Opinion needed on electrical question...

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 15, 2004
Threads
50
Messages
276
Location
Southern AZ
My 72 '40 developed a short on the T/S switch, frying the T/S flasher and the "hot" line going to the voltage regulator from the ignition switch. I've replaced the flasher and have a t/s switch on the way (thx Ige). My question; since I cannot reach the "hot" wire going to the regulator under the dash, can I connect to another keyed on hot wire (such as the coil) to the regulator without any undesirable side effects? I can cancel the current wire and cap it, eliminating the shorted out one. Thanks in advance.
 
el_diabolico said:
My question; since I cannot reach the "hot" wire going to the regulator under the dash, can I connect to another keyed on hot wire (such as the coil) to the regulator without any undesirable side effects? I can cancel the current wire and cap it, eliminating the shorted out one. Thanks in advance.



Remove the instrument cluster, and figure out why it shorted.....


The LAST thing that I would think about doing would be "jumper wires"....not even a real repair....a poor bandaid at best...and a future headache for you or the next owner, for sure.


Good luck!


-Steve
 
Poser said:
... "jumper wires"....

Thanks for the quick reply. What I meant was completely replacing the circuit wire, connecting to the ignition switch, or say a terminal block being fed by the ignition to coil wire. Again thanks.
 
yes you can do exactly that. any ignition hot source will work. I had to do that with mine as the wire is hard to get to.
 
el_diabolico said:
since I cannot reach the "hot" wire going to the regulator under the dash, .

While it certainly will work, to tap into nother hot wire, I would recomend actually doing a proper repair to the harness. The first thing you need to know, is what shorted out and why. Then, the damaged wires need to be removed from the harness, all the way to where it starts, and new wires spliced in to replce the old. What you don't want to do is start choping up the harness and making an undocumented birds nest of wires that will cause more problems and be hard to fix.

All just my opinions though.
 
Steve C is so right! The shorted wire melted wires next to it in the harness as evidenced by the regulator wire frying. You are just asking for a harness fire if you don't find the source of the short. I personally would untape the harness and replace the bad wire while checking for damage to adjacent ones. Another thing, why did it not blow a fuse? Are you missing one somewhere? Have a fuse wrapped in foil in your box? :)

Remember a fuse is designed to protect the WIRE not the device the wire connects to.
 
Thanks for the replies. I believe the short is inside the t/s switch, as the positive wire goes from the ignition thru a fuse (no foil ;) ) taps into the flasher->splits to the t/s switch while the other goes to the reg. Yesterday I replaced all the wiring in the circuit with the same results. I work with 120, 240, 480Volts all the time, but it's those damn dc circuits that get ya every time!
 
Poser said:
how many electrical fires have you took on with a dry-chem unit?
None... Good point. ;)

The one fire I did have under the dash I was lucky enough to see the smoke and rush over there and was able to blow out the flames (small) with about 5 full breaths. Had one on board since that day, whether it will help or not I'm gonna use it.

What happens when your ass catches on fire? :eek: There's other @&@&@&@& inside your rig that's not made up of copper wiring that can catch along with it, like heater ducts, carpeting, seating, clothing, plastic wiring harnesses and insulation, your girlfriends hair, etc...

Better to have something than nothing bro. :frown: Wouldn't ya say? :)
 
Was simply posing the question...


I have been involved with some electrical fires....yes there are other things that can combust....yes something is better than nothing...however, dry chem does nothing to remove the heat that is generating the combustion...
 
el_diabolico said:
My 72 '40 developed a short on the T/S switch, frying the T/S flasher and the "hot" line going to the voltage regulator from the ignition switch. I've replaced the flasher and have a t/s switch on the way (thx Ige). My question; Thanks in advance.

If both of these wires burned out because of a short, you have some major non-standard and possibly unsafe wiring issues that you should look into before applying a bandaid.

1) Both the turn signals and the voltage regulator get power from the same 15 A fuse. The fuse should blow well before either of these wires would burn. You should figure out why. Did someone put foil over the fuse or replace it with a 50 amp fuse or bypass the fuse?

2). The voltage regulator and turn signal circuits are separate, which means that a single short cannot burn out both wires. This suggests that you have more than 1 short.
 
Again, thanks. I don't know why the fuse did not blow. It is not "foiled", and is the proper volt and amp rating for the circuit. I have not found the reason it shorted. I completely rewired the circuit (not band-aided), and the only thing I can find wrong is the t/s switch. The voltage reg and t/s switch do get their power from the same fuse, which is why I was referring to them as being on the same ckt.
 
el_diabolico said:
The voltage reg and t/s switch do get their power from the same fuse, which is why I was referring to them as being on the same ckt.

Yes, but they are separate branches in the sense that a single ground fault cannot account for why both of them would burn out. It is worth figuring out why they burned in the first place rather than just popping the fuse and why they are both burned. Just rewiring a bad circuit makes it possible to happen again.
 
Back
Top Bottom