The Stealership

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Wow...where do I start...

First. I do not believe that all dealerships are bad. I do not believe that all people are dishonest all the time. I do feel like what I experienced at this dealership was unfortunate. I do feel like the behavior I saw while at this dealership was shady. Others may have had different experiences. This was my experience on this particular day with this set of people.

As a Toyota ASM, I worked my ass off making sure my customers were treated fairly and I hate when people whine about dealers, so hang on while I whine about customers.

That is great. I honestly wish more people took their jobs as seriously as you do.

Frankly your story sounds fishy too.
Seriously...it is hard for me to believe too...and quite a relief on my checkbook...for now...I am sure my cruiser will be back for more!

How accurate was your description of the problem?? If the problem was that easy for you to find, I seriously doubt the description provided to the dealer was helpful.

Well...on my receipt (I did pay for this service) it clearly states that they and I quote, "drove the vehicle and confirmed the customers description of the issue".

Depending on the advisor, something like "There is a grinding noise in my front end" might justify having the tech check the birfs or bearings. Perhaps the advisor based the estimate on the labor required to do a reseal since it would be apart. Would you prefer to be told $800 AFTER it is already torn apart?

Certainly not. I paid them the diagnostic fee that they advertised and their diagnosis was that it would cost 800 dollars to diagnose the source of the sounds.

Sounds like they never had the chance to put it up in the air and look it over. Even with the $800 quote the tech might have found the same problem and only charged you for his time (granted higher than what you paid).
I don't know what they did...I only now that I sat in their waiting room for nearly three hours.


"fleece"... that's a nasty term, don't make claims you can't backup. You have no idea what was done or why her bill was $120.
Most likely the real story...
Dealer -"Good morning how can I help you"
Cust - "I think I need a new airfilter, you told me that the last time I was here"
Dealer- "According to the mileage you need a 5000 mile service"
Cust - "Ok"
2 hrs later
Cashier - "Here is your bill for $120"
Cust - "WHAT ... all I wanted was an airfilter, that is outrageous" (that is the only part you hear)

What I heard...remember, I was there for hours.

Service Rep: We took care of your winterization. We also checked your air filter while since we had the vehicle.
Old Lady: Thanks. Were the tires OK?
Service Rep: Yeah, they weren't too bad. But your air filter could be replaced. You could get by without changing it, but I would change it if I were you.
Old Lady: OK, how much would that be?
Service Rep: 120 dollars and we can do it right now.
Old Lady: OK.

You are right though..."fleeced" is a little strong. Goes back to the that recent thread about what you would or wouldn't do when you could take money from an old woman who doesn't know any better I guess. It isn't necessarily wrong, but not everyone is comfortable with it.




Let's say the quoted $100 to diagnose. What if the actual problem had been in the front diff and they had to disassemble the entire front end to find that out. They quote a price for the repair and you say no, just put it back together. Now the tech has spent his entire day and gets paid for 1 hour .... that's not right

That really would be unfortunate...I honestly don't understand the logistics of how a tech gets paid, but I would hope the tech gets paid his hourly rate and that things like this balance out for the overall service department. For example, in cases where the diagnosis takes 10 minutes.

As long as we are working with hypothetical situations...
"Lets say" the problem is a loose exhaust and heat shield, takes 10 minutes to diagnos and 15 minutes to fix.

Would that mechanic get paid what he asked for plus a 100 dollar cash tip?


Yes...he would:cheers:.
 
I got here by link, so relax. I'll find my way out just as easy as I did in.

I had a T100 one time, that had developed an intermittent electrical problem. Long story short, after two trips to two life long mechanic friends (with a stall on a shoulderless highway and a semi bearing down on me in between) with no problems found "a loose tooth never hurts in the dentists chair". I hated to send it to the dealer to fix, having no clue what it could be.

Took it to Beamen Toyota around lunch time Friday IIRC, thinking I'd H8 to spend the weekend w/o it. They said it would be the next day or Monday for I'd get it. Called them right at 5:00 that day and they said it was ready and had been fixed for some time now. For less than $200 they had diagnosed the problem and fixed it...(but not before I managed to kick the dash out after a stall on a twisty mountain road w/ cliffs for shoulders and it happened in the only place I could get it off the road) a loose EFI or ignition fuse connection under the fuse, in the box. I can't remember.


Sorry I don't have the invoice, and can't "prove it", but that's my story.

As a rule I don't do dealerships. But in this case I was more than happy for their assistance.

Not only did they fix it, but I was amazed at what they charged me.
 
