I'm using Nitto AT 315. On a verity of vehicles I have used, it seems that mud or ice can clog just about any tread. I have even seen knobbies on quads filled with ice or mud, and traction reduced to zero.
When I air down, clogging is a lot less. Tire flex forces junk from between tread blocks, helping to keep the tread clear.
Just before Christmas, I was up playing in both mud and snow. I crossed a long patch of level, very wet clay and then onto a steep downhill of shaded ice. The tread was loaded up with mud and then onto the ice where the truck acted like it was on skis! Scary, with a creek 50 feet straight down! I dropped pressure to 15 PSI, then gently let it creep down hill about 5 feet. The tread cleared out and the next 300 feet of steep ice was no problem. It took 30 minutes of finger-numbing cold to air back up (that's why I didn't air down first!) but low pressure did what no mud tire could have done.
I have used a lot of things on two very different trucks. I had OTD's on my Montero (40% tread block/60% voids) to having common street tires on the Cruiser to the Nittos. With enough muck available, all of them loaded up enough to become skis, but none of them could hold any muck when deflated.
A trick that I have found helpful is to use a good pure silicone lube in a spray can. Spray the clean, dry tread with it before going. This will help to clear muck from the tread voids. It is not that cheap, as you will use a lot of it on every trip.
Oh, and the Mastercraft OTD's that I had deserve a point of high praise, as well as a point of scorn. The OTD was an amazing traction tire, the slowest to load up of any tire that I have ever seen. I could stop the Montero in 30" of clay soup, and drive away like it was on dry pavement. I had 4-wheel double cleated chains for those tires, and rarely used them. I could climb a rock wall on a 1" ledge where a mountain goat would fear to tread. The tire was amazing with its traction for anyone who doesn't mind some tire noise. But it also had "glass" sidewalls. Thank God that I had hazard on those tires! I tore out more sidewalls with them than I ever have with any other tire! I used to run high-speed buggies, using the front tires as bumpers. I went thru a pair of front tires every 6 months! But I didn't cut as many sidewalls as I did with the OTD's on a slowpoke Montero! Mastercraft needs to work on the sidewall strength!
Nitto's are a different story. I have seen them with the sidewall pinched between a rock and a hard rim at 10 PSI, with no damage. With pressure reduced, the tread stays clear.