RE Brake Failure Thread

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jul 24, 2015
Threads
31
Messages
313
Location
Tampa
So i dont have to browse 41 pages of text, what are my options to replace the ABS accumulator/ motor that has failed?

dealer quoted $4200 for parts n labor. not keen on that price given that is about 40% of the value of the vehicle.
 
Depends on what part failed. A dealer likely won’t just replace the motor and accumulator (~$1,000), but will instead replace the entire assembly, which is a $2500-3000 part.
 
So i dont have to browse 41 pages of text, what are my options to replace the ABS accumulator/ motor that has failed?

dealer quoted $4200 for parts n labor. not keen on that price given that is about 40% of the value of the vehicle.
It would help to know what parts they're including and how much of that is labor.

I think this is the pump and motor assembly and it's only $765.82:


If you need the cylinder as well, then you're looking at $2,176.63:


Labor is pretty easy on the whole unit. Can't speak for the pump/motor assembly by itself.
 
It would help to know what parts they're including and how much of that is labor.

I think this is the pump and motor assembly and it's only $765.82:


If you need the cylinder as well, then you're looking at $2,176.63:


Labor is pretty easy on the whole unit. Can't speak for the pump/motor assembly by itself.
Yes they quoted for the whole unit plus master cylinder.

Been browsing the forum and it seems like replacing the entire thing is the way to go since they rest will likely fail at some point.

Might buy the unit myself and have it installed.
 
It would help to know what parts they're including and how much of that is labor.

I think this is the pump and motor assembly and it's only $765.82:


If you need the cylinder as well, then you're looking at $2,176.63:


Labor is pretty easy on the whole unit. Can't speak for the pump/motor assembly by itself.

IF replacing the pump and accumulator only (this is what I did) plan on also putting in a Master Cylinder kit and replacing the 3 grommets between the fluid reservoir and M/C. This will add about another $120.00 (shipped) to the total cost.

Grommets are easy to replace. Rebuilding the master cylinder is not complicated but DOES require care be taken NOT to score the bore of the cylinder. It is also possible that the master cylinder is not rebuild-able at all...due to maintenance neglect (lack of fluid changes). It might be rusty and pitted....so pull and inspect the unit BEFORE ordering parts.
 
That's around $102 per ih8mud page. Seems worth doing your homework.
If 'mud had a "search thread" function, and someone were to maybe search the thread for the word "solution", one might even be able to get the per page value up to $1000+ :)
 
He doesn't have as much of a following here, but a guy named Andy Le in Rancho Cordova, CA will send you an entire unit with rebuilt M/C, rebuilt motor, and pressure tested accumulator ready to drop in together. He's done tons of them, and is a good honest guy that knows his stuff. It was $550 I think for my '99, but later years are cheaper I think. A couple hundred dollar core charge until you send him back your entire unit. It was maybe $75 shipping to Ohio for me.
You can swap the whole thing in and out in less than an hour, not counting bleeding the brakes. I did mine in September, and its still working great. I think he does guarantee it for a year, too.
 
If it is like a majority of the brake failures where just the electric motor for the booster has worn out, you can have motor rebuilt to get you back on the road. Eurton Electric in Whittier CA is one vendor who provides this service. Their standard rebuild consists of new bearings, brushes, rewind the armature, install a new commutator and re-balance it. For standard turn around time they charge $265 plus shipping. I sent a motor to them earlier this week based on how long they have been in business and that they seem to be one of the few shops that advertises rebuilding motors for brake systems. I am not sure what the lifespan is on the LC brake accumulator, and pumps, but I don't recall reading about specific failures related to those components. However, some judgement of what the brake system overall health at the point of failure should be factored in. If the fluid in the system is highly contaminated, then replacing additional parts in the system may well be justified. Consideration to the miles on the vehicle and the type of driving it has seen may go into the decision as more stop and go driving will place more wear on all system components. At the end of the day it is all about risk vs dollars. The Toyota legal department is likely risk adverse in particular when they are at risk of being sued if something goes wrong with your brakes after repairing them and you are the one paying the bill to replace the parts. This could be why the dealerships are replacing the whole MC assembly. The vehicle owner has to look at the likelihood of a future failure if just the components that are bad or high wear are replaced by an independent shop or themselves and then consider how much they are willing to spend along with the consequences if something does fail in the future. Not easy decisions to make for the average vehicle owner based on limited information available on component lifespan. There is also risk that the people preforming the repair add to the equation, so choose whom does the wrenching carefully and if you choose to do the repair yourself, make sure it is within your skill set and follow the FSM where applicable. This forum is one of the few places that if you search through, you may be able to get a sense of component lifespan to help you make your decision. A big thanks to all the MUD members whom have diagnosed their brake system failures and have shared their findings. If you do get your whole unit replaced by the dealership, ask for your old unit back as it may have valuable parts to help out other MUD members who need them, and it can be diagnosed so we have more information on what component have actually failed. Best of luck
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom