Sound Odd to You?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 23, 2009
Threads
5
Messages
11
Location
Camarillo, CA
Got a '95 with 146,000 miles on it and the knuckle seals were replaced 30,000 miles ago. Is it normal to have them go again so soon? Mechanic wants $1,000 to replace them now and it's rarely off the pavement :o.

But my first question was about the differential; started hearing noise and it appears to be a goner, too. From here on, what would be the recommended lubrication interval? I'm actually wondering if it has been properly serviced in the past, although I'm reading posts on this forum about dif weakness in some models.
 
Knuckle seals will eventually leak but shouldn't be too much of a concern unless they are leaking differential fluid in copius amounts(enough to create a puddle overnight).I would look at the receipt of the last knuckle work that was done and see what they replaced because they might have not done a complete job . What sounds are you hearing from the differential? Lubrication interval is the owner's manual and keeping an eye on any leaks on any vehicle is essential especially in anything over 10 yrs old.
 
They should last longer 30,000 miles. Take some pics of the knuckle so we can ensure you're not getting f'd. also $1K is WAAAAY too much for this job.
The knuckle seals don't "go" per-se. It's the inner axle seal that wears/fails and allows diff fluid to enter the knuckle and liquify the grease in the knuckle. It's that soup that leaks past the rubber wiper on the back of the knuckle pumpkin and saturate the felt cake up and drip of the knuckle.
Often this takes a long time, unless the axle oil seal was damaged (torn) during install (happens more often than mechanics tell you).
Need more info on the diff.
 
No puddles, although I have seen drops from time to time.
88K mi - Replace Front Differential pinion seal SPD Suspension/Axle
1 90311-38047 Seal, Type T Oil $10.71
2 75W-90 Synthetic Gear Oil $15
Labor $234
Total - $259.71

116K mi - Replace Knuckle Seals and Applicable parts, SPD replaced knuckle seals and applicable seals
776 CT10 $850
1 04434-60051 Gasket Kit, Fr Axle $208.86
2 90310-35010 Seal, Type S Oil $28.90
4 Brake Cleaner $33.28
Total $1,121.04

The say it was also inspected at 129K miles, but no service was performed - a second mechanic that checked the dif oil before I took it back to the Toyota shop (at 146K mi) said the oil looked very spent.
 
Is 776 CT10 the labor?

Who did the work? was it a dealership?

from that price I feel like it should have included wheel and knuckle bearings, but from the parts list it was just a seal job. that's probably 3-4 hours of labor total. I base that on the fact we can change a birf out in 45 minutes on the trail when it getting dark. less if you take the steering arms off and pull the whole knuckle as a unit.

Me thinks someone gots screwed.
Often the grease will also back flow into the diff oil when it sloshes around and mixes. Drain your diff and check the fluid, it could be thickened and/or have some other evidence of grease contamination. Let the oil set for a day and see what settles out. If the oil is beige an milky, that could be a sign of water intrusion, probably from the axle breather. Also a glogged axle breather can cause pressure build up in the housing and it forces diff fluid through the inner axel oil seal into the knuckle. Check for metal flakes and chips in the diff by sweeping your (latex gloved) finger around inside the drain hole and look on the plug. often there will be a silvery slime similar in look and feel to silver anti-sieze on the plug as well. in small amounts this is normal but chuncks and alot of that stuff usually means damage and that the fluid hasn't been changed in a while.
Searching your knuckle kit part number (04434-60051) lead me to a thread where CDan (toyota parts dealer) ID's a kit for $80 less than the one mentioned on your thread.
As an aside, on the rare occasion I take my vehicle to a Mechanic, I always tell them I want every part they remove from my truck back when they replace it. Now a dishonest mech may keep old parts around to make buck, but not likely, and Cruiser parts are fairly unique so the chances of the random mech having them around is slim.
 
Last edited:
If they changed the pinion seal they may not have set the preload correctly, leading to pinion bearing failure.

-Spike
 
Stump,
I agree with everything in your post #3 except....

... also $1K is WAAAAY too much for this job.

A skilled mechanic gets ~12 hours for this job done right. At current rates this is frequently $1,000-$1,200 just for the labor.

Yes, a trail repair of a broken birf can be done in about an hour on a FJ40 but very, very few people would be able to do a (warrant able) full front axle service on an 80-Series in 4 hours. In fact, I don't believe anyone can do it that fast even if they didn't warrant the work.

-B-
 
Fair enough, I agree with you that a skilled mech would do a warrantable job and I am way out of touch with shop prices since I try to avoid them as much as possible... So I plead ignorance :o The only job I've gone to a garage for in the last 10 years was for the HG on my LX450(It cost me $1500 labor and parts for the HG job... and that seems like a much more involved, albeit probably slightly less messy, job than a birf job.)
However, I'm saying that it doesn't appear to me to have been a full front axle service based on the parts breakdown. If the Mech only replaced the rear wiper and felt, and the inner axle oil seal then that is certainly not a 12 hour job.

