My Knocking F

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Aug 7, 2003
Threads
295
Messages
2,786
Location
Cincinnati
I took my 73 FJ40 in for a tune up(adj carb, valves, timing, new plugs, remove some emmission stuff and reconnect some lines correctly(from a PO desmog). The motor has always started right up with good oil pressure, but as you drive it would drop below a 1/4 pressure on the guage. But it would still run decent. Oh on the comp. test, 1 and 5 I think were pretty high numbers like 170.
Thats the breif history.

Anyway driving it back from the tune(2 hours or so) It started knocking and losing power. Costed up and exit ramp and it was dead. So it was towed and put in my tiny garage. Just for the hell of it, I tried to start it up yesterday and it did somewhat easily. It did not sound good at all definately something knocking in there. I shut it off imediately.

So I am just looking for a place to start looking at the engine to fix it. Any help? Or should i just look for a used one? Thanks
 
Seems to me that you need to find out what's knocking before you make
your decision. Search here and at the LCML on "rod knock". It could be
the timing gears (check Jeff Zepp's web page). Mark W. and Pinhead
are two of the best internal engine guys on this board, perhaps one of
them will respond.
 
rgentry said:
Seems to me that you need to find out what's knocking before you make
your decision. Search here and at the LCML on "rod knock". It could be
the timing gears (check Jeff Zepp's web page). Mark W. and Pinhead
are two of the best internal engine guys on this board, perhaps one of
them will respond.


Heck, I don't even know where to start. I thought about taking off the oil pan and seeing if anything falls on my head.
 
Some people take a broom and saw off the handle to make a noise
checker. Put the broom handle on various parts of the engine while
its running and stick the other end in your ear (OK, near your ear).
This is a poor man's stethoscope.

Don't stick the broom handle in the fan!

Is the noise coming from the top end (valves) the front of the engine, the back? From what I can tell, knock usually comes from bad rod
end bearings, which you can fix by dropping the pan and perhaps
removing the head. But, since the engine is still running, do
some checks now.

I have a tap in my engine that I thought was rod knock until I
figured out that it goes away when I push the clutch in. So,
it's a clutch knock, not a rod knock.

The other way to tell which piston is knocking is by pulling the
spark plug for that cylinder. If the knock is distinct enough, it
might cease knocking when you de-activate that plug wire.
If you could isolate it to a given cylinder #, then you could
pull the head and the oil pan, knock the cylinder and rod
out of the block, and find out what the problem is.

A lot of work, no doubt, but a new engine is $$$.
 
Just after a de smog and "tune" up, if it knocks mostly under load, like accellerating up hills, and sounds like someone threw a handfull of marbles into the engine, it may be "PING" or pre ignition. This is usually from 1) too much timing advance (did they set the timing correctly?), 2) poor or low octane fuel, or 3) too much compression, either from shaving the head too much or using domed pistons during a rebuild or from carbon build up on the walls of the combustion chamber. Check the timing. Easy. To see if it is pre ignition, PING, or detonation (interchangable), go get some race gas at a hot rod shop, like 112 octane, which is around 6.50 a gallon right now. Either 100 percent or 50/50 mix, and see if that cures it. If it does, it is pre ignition. If timing correct, it is due to to much compression. After a questionable rebuild, I have 185 to 190 PSI; knocks like a motha. I run 1/4 race gas mixed with premium unleaded and it never knocks, runs like a raped ape, I tell everyone I "bumped the compression" like I know what I'm talking about and have one of the fastest 2f s anywhere. Also, if you have a vac advance dizzy (with the diaphragm/bell on the bezel side), you can unplug that advance and golf tee it/cap both holes, resulting in less TOTAL advance, and see if the "knock" stops. I am working on the assumption that your "knock" is PING or pre ignition. I hope it is not a rod knock. A valve is a "tick" from up top; sounds like a loud sewing machine. PING is like marbles. A rod knock I have never heard. A bad main bearing sounds and feels like a sledge hammer is hitting the bottom end of the motor. A nag is a whining sound, very annoying, intermittent but increasingly more common, usually from a female like a mother in law or girlfriend. This usually requires immediate trade in to cure.
 
