HID for off road only - cheap & quick version

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jul 11, 2008
Threads
63
Messages
321
Location
London, UK & Lusaka, Zambia
Was thinking about this after reading the HID thread (great result, too much work/time/money for me)

IN Zambia, I only really want extra light when on dust road / tracks. ON tarmac, things are OK, so...

ON a stock cruiser, the outer lights are dual filament, high/low beam, the inners are single, high only.

So why don;t I just stick some HIDs in the inners ?
Isolate them from the regular high beam with a momentary contact switch and a self latching relay (fed from the high beam inner signal), feeding a main relay to power the HIDs.

Thus, then pressing the momentary switch (and only when hi beam was on), HIDs come on. When Hi beam gets turned off, the latch breaks, and back to regular high beam on the outers only. Thus you still have a usable (albeit degraded) high beam for flashing people, and in town driving.

Using the self latching relay/momentary swtich instead of a toggle switch means it can't be accidentaly left on, thus the HIDs flashing away when they obviously shouldn't be..

Whatdya reckon ?

Pros
Cheap
Quick
Good off road
Stock

Cons
No improvement on "on road" situations
some degredation of high beam "on road"
Not a wonderfulyl nice cut off when used off road (but I don;t think I care)

Cheers - JB
 
you've got the square headlights, right?

should work, and seems like a good idea if the onroad hibeam isn't important
 
Here is why that is a waste of time. Your inner lights use an H1 bulb. The standard 55 watt H1 bulb puts out 1500 lumens. Step up to a 100 watt H1, and you are at 2500 lumens, a 130 bulb 3000 lumens. This assumes you have glass housings and lenses (so you don't melt them) and upgrade the wiring harness to support the current. The cost of doing this is the cost of bulbs ($4.00 each) and the relays and wire to upgrade the harness (about $25).

HID's put out about 3000 lumens, but won't work nearly as well as the above for two reasons.

1) They will have the wrong focal point and focal length for your housing, resulting in poor defuse lighting. Lots of light, but no control over where it is going.

2) HID's have a lower color rendering index than incandescent lamps (70's vs. high 90s) and accordingly you need a brighter HID to see the amount as an equivalent lumen incandescent.


If you need lots more light out of the front, the best way to do it is to strap on a set of auxilary lights with big lenses (ALA Hella 3000 & 4000). Bigger housing and lamps = more efficiency and more light out the front.
 
Cheers both...

Cary, interesting that, esp ref the colour rendering... even more intersting was that was my plan A - before I read the HID thread !

Was looking at sticking in 100 W bulbs, and getting some +50% dual filamet replacements for the regular "outers"

Would still go with the additional relay/switch, but just a toggle (i.e. no momentary/self latch relay), as no real downside to having the inners flashing on if they are halogen.

I guess the only downside of 100W bulbs is the power / heat - but as I'd want to uprate the wiring anyways (to give me the control switch), no big deal.... everything is glass/metal, so shouldn't melt !

In Zambia great big spotlights on the front work well for a while, then tend to self destruct with all the vibration - a single bolt at the bottom just isn't enough for the hammering they get on hard baked, courugated dirt tracks. Had a set on my isuzu, lasted for years in the UK no problems, both dead within 3 months of arriving in zambia (casings cracked, internals rattled to bits). If I could find some with with 2 or 3 mounting points, it would be fine...

Thanks - JB
 
Cary, you really puzzled me with the lower CRI (color rendering index). Whenever I look, Metal-Halide bulbs have a very high CRI (im projectors, stage lights, photography, etc.). You know that I will check that :-)

Currently many factories produce rebased HID lamps for H1, H3, H7 and even H4 applications. So the focus point is more or less where it should be.

I would really tend towards the HIDs. Sets of 2X(ballast, bulb) cost around $50 so I would take the risk.

Oh and (at least in my case) the stock harness works perfectly with HIDs. After one year (lights turned on also during the day) there are no problems with the wires and relays. No melting, discoloration or overheating. So now I am absolutely sure that it's not mandatory.
 
Just been reading the Daniel Stern site:
Daniel Stern Lighting Consultancy and Supply

And I'm more convinced now, back to plan A.... plus 50% H4s in the outers, and for Zambia 100W H1 highs in the centre (plus 50% H1s for the UKk cars)

The 100W H1s are as bright as the HIDs, with better colour (will do an uprated harness for the H1, leave the H4 wiring as is)

Cheap and simple :) :)
 
I just run 4 H4 100/90 on my 80 with 6 relays and complete new wiring ... definately better light ..

Also run 2 bosh and 2 hella, seems to be better pathern on the hella headlamps ..

main.php


just lots of fun in those cable mess ..

main.php
 
Cary, you really puzzled me with the lower CRI (color rendering index). Whenever I look, Metal-Halide bulbs have a very high CRI (im projectors, stage lights, photography, etc.). You know that I will check that :-)

Currently many factories produce rebased HID lamps for H1, H3, H7 and even H4 applications. So the focus point is more or less where it should be.

Oh and (at least in my case) the stock harness works perfectly with HIDs. After one year (lights turned on also during the day) there are no problems with the wires and relays. No melting, discoloration or overheating. So now I am absolutely sure that it's not mandatory.

The CRI is better with large lamps and I believe HID's have been getting better over the years, but the numbers I saw for the automotive lamps put them in the 70's range.

Even though kits rebase the lamps for H1, H3, etc., the length of the HID capsule is so long that they cannot rebase it to set in the proper place. Similarly, this length of the arc is different than the incadecent filament, leading to focal problems. When dropping an HID conversion in a projector lamp, it is not as much of an issue (sharp cutoff is retained), but is it is a huge problem when doing it into a lens/reflector assembly that was not designed for it.

