unnecesary repairs??

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Apr 16, 2005
Threads
13
Messages
1,023
so my '40 was puking out oil, a lot... I don't have a shop and am a bit timid when it comes to motor stuff, so I took it in to the local guy, also was getting the brake wheel cylinders done at the same time (easy, but time....) he diagnosed the problem as being valve cover gasket, wait for parts. so tonite, I was thinking that I would like to use the truck tomorrow, so pulled off the air cleaner and checked the torque on the valve cover bolts, didn't have a torque wrench, but they MIGHT have been finger tight, cranked them down to what seemed reasonable, presto, no more oil leak.
so now should I go ahead and get the gasket replaced, when it comes in, or is it fixed? I don't want to piss off this mechanic, as I am in a small town, and he is the only decent shop I have found, so I'll at least buy the parts he ordered, so as to not leave him stuck with it and me in the bad books, but if I don't need to install it right now, screw it. but if it is one of those things that once it starts going, it's gone, I'll do it.
any advice appreciated
:beer:
 
Last edited:
oh yeah, what made me think that I need to use the truck tomorrow is that we took the top off tonite, inspired by the guy who managed to pull the hard top with his twelve year old son, I thought I'd see if my 5'3 115lb wife was up to it. we managed and now I want to cruise.
 
Last edited:
I would say to buy the part from him, at cost + his markup (usually 100% in small shops) and hang it on your wall. you will need it.

Or, pull the cover, do a valve adjustment, paint it and slap it on with a new gasket. If he is a gearhead, he will understand your desire to DIY. You are right for not sticking him with a part he can't move.
 
I agree with Rabid as a Mechanic myself, you made a comittment and the right thing to do would at least pay for the parts (that you might need later). So that way the business is not paying anything out of their pocket, unless they do alot of with Cruisers he may not even make you pay for the part since it will be used later due to the volume of cruiser business. Be honest with the mechanic and if you have a good one he will be honest with you. Then things will work out alright. :D
 
buy it definetly, drive it for now, when you find time go ahead and get a FSM and adjust the valves, it is super easy if you follow the directions and if it hasn't been done recently, will need to be done and the engine will run better. Just save the gasket till you have a weekend to work on your rig, tune up, oil change, etc. I would do a complete tune up if you haven't done one recently. It is very easy and it will give you some experience working around your rig and engine.

ps - get rid of the drum brakes and cut your maintenance in half , :)

noah
 
yeah the drum barkes are on their way out, i have a complete front axle off a newer cruiser, minus one axleshaft, but I haven't gotten around to finding the parts and doing it, and I had already bought the wheel cylinders for the front drums
I'll definately buy the part, but I guess I was just a bit cheesed that when he noticed that the leak was coming from the valve cover, he didn't check the bolts to make sure that they were tight, just ordered a new gasket instead, I mean, checking the bolts was the first thing that I thought of... and I'm not a pro.
 
Mechanics also need to cover themselves. If he were to tighten down the bolts and it stopped temporally only to have you come back a month later you probably wouldn't have been happy. After all you paid him to fix it once already.
 
If he tightened the nuts and the valve cover bowed, whose responsible?

If he tightened the nuts and the valve cover gasket split, whose responsible?

If he tightened the nuts and the rocker arm studs dimpled the acorns, whose responsible?

And, if we're talking stock 2F here, two of the 4 are hidden under the air cleaner.


Maybe I'm just oversensitive.

Good to know you thought about it.:)

Best

Mark A.
 
Back
Top Bottom