Heater Fan Fun

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 4, 2008
Threads
178
Messages
2,014
Location
Federal Way, WA
I think a lot of people would agree with me that the output of the factory heater fan is a bit anemic. It wasn't bad when I had the hard top on, but with the soft top and driving at highway speeds it's a bit cold inside. Then try defrosting the windshield. Good luck.

I decided to see what I could do.

First modification was to install a Ford Escort fan in the factory housing. It took some cutting and mods to make it fit, but the output is slightly better. This is documented in other peoples posts if you want to look it up.

Still unhappy I decided to play around a little. I picked up a 4" marine bilge blower fan and a humongous squirrel cage fan from a swap meet. Next up was to get an anemometer so I could get real numbers and not trust my hand to feel the difference.

Large fan (it's 17" wide):

1928885



First up was to measure the individual fan outputs using the anemometer. The bilge blower and in-car fan were easy as they had ducts I could measure the airflow and area of. For the big fan I created a cardboard duct to measure velocity and area. Getting the cfm is a matter of measuring the airflow in feet per minute and then measuring the duct area in square feet. CFM is fpm times area in square feet. I grabbed my teenager for a little real world math problems. Now he can't say he will never use the math taught in school :).

Current Escort fan: 71 cfm
Bilge fan: 178 cfm
Large fan Low: 438 cfm
medium: 595 cfm
high: 673 cfm

I have serious doubts that I could use the large fan even at low speed. At low speed that is over 6 times more air flow than the escort fan. At 178 cfm the bilge fan, on the other hand, might work.

I temporarily mounted the bilge fan for testing. It's loud, but only temporary. I plugged into the factory harness so I can have two speeds and use the factory switch. The airflow is noticeably better.

1928888


I will run it this way for a few wheeling trips to see how this much airflow works out. My initial gut feeling is that 300cfm in high speed would be about perfect. I'll keep my eyes out for a smaller dual fan that doesn't cost too much then fab up a new duct out of aluminum.
 
I did some research on the big fan. It's off a backhoe.

Anyway, I got to drive around for a while. The blower I am testing is too strong. It burns my leg after about 5 minutes. Running it in low speed seemed it could be about right for a normal high speed setting. Back to the drawing board. Looking for a fan of around 100 cfm. Found a couple options I am looking deeper at.
 
There must be a lot of corrosion in the factory wiring for the fan. That is one section I didn't replace. Wiring directly to the battery increased the output by about 12 CFM. I decided to order another fan, Spal 30003161, for testing along with a variable speed DC fan controller to replace the factory switch.
 
Good idea about using your son to do the math!

Corrosion in the old wire is a small part of the issue, but for that circuit, Toyota used too small a wire gauge in my opinion.
The OEM wire gauge for the heater and wipers is 18ga. I always use 16ga for these two circuits when building new harnesses. It really helps reduce the voltage drop to the two motors increasing their effectiveness.

Instead of continuing to look for the perfect motor, why not just block off or divert the drivers side "leg vent" to prevent burning your leg, then see if you stay warm. That bilge fan should easily heat an FJ40 and then some!
 
Hey there Coolerman!

I do like the 16ga idea. I read that myself. I had briefly thought of blocking that vent while I was driving. The noise of the fan made me forget it :). Actually I have two ideas I want to pursue. The first will be to incorporate the variable fan controller with the existing front fan with all new wiring (16ga of course) and see how that helps. It might just breathe enough life into the existing system. If that fails then I will work on adding the new fan.

An aside on wire gauge. I was testing my big fan using jumper wires to the battery. I am guessing 18 ga. As a quick on-off test they were fine, but not for the three or four minutes I had them hooked up. They melted.

I have an ulterior motive for removing the factory fan. I run FI with an electric fuel pump underneath and behind the fuel tank. It is quite loud. I have been thinking of adding a surge tank that includes an in-tank pump. The only place to put it would be on the firewall where the heater fan housing is now. If I were to find an internal fan that worked then I could delete the existing fan housing and make room for an eventual surge tank.



Good idea about using your son to do the math!

Corrosion in the old wire is a small part of the issue, but for that circuit, Toyota used too small a wire gauge in my opinion.
The OEM wire gauge for the heater and wipers is 18ga. I always use 16ga for these two circuits when building new harnesses. It really helps reduce the voltage drop to the two motors increasing their effectiveness.

