Tranny Problems!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 16, 2005
Threads
1
Messages
10
Location
Birmingham, Alabama
I just rebuilt my 4 speed transmission with new bearings and gaskets. Put it back together and installed it back in my 76' FJ40. Ever since then, it will not shift from first to second gear while moving. I can start in 2nd and go to third and fourth. I can also start in first and go to third and fourth. But, I can not go from first to second and then third and fourth. It runs very smooth besides this issue.

Is this a syncronization issue? Should I pull the tranny again and rebuild? Fun. Fun.

I am new at this and I very much appreciate your help!
 
Welcome to Mud! :flipoff2:

After I replaced my output shaft for my Toybox install mine also does not like to go from first to second gear either when the tranny is cold. After I drive it long enough to warm up the engine and tranny gear oil it will shift fine from first to second. I am not sure if the second gear synchro is super sensitive or what but I am not going to tear into mine again unless I need to.

I just shift using the RPMs when cold. Wind it up to about 2k then shift into second and 9 times out of 10 I never grind the gears. Once it is warm it shifts super smooth.

I am going to dump the dino 90wt and switch to synthetic and see if that makes any difference, I think it may, as the synthetic should be much thinner when cold.

Hopefully some resident tranny gurus will thow in their .02 if there is something unique about the second gear synchro.

PS, the little green flipoff guy is a traditional mud welcome and not meant to offend.
 
did you replace the brass syncronizers? All torque and preload done properly?
I would venture to say it's syncros if they were not replaced, they are the most wearable item in a box. The problem is common across the board for trannys.
My heep, mazda, even an old chevy did this after many miles or lack of care and changing fluids.

Good luck my friend with your project.
 
F-junker said:
did you replace the brass syncronizers? All torque and preload done properly?
I would venture to say it's syncros if they were not replaced, they are the most wearable item in a box. The problem is common across the board for trannys.
My heep, mazda, even an old chevy did this after many miles or lack of care and changing fluids.

Good luck my friend with your project.

Thanks for the response! I did not replace the brass, just put them back in place (I thought)...What a pain to drop the tranny again. If I got to remove it again, I might just figure out how to adapt a 5 speed back in its place. I have 90w in the case. Would it help to put synthetic or any other type oil back in??
 
It is a strange problem. Worn synchros grind when you shift, but they will shift easily. If you mis assemble the synchro hub, it won't shift at all, moving or not. The 1-2 synchro assembly isn't readily disassembled, so it is not likely to be the problem. If the hub is not misassembled, there aren't many other possibilities: shaft-gear bearing fit and end play on the shaft.

It sounds like it won't go from N to second? How does it down shift from 2 to 1?
 
Sitting still, every gear shifts from 1st to 4th. Starting off, I can start in either 1st or 2nd and then go to 3rd and 4th. I can not hit second gear while moving. I will try to go from 2nd to 1st tonight when I get home. Thanks for the help.
 
dbrogdo4 said:
No I left the linkage alone.

There aren't that many happy possibilities, but I would start by looking at the top cover because you can remove it without removing the tranny. Maybe the little balls and springs that lock out the other gears during shifting are worn and it got tweaked when you reinstalled it. With the cover off you can also look inside the tranny and see if anything obvious is hanging it up. You can move the shift collars by hand. Just make sure that they are back in the N posiiton before you reinstall the top cover.
 
Like Pin_Head said, the 1st 2nd synchro isn't easy to fool with, so it's less likely that something changed during the rebuild in that respect. I'm gonna take a different tack with this.

Can you rotate your shift lever from side to side any significant amount? I have seen a few early 4 speed towers with badly worn pins in them that would allow a fair amount of rotation in the shift lever.

If you are not sure, then pull the lever out and have a look at the pins. If you will notice, you can also look down into the shifter forks. You will note that the slot for the 1st 2nd shifter[ the one in the middle] is narrower than the others.

My theory here is that there is enough rotational 'wobble' in your shifter that it is catching the edge of the forks next to it as you attempt to cross over from N to 1st or second.

Hth

Mark A.
 
Thanks guys for the suggestions. A few additional tid bits. After driving about 50 miles in the last couple of days, I have noticed a pattern. When I come to a stop, I have to shift to 1st, before it will allow me to shift down to 2nd. Almost like it has to reset. It sometimes will go straight to 2nd, but the easy route is to go to 1st and then shift down to 2nd, before I start off.

The first thing I did was to take the top of the tranny and look around, once I knew I was having problems. Everything appears OK and there was no visible grind marks. There may have been a little more slack in rear end of the gears than I remembered before the rebuild, but it could have also been my imagination.

As far as the shifter, I tried to twist it out during the rebuild and never could get it freed up. I guess potentially, I could have bent it slightly. I will give it another try this weekend.
 
dbrogdo4 said:
As far as the shifter, I tried to twist it out during the rebuild and never could get it freed up. I guess potentially, I could have bent it slightly. I will give it another try this weekend.

That might explain it. It doesn't come out by twisting the shifter. You push down on the little metal retaining cap covering the pivot ball on the shifter and turn slightly (CCW I think?).
 
Guys,
I believe you are correct in assuming the problem is at the top, where the shaft fits into the linkage. I took the shifter cap off and could here it hitting, as I tried to shift into 2nd while moving. It does not look like the area below the cap and spring is bent, but I believe the upper shaft may be slightly tilted left toward toward the driver.

I guess that could cause it to sit a little sideways. Should I just go to SOR and order a new shifter? Thoughts?

I took a few pictures. See what you think. I have no previous reference point....
IMG_4690.webp
IMG_4693.webp
IMG_4694.webp
 
Last edited:
Can't tell anything is wrong by looking at it, but the shift lever itself is rarely a problem. It doesn't matter if the long side is bent slightly to the dirvers side because it has been bent anyway. Check the pins in the top of the shift tower that fit into the slots on the ball of the shift lever to see if they are tight. Check the slots on the shift rails inside into which the nose of the shift lever fits. They should line up straight with one another and there should be no play in them. Also check the slots for burrs and wear.

How does the top cover shift when it is out?

How does the 1-2 synchro hub move on the main shaft when you reach in and shift it manually? Is there any sideways play on the main shaft or 1-2 synchro assembly? Anything look out of place? Any missing parts on the bottom of the tranny?
 
Pin_head,
After removing the floor and looking around in the tranny, I went fishing. I found the small pin that fits in the shaft at the end of what I believe is the thrust washer. It was in the bottom of the case. It must have fell out when I assembled it.

The syncro seems to have just enough slack to allow it to move a little bit from side to side. I guess this is my shifting problem. What do you think?

The top assembly seems to all be intact.....
 
I was always puzzled by that little pin because it only seems to keep the thrust washer from spinning on the shaft. However, it sits right next to the 1-2 synchro, so it is in the right place to cause problems. Try putting it back and see what happens.

The synchro assembly shouldn't have too much wobble on the shaft, but it might slide back and forth a little. Not much you can do about it outside of getting new parts or a good used tranny.
 
Back
Top Bottom