Help me pick the right battery

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Feb 7, 2013
Threads
207
Messages
1,774
I currently have a Walmart Maxx 24F battery that's only two years old but is getting beat down pretty fast by the stereo I just put in. (70wpc x 2 + 170watts x 1 sub) Less than an hour of engine off moderate volume listening time knocks the fully charged battery down from 12.7V to 12.1V. So I'm looking into getting a battery with more capacity instead of going the dual battery route since I will be using the stereo a lot more than this come summer.

I'm looking at Odyssey brand batteries and can use some advice picking one that will have enough capacity and fit without any cable mods. Should I be looking at a group 31? 35? 34?

I'd like to keep the cost under $300. Preferably $260.
 
A stereo shouldn't be beating down your battery. The first thing I would do is have them check it, you'll prolly end up with a new one under warranty.
 
A stereo shouldn't be beating down your battery. The first thing I would do is have them check it, you'll prolly end up with a new one under warranty.



I'm going to do that at some point and then, new battery or not, use it as the starter battery in a dual battery system. I'm just not ready to do that yet (maybe in the summer) so I figured I'd get the "house" battery now and use it as a starter until I'm ready to go dual.
 
I'm going to do that at some point and then, new battery or not, use it as the starter battery in a dual battery system. I'm just not ready to do that yet (maybe in the summer) so I figured I'd get the "house" battery now and use it as a starter until I'm ready to go dual.

I would hazard a guess that failure is imminent, battery warranties are time sensitive, I wouldn't dally. In my experience, Walmart is good about honoring their warranties.
 
I have had very good luck with Costco Starting and deep cycle marine batteries. I had two in the truck for almost 7 years and was very happy with them. I just recently replaced them with new ones because at 7 years I figured their days were numbered. At 85ish dollars I think they are a bargain.
 
The battery was doing this all last summer. I'd run the STOCK stereo or a boom box off the inverter (stock CD player didn't work) and I'd watch the voltage drop for a couple hours, then when it got down near 12v I'd run the engine for a bit to recharge the battery. The battery was purchased by the PO and is dated 10/12. It does hold a charge though. I can charge it and start the truck a week or two later with no problem. But by then it'll be down to about 12v with no accessory usage.

The truck is just sitting now until April when I'll start hitting the beaches and back bays again, and I just want to be able to trust that it'll start after a long day of tunes and/or a long night of aux and interior lights.





.
 
... I just want to be able to trust that it'll start after a long day of tunes and/or a long night of aux and interior lights.

All day music with subs, amps, and power inverters cannot be sustained by any regular ole car battery no matter how top-self!

Among other things, I'd shut off my sub amp, cuz really you're not going to be able to feel the bass in an open-air environment. My old car had a dedicated sub amp and used the radio for to power the doors/rear deck. So if I was going to play the radio for extended periods I'd just kill the sub by tripping the under-hood circuit breaker and it sounded fine sans sub.

Or just get a jump box...b/c there's no way you'll be able to play tunes all day and then start the car. This isn't some old school Die Hard commercial where you come out to your car after having parked it on a lake for a few months and it starts right up...just not happening.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Nlrqqf8TsM
 
costco, costco, costco, available everywhere and are good batteries. Great return and warranty policy. I personally think that the differences in batteries are really overstated and just marketing related. Optimas are junk.

Agree. IIRC, Costco and Walmart batteries are both made by Johnson Controls. Same thing, different labels. Good, inexpensive batteries and both places support their product.
 
sucked in

costco, costco, costco, available everywhere and are good batteries. Great return and warranty policy. I personally think that the differences in batteries are really overstated and just marketing related. Optimas are junk.


I 2nd that! I got sucked into buying Optimas for my 80, F350 diesel and was a waste. Swapped one out, same thing. Holding a charge issues with all 4 and 2 were yellow top and one red. Gave up and now use Autozone Durlast gold in both vehicles and have not had an issues in over 4 yrs. I put Sams club in my boat (3) and all good there too.
 
I had 2 Interstate 27F died on me within couple months. One of the cells no longer charges probably because I have drained them quite a few times.

Sent from my iPad using IH8MUD
 
Nothing but great experience with my DieHard Platinums and I have the alt mod and plenty of extra wiring/electronics.
 
Nobody thought to recommend a sequoia alternator?

. :Sent by pneumatic tubes
 
I think this OP stereo usage kinda screams for a dual batt set-up with a deep cycle batt in the house (2nd) batt role. The suggestion for bringing along a backup starting (jump) batt is a good one if the OP will end up waiting on the dual batt installation for a while. As I think someone noted, a typical starting batt would likely get damaged by being run down with repeated/extended draw-down with the engine off, so maybe the next purchase should be a deep cycle batt (in the starting position for now as a compromise) if that one will be used to run the stereo in the interim period.
 
I mentioned "alt mod". Can't we just all assume there is only one acceptable one? :flipoff2:

ahh missed it.

carry on!

I also agree on the dual battery setup.

Have wallyborg warranty out the existing starter battery, add a big AGM for a house battery.

And a sequoia alternator. you can still get the bracket and pulley from photoman.
 
Back
Top Bottom