Thule or Yakima??

Yakima or Thule


  • Total voters
    76

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

I've used both and they are both good. I like the Yakima for their broad range of bike and kayak mounts. I personally like the Thule cargo boxes better, they are light and hold a ton while protecting stuff from the elements.
 
Ditto on the cargo boxes from Thule....the Thule Mountaineer is excellent, and fits the LC nicely as far as total size. Although, the Yakima Rocket Box has been a good one too...I have owned the Rocket Box, but it wasn't big enough for the road trips anymore with 3 kids, hence the purchase of the Mountaineer instead.

You can't go wrong with either brand though...I have Yakima products mostly for the rack items, and like I said, Thule for the box. Most of their stuff is able to be used with each others systems..so that's another plus.
 
Dunno if it's still true, but back in '93 (oh man, I'm dating myself - many of you couldn't drive yet...) when I bought the 80's Thule system the towers on the Yakima tall enough to clear the factory rack had plastic extenders as their solution (yech). The Thules are steel one piece.

For roof boxes, I have Sears XCargo 20 cu ft. It's wide, short and has a shape that is far, far more versatile than the rocket box type. If you have to put skiis inside a box, this may not be long enough, but I can carry hard sided luggage, a 19" CRT, folded kids bike trailer, kids bike, etc in it. Cheap at 175, also.

DougM
 
I sell the Yakima stuff at work and it is really easy to work with and install/uninstall. Customers like it too, as it is easy for even the least technical folks out there to understand how to do it themselves.
 
LOL!

Did you just call me stupid in a very polite way?


:beer:


I sell the Yakima stuff at work and it is really easy to work with and install/uninstall. Customers like it too, as it is easy for even the least technical folks out there to understand how to do it themselves.
 
Last edited:
I voted for Thule and broke the current tie :)

I voted for Thule based on my past experiences as I have none yet on the 80 series. My last Thule system was their quick disconnect system that worked GREAT. Basically the mounting lower half of the quick disconnect "feet" were installed onto the rig and then when you wanted to attach the rack you put the bars with the upper part of the feet over onto the quick disconnect lower halves and locked them in. Made putting the rack bars on and taking them off a one person 15 second job.

If there were a way to retrofit that onto my LX and make it strong enough to support a full rack and/or RTT I would be all over it :) Of course with enough $$ anything is possible.
 
quik-n-easy gutter mounts, solid aluminum, work great.
 
I'm not real sure on the rack I used to own, but it used the round bars. I think it's the Yakima.

The round bars were beefier than the Thule square bars.
 
The newer Yak boxes open from both sides:) more useful on a car though, because you can actually reach the top. I have a Rocket Box. Almost 10 years now. It has been very useful. Installed a Thule Terrapin (off the back hitch mount) today on a Pilot. It was very nice. Both are good. IMO:cheers:
 
I voted Yakima simply because I bent Thule bars before. Never bent Yakima bars. Had Yakima now on 4 vehicles and Thule on two.

But, as stated before, most, if not all, the accessories will fit on either square or round bars so don't feel you're locked into one system.
 
I like thule, but they are both good. Get whatever you can get the least expensive off ebay or craigslist.

The cargo box on my wagon is pretty big at 30 cubic feet. I've had it for about 5 years now. Fiberglass and sturdy.
landcruiserpackasport.jpg
 
Thule - style bars came factory original on my VW Quantum Synchro wagons, I've stayed with that since. That rectangular bar setup seemed to be the standard in Europe then, I think the round (Yak) style bars have gained popularity since. I've found off-brand ski and snowboard holders that fit Thule, not Yak, so I suspect that's still the more common format.

My bro mentioned the taller towers to clear the factory rack, my standard-height towers barely cleared my factory rack on the 40th.
 
The reason yakima chose round bars was to accomodate the curvature of various rooflines. That isn't a huge factor on the 80, but I still prefer the Yak designs. The only time I've been dissatisfyied with a yakima product (specific to round bars) is using the Hully Roller kayak system. The kayak has too much leverage on the rollers, especially with the hiegth of the 80 roofline, so the rollers twist on the round bar and you have to drill and pin the system to keep it secure. But on any system that connects the crossbars (cargo racks/boxes, bike trays, tents, etc) the round bars should work very well.
 
I have two sets of yakima bars for my lx. I had one set from my taco, and got larger bars. The second set i bought locally off of craigslist. You can get a set with the 1a gutter clamps pretty cheap. Specially since most vehicles dont use the gutter clamps. Accessories are pretty much equal across the board, and most are interchangable. There is probably more resale on yakima accessories. The yakimas with 1A clamps clear the factory luggage rack. They do look a bit high without the luggage rack on it.

MaineMike, You should look at the Malone gull wings for your hauling your yak's. They adapt to the factory rack, thule, or yakima bars. My buddy has two sets on his expedition, and they hold the boat nicely. I have a sit on top, so I just run mine hull up, and havent had any issues.
 
I prefer Yakima after years of owning and selling both.

IMO the Yakima towers are better designed and easier to use. Round bar is claimed (by Yakima) to be stronger.

Most bike/ski/box/what ever mounts are now interchangeable between both companies. So feel free to mix and match.

I buy what ever I can find used and cheap.
 
Back
Top Bottom