- Thread starter
- #21
Wow...where do I start...
First. I do not believe that all dealerships are bad. I do not believe that all people are dishonest all the time. I do feel like what I experienced at this dealership was unfortunate. I do feel like the behavior I saw while at this dealership was shady. Others may have had different experiences. This was my experience on this particular day with this set of people.
That is great. I honestly wish more people took their jobs as seriously as you do.
Well...on my receipt (I did pay for this service) it clearly states that they and I quote, "drove the vehicle and confirmed the customers description of the issue".
Certainly not. I paid them the diagnostic fee that they advertised and their diagnosis was that it would cost 800 dollars to diagnose the source of the sounds.
What I heard...remember, I was there for hours.
Service Rep: We took care of your winterization. We also checked your air filter while since we had the vehicle.
Old Lady: Thanks. Were the tires OK?
Service Rep: Yeah, they weren't too bad. But your air filter could be replaced. You could get by without changing it, but I would change it if I were you.
Old Lady: OK, how much would that be?
Service Rep: 120 dollars and we can do it right now.
Old Lady: OK.
You are right though..."fleeced" is a little strong. Goes back to the that recent thread about what you would or wouldn't do when you could take money from an old woman who doesn't know any better I guess. It isn't necessarily wrong, but not everyone is comfortable with it.
That really would be unfortunate...I honestly don't understand the logistics of how a tech gets paid, but I would hope the tech gets paid his hourly rate and that things like this balance out for the overall service department. For example, in cases where the diagnosis takes 10 minutes.
As long as we are working with hypothetical situations...
"Lets say" the problem is a loose exhaust and heat shield, takes 10 minutes to diagnos and 15 minutes to fix.
Would that mechanic get paid what he asked for plus a 100 dollar cash tip?
Yes...he would
.
First. I do not believe that all dealerships are bad. I do not believe that all people are dishonest all the time. I do feel like what I experienced at this dealership was unfortunate. I do feel like the behavior I saw while at this dealership was shady. Others may have had different experiences. This was my experience on this particular day with this set of people.
As a Toyota ASM, I worked my ass off making sure my customers were treated fairly and I hate when people whine about dealers, so hang on while I whine about customers.
That is great. I honestly wish more people took their jobs as seriously as you do.
Seriously...it is hard for me to believe too...and quite a relief on my checkbook...for now...I am sure my cruiser will be back for more!Frankly your story sounds fishy too.
How accurate was your description of the problem?? If the problem was that easy for you to find, I seriously doubt the description provided to the dealer was helpful.
Well...on my receipt (I did pay for this service) it clearly states that they and I quote, "drove the vehicle and confirmed the customers description of the issue".
Depending on the advisor, something like "There is a grinding noise in my front end" might justify having the tech check the birfs or bearings. Perhaps the advisor based the estimate on the labor required to do a reseal since it would be apart. Would you prefer to be told $800 AFTER it is already torn apart?
Certainly not. I paid them the diagnostic fee that they advertised and their diagnosis was that it would cost 800 dollars to diagnose the source of the sounds.
I don't know what they did...I only now that I sat in their waiting room for nearly three hours.Sounds like they never had the chance to put it up in the air and look it over. Even with the $800 quote the tech might have found the same problem and only charged you for his time (granted higher than what you paid).
"fleece"... that's a nasty term, don't make claims you can't backup. You have no idea what was done or why her bill was $120.
Most likely the real story...
Dealer -"Good morning how can I help you"
Cust - "I think I need a new airfilter, you told me that the last time I was here"
Dealer- "According to the mileage you need a 5000 mile service"
Cust - "Ok"
2 hrs later
Cashier - "Here is your bill for $120"
Cust - "WHAT ... all I wanted was an airfilter, that is outrageous" (that is the only part you hear)
What I heard...remember, I was there for hours.
Service Rep: We took care of your winterization. We also checked your air filter while since we had the vehicle.
Old Lady: Thanks. Were the tires OK?
Service Rep: Yeah, they weren't too bad. But your air filter could be replaced. You could get by without changing it, but I would change it if I were you.
Old Lady: OK, how much would that be?
Service Rep: 120 dollars and we can do it right now.
Old Lady: OK.
You are right though..."fleeced" is a little strong. Goes back to the that recent thread about what you would or wouldn't do when you could take money from an old woman who doesn't know any better I guess. It isn't necessarily wrong, but not everyone is comfortable with it.
Let's say the quoted $100 to diagnose. What if the actual problem had been in the front diff and they had to disassemble the entire front end to find that out. They quote a price for the repair and you say no, just put it back together. Now the tech has spent his entire day and gets paid for 1 hour .... that's not right
That really would be unfortunate...I honestly don't understand the logistics of how a tech gets paid, but I would hope the tech gets paid his hourly rate and that things like this balance out for the overall service department. For example, in cases where the diagnosis takes 10 minutes.
As long as we are working with hypothetical situations...
"Lets say" the problem is a loose exhaust and heat shield, takes 10 minutes to diagnos and 15 minutes to fix.
Would that mechanic get paid what he asked for plus a 100 dollar cash tip?
Yes...he would
.