Is this oil behaviour is normal ?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 27, 2018
Threads
6
Messages
67
Location
Lahore
The engine (1HD) become slightly smoky and started reducing bit of an engine oil too.
So I shifted to 20w-50

Now I am observing that at cold start the oil pressure needle stays high (near H).

When engine warms up (after driving couple of KM), then needle comes down at lower level.

When driving at high speed, the needle stays slightly above than middle.

Here are the pictures.

Earlier I was using 5w-30 and needle was staying at lower point most of the times even driving at high speeds.


IMG_4038.webp
IMG_4040.webp

IMG_4041.webp
IMG_4042.webp
IMG_4043.webp
 
With multi-viscosity oils such as 5W-30 and 20W-50, the first number (5W and 20W) indicate the apparent viscosity when the oil is cold. The second number (30 and 50) are the apparent viscosity when the oil is at operating temperature.

Motor Oil Viscosity Grades Explained in Layman's Terms

All other things remaining equal (1) Higher oil viscosity should result in higher oil pressure. (2) Lower oil viscosity should result in higher oil consumption

Seems to me what you describe is to be expected.

Your owners manual should have a chart with recommended oil viscosity based on the environmental air temperature for your location.
 
I agree with above.

20w50 is not normally used in that engine.

My 1HD-T would sit at aroyund 1/3 - 1/2 on the gauge most of the time.

I'd try 15w40, or maybe 10w30.
If you're in a hot environment (Lahore) I wouldn't use 5w oil, and 10w may be too light to as it will by warm just from the ambient air temp
 
I agree with above.

20w50 is not normally used in that engine.

My 1HD-T would sit at aroyund 1/3 - 1/2 on the gauge most of the time.

I'd try 15w40, or maybe 10w30.
If you're in a hot environment (Lahore) I wouldn't use 5w oil, and 10w may be too light to as it will by warm just from the ambient air temp

Just checked the climate in Lahore:

Month..........Ave. Low.......Ave. High
January...........43°F............67°F
June...............81°F...........105°F

5W30 seems much to thin in that climate, especially for a diesel. Without knowing Toyota's recommendation I'd use 15W40.
 
Just checked the climate in Lahore:

Month..........Ave. Low.......Ave. High
January...........43°F............67°F
June...............81°F...........105°F

5W30 seems much to thin in that climate, especially for a diesel. Without knowing Toyota's recommendation I'd use 15W40.

As I said the engine become smoky and started reducing engine oil and its clear indication that engine is going weak.

That’s why I chose to shift on high viscose oil. I read the oil broacher and they said it is specially designed for the weaker & worn-out engines. Its one of the properties of oil to stay in the minor gaps of rings which helps reducing smoke and hence adding some life to engine.


On the other side its also true that using 20w-50 in winter is also not good for oil pump as it as to work harder to pump the oil at cold start unless the engine is warmed up. But I have to give this oil a try at-least, as 20w is still good to use as min. temperature here during winter is 35F (during night & morning) and 60F during day.
 
Why would you run 5w30 in you diesel ??? , you need to run a 15w40 ...........................................
 
Well, my ex-vehicle was Gasoline and I was using this 5W-30 throughout the year. Believe me this is best grade to use all year round.

I usually buy bigger packings (20L mostly) and hence was having around 12L oil in my stock.

I bought this Cruiser a few week ago and hence used this oil from my stock.

I was using Total Quartz 9000, 5w-30 which is SN/CH Grade (SN is for Gasoline engines and CH is for Diesel).

Hence its safe to use it for Diesel engines.

But when I was using this 5w-30, then oil pressure needle was mostly staying at lower side or maximum in the middle only.
 
The chart above is from the Toyota FSM for 1HD-T engine.
According to Toyota, you should be using 10w30, or 20w40, and up to 20w50 in summer.
Never use 5w30 above 0°C.

Well if you look closely then 20w-50 oil is suitable till -10 Degree C.

I am using Mitasu oil 20w-50 for my JDM and as per its specs its pour point is -21C

Hence its totally OK to use this oil in this weather because weather is staying 10-20’C these days.

Coming back to question, does anyone else also experience such needle movement at Cold Start, warmed up idles & at High Speeds ?
 
Oil pressure on startup should be above the 1/3 mark - anything higher is good. At idle my very old 1hz almost always drops below the 1/3 mark but once I start driving, it rises and I get about 2/3 on the gauge at above 2000 rpm. It's a very old motor though having done 670+ k km's, so it's going to have a lot more wear. No turbo either.

As the motor warms up the oil heats up so it'll flow better and pressures will be less. Just a natural thing with the effects of viscosity with temperature.
 
Try posting this question in the diesel tech section, and add a link to this thread.

You'll get more responses.

From the chart above, I would say Toyota is not recommending 20w50 until ambient temperatures are above 20°C.

Apart from the high pressure at start up, I don't think there's anything unusual with the pressures you have pictured.

The high oil pressure on start up is because the cold 20w50 is not as liquid as when it's warmed up, it's harder to pump though small galleries, so pressure goes up.
If it's too thick, the risk is it won't get through all the small oil galleries well enough to lube all your bearings on start up. Start up is when oil is most critical, it's when a lot of bearing wear occurs.

Opposite is true with the 5w30 when it's too warm.
It will flow easily through all the galleries, so you see low pressure, and is easily lost from the bearing surfaces as it's not thick enough to stay where it's needed.
Things like crank, cam, conrods "float" no a film of oil, if the oil is too thin, you won't have enough oil film thickness to keep metal crank and metal bearings separated. Too light an oil will also get past the piston rings more easily and be burnt during combustion.
 
Oil pressure on startup should be above the 1/3 mark - anything higher is good. At idle my very old 1hz almost always drops below the 1/3 mark but once I start driving, it rises and I get about 2/3 on the gauge at above 2000 rpm. It's a very old motor though having done 670+ k km's, so it's going to have a lot more wear. No turbo either.

As the motor warms up the oil heats up so it'll flow better and pressures will be less. Just a natural thing with the effects of viscosity with temperature.

So generally it seems that oil pressure behavior is quite normal in my case as per posted pictures.

Well, only at the cold start the needle stays close to H because oil is thick & cold. But once its warms up then needle shifts down to 1/3 position.

And when driving, the needle stays in between 1/3 & 2/3 marks.
 
Back
Top Bottom