I got here by link, so relax. I'll find my way out just as easy as I did in.

I had a T100 one time, that had developed an intermittent electrical problem. Long story short, after two trips to two life long mechanic friends (with a stall on a shoulderless highway and a semi bearing down on me in between) with no problems found "a loose tooth never hurts in the dentists chair". I hated to send it to the dealer to fix, having no clue what it could be.

Took it to Beamen Toyota around lunch time Friday IIRC, thinking I'd H8 to spend the weekend w/o it. They said it would be the next day or Monday for I'd get it. Called them right at 5:00 that day and they said it was ready and had been fixed for some time now. For less than $200 they had diagnosed the problem and fixed it...(but not before I managed to kick the dash out after a stall on a twisty mountain road w/ cliffs for shoulders and it happened in the only place I could get it off the road) a loose EFI or ignition fuse connection under the fuse, in the box. I can't remember.


Sorry I don't have the invoice, and can't "prove it", but that's my story.

As a rule I don't do dealerships. But in this case I was more than happy for their assistance.

Not only did they fix it, but I was amazed at what they charged me.

Very nice.
 
No problems with the local Toy dealership here, but Canadian shops aren't too familiar with the 80 as it was never available domestically here (although the LX450 was). Getting parts can be a PITA, and they service staff don't have as much experience on 80s as a US dealer would.

Once a few years ago a different Toyota dealer left a chunk of 2x4 in the engine compartment of a 22RE 4Runner I had in for a new timing chain. The wood fell onto the downpipe, caught fire and nearly burned the truck down, but apart from that.... no complaints. :rolleyes:
 
You may or may not have valid claims. I bristle at the term "stealership" and based on my experiences, tend to take the dealer side. Frankly I see no "tech" side to these sort of threads. You want to vent ... cool, I get that but take it to chat. (just my opinion... obviously Romer and Reffug feel it is appropriate I'm not trying get THIS thread moved).

Along that line. We have some very knowledgeable people on this board and I know that most will disagree but I just don't see the value in having this group second guess a shop's diagnosis, it is all second hand info and we are not always in a position to say yeah or nay when they suggest a specific course of action.

I don't feel good, the doc said I have cancer ... what do you guys think is wrong?:rolleyes:

I honestly don't understand the logistics of how a tech gets paid, but I would hope the tech gets paid his hourly rate and that things like this balance out for the overall service department.

When I was at the dealer (10 yrs ago) our shop, and most others, paid the techs by "flat rate" meaning he gets paid a set amount of time to do a specific job. The dealer usually sets the number of paid hours for the interval services (i.e. 15K, 30k 60K etc) and for repairs it come from one of several books that list repair times for specific jobs.
For instance replacing a starter might list for 1.5 hrs. The mechanic gets paid 1.5 hrs regardless of how much time it takes .. he is a super genius and does it in .5 then he pockets the extra time but a couple rusty bolts or problems and 2.5 hrs later ... well, he still gets paid 1.5.
Most good techs can "flag" (meaning chargeable time) 12-14 hrs in an 8 hr day but somedays they get 6 so it isn't all roses.

The system bites the customer on some jobs and the tech on others. I used to do lots of taillight bulbs, air filters (not all .. some are a bitch) wiper blades, etc. right in the service drive. Sometimes the dealer decides there is a .5 minimum to pull a car in the shop or there wasn't a flat rate for the job and so the tech wanted to charge "straight time".
That meant the customer paid for every minute the tech was on that job ... not just the time to put in a bulb.
So from getting the ticket, to walking to the car and pulling it inside, going to the parts counter and standing around waiting for the part, the install and reparking the car ... the tech spent 30-40 minutes and wants to get paid for all that, especially since he might lose out on a "good" job in the mean time. Suddenly a bulb replacement is $70 so rather than explain why ... I just did the work.
Keep in mind that same tech will replace a couple burned out bulbs and the wiper blades for free if he is doing an interval service.

Diagnosis can fall into the straight time realm since in many cases he just needs to poke around. MANY times you can estimate the diagnosis time to include the repairs. This is very common on wiring problems ... by the time you figure out what it is, you have fixed it.

Diagnosing a "noise" can be extremely time consuming and can even require two techs to pinpoint. I have had cases where the tech was hearing a noise he considered significant and began chasing it down. He finds a problem and fixes it when in fact that noise wasnt bothering the customer because it had been there so long. The customer was actually hearing a "new" noise that was very minor and the tech heard and ignored it. Communications issue not a "ripoff".

