Starter contacts replaced - con't starting issues

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 7, 2004
Threads
37
Messages
258
Location
S. Texas
Last week I replaced the starter contacts (last done June 2005), only one looked slightly worn, the other had two wear spots, not the normal semi-circular pattern. Initially it seemed to correct the non-starting issue. Now what happens is I turn the key all the way to the right, all accessories come on, I'm pretty sure I hear the solenoid clicking but there is no turn over. If I con't to hold the key in the start position or try and rotate the key harder it will start, sometimes it sounds like the battery is weak and sometimes it cranks like it should. I need to have the battery checked (Optima red top).

I have read most of the old posts on starter issues - focusing on roncruiser's case. Is this pointing to the ignition switch or a new starter? Thanks, Nelson
 
It probably is the solenoid. You're better off getting a new starter. It could be the ign. switch but I replaced that as well and it turned out that was still in working condition.
 
It sounds like a bad contact at the ignition switch. To confirm hook a volt meter to the start wire at the starter and compare when the voltage comes on vs starter response. If there is voltage to the starter and no starter response it's probably the starter, if no voltage to the starter when the key is turned, probably the switch and/or connections.
 
Ron - thanks for your response; all is still well with the new starter? Your suppose to respond with the cheaper part as being the fix.

Kevin - I'm not great with electrical issues. Using a volt meter, set on DC, connect red wire on volt meter to which wire? - the small black wire and try the key? and/or the large wire from the battery (?) to the starter and try the key? I don't have any alligator clips to hold the wires on at the moment. Thanks, Nelson
 
Poor grounds could do the same thing. I would think it would be cheaper to replace the solinoid then the whol;e starter.

Everyone jumps on contacts everytime there is a starting issue. If what you heard was clicking, I would have started with grounds and then solinoide.

You can always take it to an autoparts store that tests them for free.

You could also use on of those starter cables that allow you to crank the starter directly and this would rule out the ignition.
 
...
Kevin - I'm not great with electrical issues. Using a volt meter, set on DC, connect red wire on volt meter to which wire? - the small black wire and try the key? and/or the large wire from the battery (?) to the starter and try the key? I don't have any alligator clips to hold the wires on at the moment. Thanks, Nelson

The smaller clip-on wire is the one that comes from the switch, that's the one we are looking for. In spots like this, I make a jumper wire for testing, take a short piece of wire and put a spade on one end and a butt connector on the other. Unplug the starter wire and plug in the wire like an extender, then you can strip a spot, probe it etc, without damaging the stock harness.

Poor grounds could do the same thing. I would think it would be cheaper to replace the solinoid then the whol;e starter.

Everyone jumps on contacts everytime there is a starting issue. If what you heard was clicking, I would have started with grounds and then solinoide.

...

On reduction gear starters the solenoid is built in. The plunger is the "solenoid plunger", the contacts are "solenoid contacts". So by replacing them your rebuilding the solenoid.:D
 
Well, I only did the contacts and not the plunger - possible issue or not? Nelson

Yes, it's a "possible" issue, but they are pretty durable, I usually only replace it with every other set of contacts. The plunger is basically a hunk of metal that the electro magnet pulls on and a ring that hits the contacts completing the circuit. If the ring isn't badly warn and the metal plunger isn't rusty, etc, causing it to stick, then your probably good to go.

You can test the starter operation by making a jumper wire to connect to the start terminal and touching it to battery hot. Each time it's touched the starter should run.
 
Update - with my daughter in town and two houses being re-modeled I had no time to try the wire/battery/starter test. One morning this week while changing the Suburban's oil I crawled under the LC and looked at the starter to make sure it was tight and in place, kind of bumped it. Also this week several starting episodes you could hear the screeching noise of when you go to start an engine that is already running, after two or three of those episodes the engine/starter is working/starting with no issues. Of course now my PO401 code is back - great. Thanks for all the info/help. Nelson
 
Back
Top Bottom