Synthetics

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 2, 2017
Threads
86
Messages
701
Location
Tustin, California
There are plenty of threads to go through but wanted to talk about oil choices in 2017 for the 1FZ.
 
Last edited:
If you like the M1 then run it but use a very good filter so you can run it 15k thereby lowering the cost of oil change maintenance.

The wix is a decent filter but there are better. Currently I'm running a Toyota 15600-41010 but on the shelf is a Baldwin B2 hpg for next time. The Baldwin is cheaper and it's a top notch filter. I can't find any specs on the toyota filter but the Baldwin is rated at 6 microns nominal and 20 microns absolute. Those are phenomenal numbers. The only filter I know of that's better is the Donaldson filter I run on my Cummins, it's adsolute at 15 microns.

Absolute is 98.7% or better.
 
I have been using Mobil 1 for years, obviously no problems. That said a recent post from the Bob The Oil Guy's website had a pretty in depth report on oils. Basically, all the major brands of oil are more than adequate. The difference between a high dollar oil and "standard" grade oil is minuscule. His advice, save money and get the off the standard stuff. There is not enough difference between them to justify the difference. If you search, you will find the report here on MUD.

Personally, I will be changing to a less expensive oil because of this but, I will still use a high dollar filter, such as the Mobil 1 or buy the Japanese Toyota filters from Beno.
 
I have been using Mobil 1 for years, obviously no problems. That said a recent post from the Bob The Oil Guy's website had a pretty in depth report on oils. Basically, all the major brands of oil are more than adequate. The difference between a high dollar oil and "standard" grade oil is minuscule. His advice, save money and get the off the standard stuff. There is not enough difference between them to justify the difference. If you search, you will find the report here on MUD.

Personally, I will be changing to a less expensive oil because of this but, I will still use a high dollar filter, such as the Mobil 1 or buy the Japanese Toyota filters from Beno.

Makes sense. I will for sure be going and checking out that report. I've sworn by Mobil 1 for years, but could use the money to invest into my rig if I'm being quite honest.

I am using a WIX 51515, have it on the shelf for my next oil change. Is this an adequate filter? I've heard a lot of great things here on MUD.
 
I look at it in a different way.

My oil changes are around 5000 miles apart. I use synthetic oil every time and of course replace the oil filter with every oil change.

Overkill? I don't know. Peace of mind? Yes. Expensive? Not really. About $40 per oil change.
 
I look at it in a different way.

My oil changes are around 5000 miles apart. I use synthetic oil every time and of course replace the oil filter with every oil change.

Overkill? I don't know. Peace of mind? Yes. Expensive? Not really. About $40 per oil change.

For me its about $55 to do an oil change with Mobil 1/Toyota Filter here in So Cal. Walmart has the best price on oil, and I need 8 freakin quarts of oil.
 
I use Rotella T6 from Walmart. Once or twice a year there is a coupon for $5 off per gallon. It comes out to about $16 per gallon, plus the cost of a filter. Otherwise, it's about $45 - $47.
 
I have been running T6 and had a good oil analysis report from blackstone. It's cheaper than Mobil 1 when purchased at walmart. I like and use mobil 1 in some of my other vehicles, and used to run it in my LX450, but switched to T6 several years ago in the LX450.

But as stated, they are all good oil and one shouldn't lose a lot of sleep over any of them. 25 years ago my habit was to use what ever dino oil was on sale and change it every 3k miles. All my engines lasted fine and had no abnormal wear. Choosing the correct viscosity is probably a more critical aspect than the oil brand or type.
 
I look at it in a different way.

My oil changes are around 5000 miles apart. I use synthetic oil every time and of course replace the oil filter with every oil change.

Overkill? I don't know. Peace of mind? Yes. Expensive? Not really. About $40 per oil change.
Over kill? Yes? I can't understand why you would run an excellent oil and an average filter. Run a very good filter and be done for 15k. Confirm this will oil analysis.
 
I've only used Toyota filters till recently when they are not available anymore, except for the ones made in Thailand. If Wix fits the bill, oh well. Can't be all that bad compared to what else is currently available on the market. At least it is the large size one.
 
