also at 175k miles mine seemed fine but when i removed it the bearings where shot although it still worked fine it wass excess drag on the belts. You have the radiator off with 165k miles on it. Its less than a 5 minute job now.

I went ahead and put in a brand new Toyota water pump as well as a new Toyota blue hub fan clutch.

Both of these parts seemed fine, off the rig, but this is just more preventative maintainence for me.

Only part I screwed up in is when I was all finished, I was checking for oil leaks and spotted one in the back of the valve cover. I was just gently snugging up the bolts a little, but the back one was totally loose. It was such a stretch for me, and I was using a long extension and long ratchet, and can't believe I did this but I snapped that bolt off. First bolt that I've done this to on this rig, and I've had it since 98. What a pain in the ass to fix. Hopefully it won't leak to much and I can drive it for a while without fixing this. I am tired of carpooling with my wife.

I'll work soon on this and drill it and try to use an easy out on it. It would be real easy to fix when I do a head gasket replacement though. Was hoping to do that in the fall when it's cooler.

Thanks for all the tips and recommendations.
Bryan
 
Back
Top Bottom