severe snow rated tire

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 10, 2007
Threads
60
Messages
814
Location
Phoenix, Arizona
I used search and came up with nothing on peoples experience with procomp a/t's. I've pretty much narrowed my search down to these or the bfg a/t's. Anyone have any experience with these?

I'm looking to get into a set of 5 tires (@ 285/75) and the 100$ yellow box for under a grand. I think I can swing the procomps for 850$-900$ installed. But are they a good tire?
 
No, I believe there have been some issues with them. I've seen them referred to as procrap's before. But as with everything there are exceptions.

Do a little goole search for "pro comp tires suck", and enjoy.
 
Ah, thanks for the input, I also ran across a couple bfg a/t vs procomp a/t threads, and it looks like the bfg's are the way to go.
 
BFG T/As. Best snow tire I ever used. 2x.

Sidewalls suck for off-road durability, but for on road snow, there are few better.
 
They where ok 15 years ago when I had them on my FJ40... But I hate the BFG's AT's on my 80 driving Anchorages sloppy, icy, snow packed streets... As heavy as the 80 is, they should be no where near as squirrelly as they are. No quick stopping. Will even spin all 4 tires at times to get going... Will never buy them again.

Will be trying some Revo's or Geolander AT's next time round, much better looking tread/sipe patterns on them...
 
I haven't tried them, but the Maine Warden Service is running Goodyear Silent Armor ATs on their full size 4x4 trucks, and the folks I talked to raved about their snow ability. To the extent that they claim they get much farther in 2wd than ever before (not sure what they used to run). A friend in SLC has them on his Sportsmobile and is happy with them. I used to run a set of Wrangler MTRs, which I felt were amazing rock/mud tires, but not so great in plowed (road) snow.

Snow is really hard to make all-encompassing tire judgements on, since there are many flavors of "snow conditions" but in Maine, we see most of them. Expensive tires, but built for vehicles the size/weight of 80s, and they carry the industry's severe snow service rating.
 
I'll be getting a set of Wild Country TXR's, siped and studded, once I track down a set of rims for the LX. We had a set on the 4Runner, performed well in snow and felt solid. They're a good choice if you need studs.

:cheers:
 
TRXUS MT's Nuff said!!!
 
When you say "severe snow rated" are you talking about playing off road? If you are then you wnt BIG and WIDE with little concern about the actual tread pattern. Think 40x18 and larger. Aired down LOW.

However if you are looking for a street tire to use in snow, ice and slush. Then look to dedicated snow tires. ATs and MTs are not snow tires. Regardless of brand. They all pretty much suck on slick roads compared to a true snow tires. All of them.

Add studs if you want the best peefromance. Although some of the new studless snow tires rival the performance of older design tires even w/studs.

Get them double studded for better snow/ice traction. This will sacrifice dry pavement adhesion a little bit.

Of course in Portland you really shouldn't have much need for real snowtires either.


Mark...
 
Thanks for all the replies guys. I mainly just wanted a tire that was decent for the little amount of offroading I do. I don't do anything major... yet. But also wanted a severe snow rated tire so I didn't have to put on chains if there was a chains required sign.

I actually already had the wife pick up the tires. Look like they should be the stock tire size. This is stock suspension too.
iaheeaabg.webp
 
But also wanted a severe snow rated tire so I didn't have to put on chains if there was a chains required sign.

In WA all it takes is to have 4wd to avoid using chains (Also you need proper snow rated tires, but very few SUV tires are not snow rated).

They do reserve the right to enforce chains even on 4wd vehicles, but I've never seen this done before.

Either way, carry chains. In severe ice they make driving easy as pie...though you do need to hop out into the cold and put them on for that to happen. Got some good use out of the chains this past winter. :doh:
 
TRXUS MT's Nuff said!!!

We have a winner. BFG AT's are a middle pack snow tire at best. Trxus MT's are unreal snow tires, they handle both icy hardpack and the deep stuff, BFG AT's suck at both of those because they freeze up in very cold temps and start to sled and don't have the tread for the deep stuff (wrong compound and wrong tread design for a true severe use snow tire).

For your use, get Revos or maybe the Yokohama AT's that have a silica compound base - the Yokos should be cheaper than the BFG's. My neighbor moved here from CA and I must have had to pull his sorry BFG AT shod ass out of the snow 6 or 7 times last winter, and he had to ditch his Tacoma more than once on the way home from work.

I told him to get Revos, which he did in the Spring, and had no issues with basic snow transportation after that and we still had some pretty big snows. He still can't do the deep stuff like you can do with a tire like trxus MT, but for general use even in a high snow zone (we got over 200" last winter) they are clearly a very good compromise, Yokos or Nittos for your budget.
 
Pro Comp MUD Terrains rule. I've had them on the company truck for almost two years from here to Moab to just recently the Rubicon Trail. They have excellent sidewall durability, they've been folded almost double over rocks, and speaking of, I've never had a flat. Pictures are the proof, see here:

https://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=177928&highlight=photos

http://www.4wdtoyotaowner.com/FZJ80.html

Maybe other Pro Comps like A/Ts and X-terrains suck, but Mud Terrains kick ass.



Company truck...:D:D:D There are a lot of people on here that I know would love to say that too...

barrypt5
 
Agree the 285/75 BFG AT suck in heavy wet snow. Never had an issue in deep powder (foot plus) but all other snow/slush conditions suck.
 
I have never been much of a fan of the BFG AT KO's for snow. I had them on my 60 for one winter. 33"x12.5"

The rubber compound is too hard when the temps drop. Great for tread life, sucks for snow and ice. 2nd, once the newness of the tread wears off (5-10K) they seem to really loose the little grip they had to begin with IMO. Just my .02 as someone driving in snow more than most.

Once my 80 gets its lift it will see a set of the Nokian's I posted above in 35". Yes they actually make them that big. Then I can run what ever I want in the summer.
 
Last edited:
I have never been much of a fan of the BFG AT for snow. I had them on my 60 for one winter. 33"x12.5"

The rubber compound is too hard when the temps drop. Great for tread life, sucks for snow and ice. 2nd, once the newness of the tread wears off (5-10K) they seem to really loose the little grip they had to begin with IMO. Just my .02 as someone driving in snow more than most.

Once my 80 gets its lift it will see a set of the Nokian's I posted above in 35". Yes they actually make them that big. Then I can run what ever I want in the summer.

The Nokians will be sweet - I had a similar set (much, much smaller :D) on a Sube and loved them. Not a drift busting tread design for sure, but I thought Nokians Silica compound line (the WR for sedans) was stickier on Colorado hardpack than their Hakka Q studless snows. You could just ease it out toward the predictable limits in a very low traction environment...too much fun to be safe :grinpimp:

Dead on description of BFG AT snow performance. At about 25 degrees it's like you just slapped on a set of racing slicks. My final BFG snow experience was sitting in my driveway fully locked and spinning all four in 8 inches of snow about 4 feet from my garage door as it got dark and having to get out and shovel - next day it was off to Discount Tire for the trxus. I'd be pissed if my minivan got stuck in those conditions, totally unacceptable for a dual locked 80 that can handle 2 feet of snow easily with good tires.
 
Back
Top Bottom