perhaps you have a ramsey PTO box with a franken shaft to the OEM toyota winch?
Ramsey PTO gearboxes engage/disengage via cable linkage to a pull knob.
The problem is opposite. I have to use the REVERSE to wind, not play out the cable... still puzzled, but I am going to get under the truck this afternoon.
Is it possible you have the cable wound onto the drum the wrong way? This would cause the problem you are describing, provided everything else was kosher.
Last edited: