If the part number is still active and authorized dealers are sending it out, it should be a genuine Toyota part.
However, as with oil filters, Toyota has switched manufacturing to other countries than Japan. However, those labels should indicate the country of origin, usually typed in black ink, in a space left on the label that uses red ink.
It's hard to believe anyone could infiltrate the Toyota parts organization and substitute parts that are not authorized if you received this part from 2 different authorized sellers. Yes, people do buy original, put their own cheap aftermarket part back in the bag and seal it up and return it for a refund. But again randomly, not on a large enough scale that you found this problem in 2 different places.
For those of us who buy authentic parts to replace on our vehicles, because we trust them to be as strong and well-built as the originals, if we learn that Toyota has cheapened their construction, reliability, and materials and/or has mis-stated their place of manufacture...................then the marketplace will speak by refusing to buy Toyota-branded items at a premium and we will hunt down the very best aftermarket replacements which should be at a much-reduced price.
Knowing that response, Toyota would be foolish to engage in deceptive advertising and thereby lose a tremendous amount of income, not just from the limited Land Cruiser crowd, but once word got out, customers for their other vehicles here and around the world.
There was in the past an outcry when Japanese manufacturers started building some of their vehicles here in the USA, in an effort to bypass restrictive import regulations. People wanted the true Japanese product, made in Japan, and quality was believed to take a nose dive. That hasn't been true, however. Toyota carefully monitored the entire process, as they have done in other countries as well. So...........with that in mind, manufacturing in China or anywhere else is okay with me, as long as the end product is truly the same in all respects.
But Toyota needs to be honest and not misrepresent any aspect of those parts. I would write a letter to your dealer sources adding photos of the labels in question and ask for an explanation. If they sidestep it, go over their heads to a district manager and beyond. Hopefully you have not discovered a new trend and hopefully none of us need to rethink where and what we purchase.
Again, thanks for the heads-up.