You are correct that the stock harness is more than adequate for an HID setup, as they draw only 35 watts when on, a bit more for startup.
 
I just run 4 H4 100/90 on my 80 with 6 relays and complete new wiring ... definately better light ..

Also run 2 bosh and 2 hella, seems to be better pathern on the hella headlamps ..

main.php


just lots of fun in those cable mess ..

main.php

Are you running H4 bulb in both inner and outer.? This would give you 4 lights on either high or low then. With the 4 lights on low beam do you notice much of an inprovement over the original setup. At present I have sealed beam units in mine and I think I would get better light from 2 Dolphin torches strapped to the Bull bar.
 
SO I've done a little reading and found (among lots of others) this article...Daniel Stern Lighting Consultancy and Supply

First of all it was written in 2003 and I also find it a little bit biased or not fully explanatory. All the HID disadvantages he mentions do exist but only in poor designs.

1. Low CRI. Well, HIDs have indeed a low CRI (of around 75-80) but what is this? A low color rendering index affects vision really very slightly because it doesn't make colors disappear but only can change their hue a little bit. Imagine that a typical fluorescent tube has a CRI of 50 and we still distinguish colors perfectly. There might be some differences in colors but a photographer and a scientist will see them, not the typical person. The yellow lights, which were so popular 40 years ago in France could have a CRI of 20 and he still says that they were good. Really odd.

2. Another thing he mentions is problem with too much light in front of the vehicle which causes too much contrast and doesn't let us see objects which are distant and poorly lit. Well, this problem depends on the design of the lamp and is not the fault of HID technology. If you put HIDs in a H4 lamp you will be in big trouble, if you put HID in a H1, H3, H7 lamp you will have less trouble, if you put HID in a H1, H3, H7 in a free form lamp (the one with clear glass) you will have even less problems, and if you put it in a HID specific lamp everything is going to be absolutely OK. It's a fact that more light is always better, especially off road. Otherwise rally racers would be using dim lights and not power plants in front of their cars.

3. The author speaks of the worst case scenario, when a person buys very blue (above 6000K) HIDs and makes a flimsy install. This is in general a very good remark and warning, but for our specific case a 4000K HID in a H1 lamp for off-road use would be ideal.

Remember that the native color temperature od automotive HIDs is around 4000K and if we buy such bulbs we will get the best luminosity and best CRI. The bluer you go the worse for your eyes and safety.

JLBUK, in your case you have the following advantages.

1. Low power consumption (35W vs 55W or even more). This means less strain on your alternator, battery and slightly lower fuel consumption.
2. Vibration resistance. HIDs do not have a filament so road vibrations do not affect them. A very good solution for off-road.
3. Lots of light. This is an obvious point.
4. Good performance in a H1 housing and in the type of beam you have. If you install HIDs as your low-beams you need a good cutoff line in order not to blind oncoming traffic, but if you plan to use HIDs in additional lights then what you want is light far in front of you and all over the place and not only in the lower half of what you see. So for this application you have large tolerances for HID bulbs and I'm sure they will work very well.
 
Last edited:
I don't much care for Daniel Stern. I bought the Depo headlamps (H1 H4 combo) from eBay and went to him for consultation on wiring and bulb options. I was willing to buy a harness and bulbs from him to upgrade my stock harness. I sent him the specs on my current setup and the lamps that I bought. He told me that the lamps I bought were cheap and crappy Chinese garbage (not his exact words but nearly) and that they had a very poor design. I asked for recommendations and why the lights I bought were poorly designed and he never wrote me back. I wrote him again asking for harness advice and prices and he never replied. I understand that he may be a busy man but that is just poor manners and poor customer service. I went to him because I heard good things on Mud. Now I am not certain that he even knows what he is talking about, especially regarding new HID technology. ::rant off::
 
Are you running H4 bulb in both inner and outer.? This would give you 4 lights on either high or low then. With the 4 lights on low beam do you notice much of an inprovement over the original setup. At present I have sealed beam units in mine and I think I would get better light from 2 Dolphin torches strapped to the Bull bar.

Yes H4 inner and outer .. 4 light low or hi beam .. and I'm keep the low activate with I go hi beam too ..

Improvement .. from the ground to the heaven ..

Low

main.php


hi

main.php



low

main.php


hi

main.php
 
I just installed a set of big HID lamps tonight, great light and pretty easy install.

I have a question for anyone that has wired aux lights using the high beam circuit as a signal for the aux relay; why do the aux lights work on low and high beam? I have done this circuit before and tapped into the high beam, to my relay, to my switch so that when I pull the stock high beams in for low it breaks the circuit to the relay, killing the aux beams. tonights install does not work the same way. am I missing something? :o
 
:mad: sorry, should have searched harder. I can hear the rumblings now...

quote:
Based on obscure physics, Toyota likes to switch circuits in the ground side of the circuit.
The C14 switch does indeed switch the hi-beam current. Finding a hot (+12v) lead from the Hi-beam switch may not be easy - lots of tape wrapped wire bundles. "Splice point" E2 may be the easiest, left front of cruiser near the head light assembly. Tap this point and bring back into the cab.

Connector "EA2" is near the fuse panel.

Ref: EWD189U, Pg 64.

Clear as mud, huh?

k0dar (end quote)

I just need to consult my FSM that I loaned out a couple weeks ago:whoops:
 
Back
Top Bottom