To be fair, I turned around and bought the Cooper STT Pro and winter requirements are high on my list.
I posted this in the main km3 thread, and I’ll leave it here. Advances in tire compounds are occurring so rapidly that I think one selection criteria can simply be how new the tire is.
The ko2 won the ice test portion of a 3rd party run test in Sweden that Canadian tire did right at the time that tire was released. It got a perfect score. This was done on a frozen lake instead of in an ice rink like typical U.S. tests.
That test plus the advances Michelin (owns BFG) had made with getting long tread life out of its highly rated x-Ice winter tire series and how much market share BFG had lost to Goodyear’s Duratrac convinced me.......
43K miles later, consuming only 8/32 of tread in just about every condition except gumbo mud, and that theory played out. And it’s not like that tire has any actual siping.
This was part of my decision making on the STT Pro, which is a relatively new tire and Cooper won all kinds of tests with its innocuous looking AT3, including the deep comparison done by Expedition Portal.
First blush on the STT Pro is that it is embarrassingly civilized for such an aggressive tire and it rides a lot nicer than the ko2 in the 37” size (both D rated).
But the buyer right now has to make a bet. There isn’t much out there about the STT Pro, either, so you need to look across the product line and hedge a bet on what you see the manufacturer doing at the compound technology level and then see if your wallet is ok with a potential mistake.