Instead of continuing to look for the perfect motor, why not just block off or divert the drivers side "leg vent" to prevent burning your leg, then see if you stay warm. That bilge fan should easily heat an FJ40 and then some!
 
Lots of progress to report.

I purchased a new fan, Spal 30003161 from Amazon ($70). (tested the air flow at about 120 cfm)

https://amazon.com/gp/product/B01HQHR6C4/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o06_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I also purchased a variable DC fan controller ($12).
https://amazon.com/gp/product/B07CWT71W9/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o07_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

The picture of the fan when I purchased it showed it to be a 2 wire so I went with the variable controller. The picture now shows the 4 wire unit I received which has a resistor pack for three speeds. If I had knows this before I ordered I would have purchased a three speed switch from Summit. Oh well.

I installed the fan switch in the original dash hole and wired it nicely with all new wire. This made a small difference in the factory fan output, but I already ordered the new fan so I decided to continue down that path. I found that the new fan was a perfect size to sandwich into the space outboard of the glove box. It barely fits, but does. I fabbed some L able brackets from 1/8" aluminum bar stock, drilled and tapped for screws to attach them to the fan. I cut a rectangle out of thick sheet metal stock and cut a section from the middle to match the outlet of the fan. I drilled holes to match those on the fan. Then I used some aluminum sheet and built a duct with 2" x 4" opening at the fan side and 3 1/2" by 4 1/2" at the heater box side. I slipped it through the rectangle I made and bent the edges over. This way the duct lip was sandwiched in place when I screwed it to the fan. Sorry, no pictures of that part. I was using this thin aluminum as a proof of concept and may make it again out of steel sheet. We'll see. The other end goes into the factory rubber sleeve just like the original duct does.

The fan puts out a perfect amount of air. Not so much it burns my leg, but way more than the stock fan/housing did. It is fairly quiet too.

I think I will stick with this for a while. If I could re-do the brackets I would drop the fan about 1/4". I just plugged the spade connectors into the existing fan plug. I will leave it this way until I decide to keep it or not. If I keep it I will re-wire with weatherpak plugs.

1947633



1947634
 
Lots of progress to report.

I purchased a new fan, Spal 30003161 from Amazon ($70). (tested the air flow at about 120 cfm)

https://amazon.com/gp/product/B01HQHR6C4/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o06_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I also purchased a variable DC fan controller ($12).
https://amazon.com/gp/product/B07CWT71W9/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o07_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

The picture of the fan when I purchased it showed it to be a 2 wire so I went with the variable controller. The picture now shows the 4 wire unit I received which has a resistor pack for three speeds. If I had knows this before I ordered I would have purchased a three speed switch from Summit. Oh well.

I installed the fan switch in the original dash hole and wired it nicely with all new wire. This made a small difference in the factory fan output, but I already ordered the new fan so I decided to continue down that path. I found that the new fan was a perfect size to sandwich into the space outboard of the glove box. It barely fits, but does. I fabbed some L able brackets from 1/8" aluminum bar stock, drilled and tapped for screws to attach them to the fan. I cut a rectangle out of thick sheet metal stock and cut a section from the middle to match the outlet of the fan. I drilled holes to match those on the fan. Then I used some aluminum sheet and built a duct with 2" x 4" opening at the fan side and 3 1/2" by 4 1/2" at the heater box side. I slipped it through the rectangle I made and bent the edges over. This way the duct lip was sandwiched in place when I screwed it to the fan. Sorry, no pictures of that part. I was using this thin aluminum as a proof of concept and may make it again out of steel sheet. We'll see. The other end goes into the factory rubber sleeve just like the original duct does.

The fan puts out a perfect amount of air. Not so much it burns my leg, but way more than the stock fan/housing did. It is fairly quiet too.

I think I will stick with this for a while. If I could re-do the brackets I would drop the fan about 1/4". I just plugged the spade connectors into the existing fan plug. I will leave it this way until I decide to keep it or not. If I keep it I will re-wire with weatherpak plugs.

View attachment 1947633


View attachment 1947634

How is the noise level from the Spal fan? I’m looking to replace fresh and exhaust fans similar to your first white one. The current fans can be heard outside from 30’ away... and prevent conversations inside.
 
The spal fan is pretty quiet. Maybe a tiny bit louder than the stock fan just because of it's location, but I can not really tell the difference.

How is the noise level from the Spal fan? I’m looking to replace fresh and exhaust fans similar to your first white one. The current fans can be heard outside from 30’ away... and prevent conversations inside.
 
Back
Top Bottom