DocB said:
Just after a de smog and "tune" up, if it knocks mostly under load, like accellerating up hills, and sounds like someone threw a handfull of marbles into the engine, it may be "PING" or pre ignition. This is usually from 1) too much timing advance (did they set the timing correctly?), 2) poor or low octane fuel, or 3) too much compression, either from shaving the head too much or using domed pistons during a rebuild or from carbon build up on the walls of the combustion chamber. Check the timing. Easy. To see if it is pre ignition, PING, or detonation (interchangable), go get some race gas at a hot rod shop, like 112 octane, which is around 6.50 a gallon right now. Either 100 percent or 50/50 mix, and see if that cures it. If it does, it is pre ignition. If timing correct, it is due to to much compression. After a questionable rebuild, I have 185 to 190 PSI; knocks like a motha. I run 1/4 race gas mixed with premium unleaded and it never knocks, runs like a raped ape, I tell everyone I "bumped the compression" like I know what I'm talking about and have one of the fastest 2f s anywhere. Also, if you have a vac advance dizzy (with the diaphragm/bell on the bezel side), you can unplug that advance and golf tee it/cap both holes, resulting in less TOTAL advance, and see if the "knock" stops. I am working on the assumption that your "knock" is PING or pre ignition. I hope it is not a rod knock. A valve is a "tick" from up top; sounds like a loud sewing machine. PING is like marbles. A rod knock I have never heard. A bad main bearing sounds and feels like a sledge hammer is hitting the bottom end of the motor. A nag is a whining sound, very annoying, intermittent but increasingly more common, usually from a female like a mother in law or girlfriend. This usually requires immediate trade in to cure.

I believe the timing was set correctly, the guy knows his cruisers very well. He did say it was way up and he corrected it. It does have high comp. on I think 1 and 5, like 170(I have this on his paper work in the 40). I am pretty sure I do not have vac advance. I'm pretty sure it is a rod knock, sounds like its coming from down low. When it started I thought it was some of the parts on the floorboard rattling against each other. Thanks so much for your input. I'll try some supergas.
 
The 74 I sold to a guy did the same thing. He said it just lost power and he pulled over. After pulling the pan ha found the the #2 Rod bearing had spun. He installed a new set of rod bearings (against my advice) and ran it a few more months. Did the same thing and he had to buy a crank. Have the carnk turned and install the appropriate bearings and you should be good. (if that's what it is).

later,
 
It always happens like this...

My dad came to town this weekend to give a listen. It started up right away (4 times) and never knocked. I guess, I'm going to drop the pan and give a look for chunks. I have a new oil pump that cam with my 40 so I'm gonna go ahead and put that in and see if it helps.
 
phishtaco said:
It always happens like this...

My dad came to town this weekend to give a listen. It started up right away (4 times) and never knocked. I guess, I'm going to drop the pan and give a look for chunks. I have a new oil pump that cam with my 40 so I'm gonna go ahead and put that in and see if it helps.


Rod knocks don't just come and go, so it is probably not a rod knock. They make more noise revving up and down and they get quiet when you pull the spark plug wire over the piston with a bad bearing. A new oil pump isn't going to help a bad bearing or anything else that might knock. Save your time and put your effort into finding out where the noise is coming from.
 
Pin_Head said:
Rod knocks don't just come and go, so it is probably not a rod knock. They make more noise revving up and down and they get quiet when you pull the spark plug wire over the piston with a bad bearing. A new oil pump isn't going to help a bad bearing or anything else that might knock. Save your time and put your effort into finding out where the noise is coming from.


But, its not knocking to find the noise. Maybe I should let it run for awhile longer and get it heated up more.
 
phishtaco; I had a very similar experience recently. I had my distributor worked on and right after my 2F started knocking. Like with me, it seems too coincidental that you developed a knock right after a tune up. In my case, I went to Napa and got a mechanic's stethescope for $16, and listened to my engine. It didn't sound like a bad rod bearing that I feared I had. My truck also quit knocking one day and then knocked again the next. It was kind of eerie. I finally figured out that the guy that worked on the distributor had crossed 2 of the plug wires. Try taking off your plug wires one at a time and see if the engine runs noticeably worse. If it doesn't you'll isolate which cylinder is not firing, if that's what's happening. Also, on my truck the timing was off. I got that adjusted, and the truck now runs better than it ever has. Nothing obviously lasts forever, but I think given the TLC that most of us give our trucks, it's be pretty hard to throw a rod. (at least I hope so)
 
Last edited:
paulj said:
phishtaco; I had a very similar experience recently. I had my distributor worked on and right after my 2F started knocking. Like with me, it seems too coincidental that you developed a knock right after a tune up. In my case, I went to Napa and got a mechanic's stethescope for $16, and listened to my engine. It didn't sound like a bad rod bearing that I feared I had. My truck also quit knocking one day and then knocked again the next. It was kind of eerie. I finally figured out that the guy that worked on the distributor had crossed 2 of the plug wires. Try taking off your plug wires one at a time and see if the engine runs noticeably worse. If it doesn't you'll isolate which cylinder is not firing, if that's what's happening. Also, on my truck the timing was off. I got that adjusted, and the truck now runs better than it ever has. Nothing obviously lasts forever, but I think given the TLC that most of us give our trucks, it's be pretty hard to throw a rod. (at least I hope so)


I'll have to try that out. I really don't think the guy that worked on my 40 would have screwed something up like that. He knows his stuff, maybe he'll see this and reply.
 
Back
Top Bottom