The tech get paid an hourly wage for his flagged time. The less experienced guys get paid less per hour than the Master Techs but the shop charges the same shop rate. Yes, $90-120+ per hour is alot but it cost a lot to run a shop in terms of lights, heat, shop equipment, formal training by Mr Ts best and don't forget the advisor's pay.
 
Saying stearlership in the title is painting with a broad brush, more like the title should have been "had a bad experiance at a dealer"

I have had good and bad experinaces. In a dealer I have lerned a mechanic will take a quick assesment, look in the book for the qouted hours and likely tell you the part needs to be replaced. Remember, they usually work on near new in warranty vehicles, so if there is a leak there is a major problem.

I was told I needed to replace my Power Steering hear box. Nothing wrong with the gearbox, the Hydrolic hose just needed to be tightened. I don't fault the dealer for telling me that based on they way they work. I was getting atrany fluid exchange and they called to see if I wanted it done, no thanks.

Another thing to think about, if something has a slight leak, almost more of a sweat, the dealer will say replace it to get it back to perfect, where you or I may say its not leaking and not a problem, so leave it.

They are not experianced into digging into the older vehicles and troubleshooting. They are use to replacing under warranty and sometimes their first opinion is wrong so they replace something else.

Thats why it pays to know a shop that knows these vehicles. Tell a Dealer your having problems with a starter, and they replace. A small shop will know about swapping starter contacts and save you a lot of money.

So I realize, they take a quick look see some oil or grease or something and give you a quick estimate to replace everyting even if its a $10 hose at fault. I only go there when there is something that just is much easier for them to do and in-espensive, like it isn't worth my time. $100 to do a complete fluid exchange on my tranny, isn't worth my time. A front axle job that costs $1000 in labor, thats worth my time to do myself.
 
You live in Boulder so one of the best 80 series mechanics in the country lives just up the hill from you.

If you search on the name Robbie or Powderpig you will se people have flown him across the country to do their Headgaskets. 5 guys set up a time in California for him to come out and do all 5 of their trucks. He doesn't have a shop and works a mobile service. PM him on here, his name is Powderpig

Additionally, there is Sleeoffroad. They do excellent work and you can get that rear bumper of slider put on while your there. They are located in Golden.

On the east side of the metro area is IRBIS offroad.

The above three really know our trucks and all three are members of the local Rising Sun 4WD club. Come to the next meeting and you likely could talk to at least one of them about your truck.


Interested in Rising Sun? Join us for a meeting... - Rising Sun Member Forums
 
Just a thing or two to add. I used to work at a VW dealership and saw what was going on with the sales staff and the service staff. I just want to point out that there are two sides to everything. People who are not happy with the so-called "stealerships" have been burned and that I have no doubt in. But there are other dealerships that provide excellent service and satisfaction. When I worked in cars, I had a customer that walked in to Tynan's VW (Aurora, CO) who had left his car for a service and the tech dropped the ball somehow and didn't complete it the same day as promised. His daughter was leaving for Ft. Collins, CO the next morning; approximately 80 miles away and needed the car. Understandably the customer was fuming and angry at how this could happen. The general manager of the dealership offered to pay for their gas, gave them a brand new Jetta to drive and offered to have their car trailered to Fort Collins (80 miles) when completed.

Granted, you may have had a bad experience but that's not all dealerships. I can tell you my parts guys at the dealerships in Denver that I go to as I have built a relationship with them. I can even tell you their significant other's name, their kids and in turn they can remember my 98 4runner and 96 LX. Over the weekend, I cleaned the birfs and ordered parts from CDan. I did that because I know the expertise that CDan has is invaluable. If Dan were to charge full list (Dan, don't get any ideas) I would pay that happily because of his knowledge. The same principle for the dealership, I can do a lot of wrenching on my truck but if it comes down to something I don't know, I will have to pay a premium for it.

Ex: Tranny rebuild; can people on mud lead the way for me to do so? For sure. Do I want to know, or trust in my capabilities to do so? Not a chance. This is where the premium comes in.

Wow that was probably the longest post I have made on this forum yet.

Regards,
Q

Everyone has their limits
 
Other than the title, I think I was very clearly referring to a single dealership. I was just venting, and now that I think about it, it is probably more appropriate for chat. Didn't expect to ruffle so many feathers! Thanks to those of you that work at dealerships and do your best to be honest and fair. I have no problem paying for services of skilled technicians, I just want to be able to trust them.
 
Back
Top Bottom