I've only used Toyota filters till recently when they are not available anymore, except for the ones made in Thailand. If Wix fits the bill, oh well. Can't be all that bad compared to what else is currently available on the market. At least it is the large size one.
Baldwin B2 HPG. Go 15k with M1
 
I apologize, this is a reason I don't get asked to many parties...I tell long stories...but...here goes...

I managed an oil product line for many years and that doesn't make me a chemist by any measure. It just means I spent some time talking to people that actually make oil and additives for it.

If you don't know, there are groups of base oils. Mineral oils are Group 1, 2, 3, and Synthetic is Group 4. There is also a mythical 5th group that is primarily esters and anything else that doesn't fit in the other groups.

Every engine oil you add to your car contains some Group 2 base oil. This is either as a base stock or as an additive stock because the additive packages cannot bind with Group 4 oils (PAO) and thus need a carrier to stay in suspension. (so, technically you could argue there is no such thing as a "Full" synthetic)

Group 3 oils by benefit of USA law can be categorized as a synthetic in the USA while only being highly refined crude oil. If using a full synthetic matters to you, shy away from oil companies that support group 3 as a full synthetic - looking at you CASTROL and SHELL. Outside the USA, Group 3 is a mineral oil that cannot be sold as synthetic.

Base oils help you achieve one thing - viscosity while the engine is cold or the number before the "W". Mineral oils don't get to 0 weight, struggle with 5 weight and are usually a 10 weight. After that point there is very little differences between "synthetic" vs "mineral". The primary difference is shear resistance and how much viscosity modifier is added.

The most critical factor when choosing an oil is the credibility of the oil company blending it. Whether they can back up their claims with real data is how I measure them. Mobil 1 and Motul are two companies with great reputations supported by data and they are chased by an industry trying to beat them. (I was one of them)

Bargain oils are going to use bargain additive packages while premium oils from premium companies are going to add extra additives or use more of expensive additives. Bargain oil companies can't use the same packages and still make their price point. The additives are what make the oil you buy perform the way it does.

Even with the best oil on the market, without detailed oil analysis on a regular basis, anything you decide to do with your engine is going to be based on a hunch if you aren't following the manufacturers recommendations. The only way to truly tell when and how often oil should be serviced is by detailed oil analysis.

I am not going to talk you out of the oil you use or how long you wait to service it, I wasted a lot of time on those arguments and I am done doing it. I'll just tell you what I learned and let you decide what you do.

I used to use Mobil High Mileage in my truck and have since decided to try DELO based on some opinions on this forum and reading up on it. I also use Napa Gold filters (the long can 1515) because Napa is closer than Toyota, I'd be using Toyota filters otherwise. I change the oil in my cruiser when my other cars oil change light comes on. Not because the cruiser actually drove any distance (it isn't a daily driver) but because oil oxidizes and should be changed at the very longest every six months, regardless of miles.

Story time:
One particularly gray haired scientist told me where he had heard the origins of 3000 mile oil changes came from. He said that there was a conundrum when engines got oil sumps. Before the sump was invented, oil just sloshed out or was burned by the engine. That made servicing easy because the reservoir was empty or you added more fuel that contained lubricant. When sump engines were run in factories or commercially they typically measured by hours of use. Engines with filters would get serviced every 50 hours of use and engines without filters were serviced every 25 hours. They needed a way for passenger car owners to know when to service their engines. The problem was people didn't usually keep track of how many hours their engine ran, they only kept track of miles. So an engineer came up with 3000 miles intervals because if you drove 60 mph for 3000 miles it would be 50 engine hours.

I believed him, because it made sense...he could have been telling me a story though because he liked to pull my leg sometimes. HA!
 
Last edited:
The most critical factor when choosing an oil is the credibility of the oil company blending it. Whether they can back up their claims with real data is how I measure them. Mobil 1 and Motul are two companies with great reputations supported by data and they are chased by an industry trying to beat them. (I was one of them)


Thanks for your input.
My car calls for Shell special formula, prior to Shell they required a special Castrol oil, which is no longer available.
The way I read your post, it seems like those two companies do not produce really high quality oils. Did I get that right?

What is your take on Rotella T6? They recently altered their formula, less zinc content I believe.
 
I found the link to the oil report.

https://gallery.mailchimp.com/f6413...e6-44ac-42f3-bf55-9dcaa234d223/Aug_17_ENG.pdf

Much of the information listed above, by proven, I have seen before, again why I have been using Mobil 1. I also have relied upon a report about oil filters from another forum, and yes, I know it is heresy.

