starter questions

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Mace said:
That is the funny thing... I tried that..

But.. I might have been on the wrong side of the dual battery solenoid..

I am not the brightest sometimes...


You tried it and what happened?

Umm, the right side would be the battery + (red) post with the big wire that goes directly to your starter. If you run a wire from the + post to the + post of the coil and it still won't start, chances are that it is not a problem with the ignition switch or its circuit.

If you use a separate battery from another car to power the ignition by jumping to the + side of the coil (it needs to be grounded to your frame too and you are using your own battery to crank it) and it starts right up, then you can be reasonably sure that it is the voltage drop while cranking that is the problem.

The solution for the voltage drop problem is the OEM Toyota coil with the external resistor and add the bypass wire from starter to the coil + lug. Toyota wouldn't have gone to the expense and trouble to do this if it wasn't necessary.
 
When I jumped the coil I used the dual battery solenoid (glorified starter solenoid)
What I was saying is that I have a dual battery system and only one battery hooked up (trying to reduce potential issues) I might have actually hooked up the jumper to the non battery side of the solenoid.

Now, if I can hear the dual battery solenoid clicking on and off when I put the key into the "start" position (with no starter attatched) it sounds like I have a bad connection somewhere...


Pin, the only reason I am hesitant to run the ballast resistor is because I have never seen one used on a fully electronic ignition and for the last 10 years or so I have had the same basic ignition setup and it has not been a problem.. Why would I suddenly need something when I never needed it before?
 
Mace said:
Why would I suddenly need something when I never needed it before?

Well, that is an interesting question. What did you do just before this problem popped up?

OTOH, you might have always been on the ragged edge of this happening and now something is taking a little more current, the battery isn't putting out as much or there is a little more voltage drop and SMACK.

It really doesn't matter what kind of coil you run as long as it makes a spark. Yours isn't cutting it under the present circumstances.

My point is that Toyota wouldn't have gone to the trouble of engineering the ballast bypass circuit if there wasn't a problem with this. Their solution works.
 
"the battery isn't putting out as much or there is a little more voltage drop and SMACK"

putting a ballast in the line of this smack will only worsen the issue. Cause a ballast purpose in life is to drop voltage to the coil...normally I follow you pretty good Pin...am I missing something here ?

"My point is that Toyota wouldn't have gone to the trouble of engineering the ballast bypass circuit if there wasn't a problem with this. Their solution works."

I have a theory on this whole ballast bypass issue...oh WTF why not throw it out.

First there was no ballast and no bypass...yea points were getting worn but they are/were cheap and everybody replaced them back in the day as often as our latter day maintenance freaks change their oil. Also, again back in the day peeps did not put a gazillion miles a year on their cars and points life was deemed adequate. Geologic time passes enter the late sixties and ign systems go to 12 volt (at least 1967 for VW IIRC), people are putting way more miles per month on their lowly points/condensor ign systems...and hit me with a brick points are wearing out faster. Enter the ballast resistor. Viola, points life extended by 2x. Now the little biatch, especially those with tiring coils won't start for shizzle under certain conditions. Enter the 12v ballast bypass on start up only. I'll pass the speculative soap box now...as I need another glass of wine :cheers:
 
toddslater said:
Pin...am I missing something here ?

Ummm, Yes. Just the first two threads and the first page of this one. :flipoff2:

Yes, the purpose of the ballast resistor is to drop the voltage.

It is not there to deal with points burning; thecondensor does that.
It is part of the solution to the starting problem due to voltage drop while engine cranking.

The solution to the starting problem is to use a coil that operates at 6-8 volts because the voltage drops this low sometimes during cranking. This creates a new problem: If ou run this coil at 12V it will burn out and the solution to this is to add a ballast resistor in the ignition circuit when it is running, but not cranking.

The wire from the starter solenoid bypasses the ballast temporarily during cranking only so that it will get the full 6-8V that it needs to make a spark.
 
Second problem.. the electronic module needs something like at least 10 volts to work..

I think that is my main problem. Not as much the coil voltage..
 
I have,
It drops down to 5 volts or so..

I talked to the builder of the hyfire/MSD. Both require more voltage to continue running than 6 volts..
 
OK, now you are getting somewhere. What does the voltage drop to directly across the battery when it is cranking? If there is a big difference, like a couple of V, then the ignition wire has too much resistance and it should start right up if you jumper wire the coil and ignitor directly to the battery.

That voltage is way low to run the coil. If the battery voltage also drops to 5V, then something is fawked at the battery. Either the battery is bad or its wiring is bad (like the dual battery isolator setup). My single red top only drops to 10V during cranking.
 
Okay

This weekends project ;)
 
Pin_Head said:
Yes, the purpose of the ballast resistor is to drop the voltage.

It is not there to deal with points burning; thecondensor does that.

Correct me if I'm wrong....but the condensor merely stores the energy while the points are open. The energy it stores is dictated by the coil. The energy the coil delivers is dictated by the energy it receives. On a ballast system the energy the coil receives is regulated by the ballast.

And yes ..I do believe I was awake on page 1 when I said that the 12v electronic ign systems marketed by MSD need/require 12v. :flipoff2:

As Poser said the prob is in switch or the wire itself to your ign system.
 
Also, if your dropping some serious voltage ....I am inclined to agree with one of the early early posts...your starter is huffed and sucking the life out of the rest of your ign system.
 
toddslater said:
Correct me if I'm wrong....but the condensor merely stores the energy while the points are open. .

The main thing the condensor does is attenuate the arc across the points as the field collapses in the primary to generate the high tension spark in the secondary. The spark is also propagated across the points as they open.

The ballast resistor limits the amount of power the coil sinks so that it doesn't melt down. All coils need to have a certain amount of impedance whether it is an external resistor or internal to keep them from overheating.
 
toddslater said:
Also, if your dropping some serious voltage ....I am inclined to agree with one of the early early posts...your starter is huffed and sucking the life out of the rest of your ign system.
Post #34,

Starter tested out perfect..
 
Mace said:
Post #34,

Starter tested out perfect..

You never know about the lug nuts at the parts store. They probably just hooked it up, noticed that the motor turned and said that "it's all good", never mind that it was sucking up twice the current that it is supposed to.

The armature can get shorted out and you have to take it apart to test it reliably.
 
Actually it was hooked up to a meter that tested for resistance, power consumption and something else.

The test was counter idiot proof (theoretically)
:)
 
Back
Top Bottom