I have done full services on both my LX and the FJ40. First go is definately slow, but I also through every bit that was gunked into the parts washer, cleaned and dried I also repainted the knuckles (I'm stupid anal sometimes) as well as degreased and regreased the birfs. Yes, it took about 14-18 hours of labor in my garage.

Cheers,
Stump




Stump,
I agree with everything in your post #3 except....



A skilled mechanic gets ~12 hours for this job done right. At current rates this is frequently $1,000-$1,200 just for the labor.

Yes, a trail repair of a broken birf can be done in about an hour on a FJ40 but very, very few people would be able to do a (warrant able) full front axle service on an 80-Series in 4 hours. In fact, I don't believe anyone can do it that fast even if they didn't warrant the work.

-B-
 
Stump,
I agree with everything in your post #3 except....



A skilled mechanic gets ~12 hours for this job done right. At current rates this is frequently $1,000-$1,200 just for the labor.

Yes, a trail repair of a broken birf can be done in about an hour on a FJ40 but very, very few people would be able to do a (warrant able) full front axle service on an 80-Series in 4 hours. In fact, I don't believe anyone can do it that fast even if they didn't warrant the work.

-B-

With a lift, a cabinet parts washer, and lots of air powered tools, this can be done by a good mechanic in under 3 hours. at 2 hours and 45 minutes, my brother ( a Dodge/Jeep/Mazda certified tech) was done, until he realized the passenger side dust plate was still laying on the lift (doh!) That's assuming you don't separate the birfields.

He called the sister Toyota dealer down the street, asked what the book rate was, and then asked when they might have an opening for another tech.:D
 
This is a repair you have to do yourself. If they replaced the seals and neglected the trunnion bearings, that's mechanical malpractice.

You need a full knuckle job. Parts are about $300. Wheelbearings and extra $100 or so. The labor is up to you, but a professional mechanic would charge at least a full day's work for this. So the crazy charges are not out of line. This is a job that takes awhile.

Consider learning, and doing it yourself, because only you will take the time to do it right.
 
at 2 hours and 45 minutes, my brother ( a Dodge/Jeep/Mazda certified tech) was done, until he realized the passenger side dust plate was still laying on the lift

I prefer that all parts get reinstalled correctly so that one doesn't count. :D

Seriously though... a helper or two really makes the job go a lot faster than a lift and air tools.

The guys in our local club are getting pretty good when doing the birfield parties. One or two guys kneeling in front of the knuckle installing parts, one guy reading instructions and torque specs, and one guy fetching tools and supplies, and one or two guys cleaning and fetching parts.

-B-
 
you sure your diff noise isn't a u-joint?
 
We still need more info on the noise itself. And again, pictures would be indispensable. Until then, it's all just fun and games saying mechanics don't know what they are doing and are irresponsible. But like my dad always asks, "Was it a mechanic, or a parts-changer?":hhmm:
 
OK - had the job done in the Toyota dealership, they did the dif and knuckle seals and discounted the workd by 50% (I think the service manager realized that something was foul). Here's the parts breakdown (costs are pre-discount):
Knuckle Seals:
1 04434-60051 Gasket Kit, Fr Axle - $231
2 90310-35010 Seal, Type S Oil - 32.30
Labor - $660

Differential:
1 41110-60370 Carrier Assy, Differ - $1,230
1 42181-060080 Gasket, Differ - $14.14
2 90310-35010 Seal, Type S Oil - $32.30
4 75W-90 Synthetic Gear Oil - $111.60
Labor - $880

Seems like a reasonable resolution to me - you?
 
Differential:
1 41110-60370 Carrier Assy, Differ - $1,230

Seems like a reasonable resolution to me - you?

In another thread, Beno mentioned this part is ~$600 (probably 'Mud discount). That price seems high but I guess if you only paid 50% of those prices you probably came out OK.

I still have a hard time believing the diff was bad at that mileage. Not impossible... just illogical.

-B-
 
OK - had the job done in the Toyota dealership, they did the dif and knuckle seals and discounted the workd by 50% (I think the service manager realized that something was foul). Here's the parts breakdown (costs are pre-discount):
Knuckle Seals:
1 04434-60051 Gasket Kit, Fr Axle - $231
2 90310-35010 Seal, Type S Oil - 32.30
Labor - $660

Differential:
1 41110-60370 Carrier Assy, Differ - $1,230
1 42181-060080 Gasket, Differ - $14.14
2 90310-35010 Seal, Type S Oil - $32.30
4 75W-90 Synthetic Gear Oil - $111.60
Labor - $880

Seems like a reasonable resolution to me - you?

Where are the new knuckle bearings? They didn't do the most important part of the job if they did not replace those.

$25 per quart for Synthetic gear oil is robbery ($7.99 = usual price for Mobil1). At least a new ddifferential is a good thing, even if pricy.
 
Back
Top Bottom