Oil Filter Comparison Study - GM Truck Central

This is beating a dead horse, much like tire arguments, but can be fun. Arguing about a 10th of 1 percent improvement, while accurate, probably is not worth the argument. Will any of us recognize a HP gain of .2 HP on our rigs? No, we won't, and spending money on chasing it is, well, just plain dumb in my opinion. The testing results by BTOG pretty much sum that up. Is one oil better than the other? YES and that is incontrovertible. But is the gain worth it?

Now please realize that I am a bit anal when it comes to my truck. I am always trying to find the best but almost always must compromise because my last name is not Gates, as in Bill. I just rebuilt my engine about 20k miles ago and do not want to do it again! I will spend $ to make sure I don't do it again but, why throw $20 bucks away every oil change for a 1/2 part per million improvement? Dunkin Donuts needs my money too!

I am a nobody when it comes to this. Proven obviously is an expert, so are Cary and RavenTai (see Oil Recommendations and Discussion Thread for FAQ ). Trust expert opinion and facts and feel free to form your own opinion after listening to them. The bottom line, you are going to do what you want regardless of their opinions. So, let the :deadhorse: begin.
 
Does anyone pour some oil inside the oil filter prior to installing it?
I don't because I don't like oil all over my shop floor. I assume you are referring to a stock 80 series.

My Cummins filter goes on full of oil because it mounts hole side up like it should.

Any motor oil on the shelf will work fine. Will some be more ideal than others? Probably so. Match cheap oil to average (not cheap not fram) filter and change out more often. Match high end oil with a well built, "bullet proof" filter that has above average filtering capability and holding capacity so you can run that expensive oil longer.

Would you put bias ply pizza cutters from yesteryear on a brand new corvette? I think not.

As for motor oil; it's all in the additive package. Research Lubrizol.
 
Last edited:
Does anyone pour some oil inside the oil filter prior to installing it?

Yes, I fill it and then saturate the media by rotating it multiple times. I usually do this at least twice before installation. I go at least half way full after that before reinstalling. I place rags or paper towels directly under where the filter is installed and have minimal clean up afterward.
 
I always run synthetic in my motorcycles, because it gives better shifting, supposedly resists wear, and supposedly is more stable at higher temperatures.

After years of putting synthetic in my cars, I realized:

1) none of these conditions apply.

2) I'm more likely to end up with a wrecked vehicle than an engine that died of oil-preventable causes (sold my carefully doted-over Grand Cherokee to my dad and a guy ploughed into him within a year).

3) synthetic oil isn't going to turn a 300k motor into a 600k motor. It's going to turn it into a 350k motor.

Your Land Cruiser is most likely to die of a catastrophic head gasket failure, or an oil pump failure, or getting rolled, T-boned, etc. Save your money, run a reputable standard oil and buy ten packs of Toyota filters.
 
I don't because I don't like oil all over my shop floor. I assume you are referring to a stock 80 series.

My Cummins filter goes on full of oil because it mount hole side up like it should.

Any motor oil on the shelf will work fine. Will some be more ideal than other? Probably so. Match cheap oil to average (not cheap not fram) filter and change out more often. Match high end oil wih a well built, "bullet proof" filter that has above average filtering capability and holding capacity so you can run that expensive oil longer.

Would you put bias ply pizza cutters from yesteryour on a brand new corvette? I think not.

As for motor oil; it's all in the additive package. Research Lubrizol.

My old GFs grandfather was a Lubrizol executive back in the day and he said all oil is the same except for the additive packages they put into the oils.
 
Does anyone pour some oil inside the oil filter prior to installing it?

I do, because it's not hard to do. sometimes I push on the check valve flap to speed up the filling process. Sometimes there's a bit of cleanup, but not really, because there's some dripping when the old filter was removed. And I've got a pan under there anyways. So a spritz of brake cleaner to clean up the new oil drip plus the old one, it's all done at once.

As for oil, I run toyota 0w20 which is the least expensive 'synthetic' oil available in Canada. Also a toyota yzzd3 filter, because that's what they sell at the Toyota and Lexus dealers.

/2cents/
 
Back
Top Bottom