Front Diff gear wear question

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Not that I know for sure, but...

Based on the several thousand drive axles I built at Dana, you need a new gearset. Yes, the wear is on the coast side, but the tooth strength calculation is based on the whole tooth thickness (albeit at the root, but in practice the whole tooth gets used) and your teeth aren't full thickness. The reason you haven't heard anything is that the wear isn't on the drive side (or you would have heard it sing). My guess is that during setup, someone royally screwed up, and put it in anyway, knowing a) you wouldn't see it and b) you wouldn't hear it, until a tooth broke under extreme load. Then, during failure analysis, someone well meaning someone would suspect, and claim, that the tooth damage was due to the breakage and dismiss it entirely. Yes, I'm very cynical; I also spent a couple of years in root cause failure analysis, trying to prove the axles I built were actually good when they left my line.

That having been said, while it's apart have a new set installed and make sure, if you're not there, you get pictures of the gear contact print that's done to confirm the backlash before they bolt everything up. That's the only way you'll ever know that the gearset was installed properly.
How important is longitudinal crowning vs profile crowning in your typical dana axle?
 
On paper, or in the case?
 
Good advice, thanks!

East Coast Gear called me yesterday and said they feel i should replace the gear set. They actually suggested, since i'm not changing the ratio, to go back to a stock gear set. They have one on the shelf that appears to be in excellent shape, so i'm going to go that route.

They also pressure tested the ARB to 140 psi and said it held at 140 for 2 hours. So they said the ARB is not leaking and is in great shape.

I hope i made the right decision, but i'm going to keep the ARB and have a slightly used Toyota gear set put in.
 
In practice
Not at all. These were heavy use designs, intended for agricultural/industrial applications. Travel speed is extremely slow so the torque is high, but there isn't much intermittent loading. Once the load is applied, at high torque, the tooth tends to flatten out (measured in tenths, of course). The gear designers included a bit of cross sectional crowning (so they told me) to help fitting on the assembly line. The contact line doesn't (or more accurately, shouldn't) move once the backlash is set, so the tooth is essentially flat there. This assumes the theoretical point rolling contact, of course.
 
Good advice, thanks!

East Coast Gear called me yesterday and said they feel i should replace the gear set. They actually suggested, since i'm not changing the ratio, to go back to a stock gear set. They have one on the shelf that appears to be in excellent shape, so i'm going to go that route.

They also pressure tested the ARB to 140 psi and said it held at 140 for 2 hours. So they said the ARB is not leaking and is in great shape.

I hope i made the right decision, but i'm going to keep the ARB and have a slightly used Toyota gear set put in.


I think that's exactly the right move. But have the ARB O rings replaced while it's apart. Ask them for a solid pinion spacer (in lieu of a crush sleeve) too if you don't already have one.
 
I replaced the ARB o-ring before last years trip. The old one was leaking bad but this one seems to be doing just fine. He said not to mess with it. He is going to use a solid spacer and not a crush sleeve.
 
In practice
Apologies for hijacking the thread.
Am I right that you have a Dana 40 drive/steer axle? The axles I built were 70-90, but the gear designers I worked with were responsible for the 35 series and up, and we built everything from 40 on up, that wasn't ordered for the on highway market. The gear designers were constantly fiddling with the tooth parameters, using the argument that they were trying to "optimize" the design for this or that characteristic. The results, during my tenure (and I was told up to that time) were negligible differences in both load carrying capacity and longevity, regardless of the series. Seems that the old Dana designers back in the 60s knew what they were doing.
 
Good advice, thanks!

East Coast Gear called me yesterday and said they feel i should replace the gear set. They actually suggested, since i'm not changing the ratio, to go back to a stock gear set. They have one on the shelf that appears to be in excellent shape, so i'm going to go that route.

They also pressure tested the ARB to 140 psi and said it held at 140 for 2 hours. So they said the ARB is not leaking and is in great shape.

I hope i made the right decision, but i'm going to keep the ARB and have a slightly used Toyota gear set put in.


You still have the 4.11:1 gear ration R&P? I thought I read somewhere in this thread you had 4.88:1's..........
 
You still have the 4.11:1 gear ration R&P? I thought I read somewhere in this thread you had 4.88:1's..........

Not that it really matters, but an 80 series comes with 4.10 gearing. Pinion has 10 teeth and Ring has 41.

Traditional Land Cruisers had 4.111111..... gearing Pinion 9 teeth, Ring gear 37 teeth.
 
Not that it really matters, but an 80 series comes with 4.10 gearing. Pinion has 10 teeth and Ring has 41.

Traditional Land Cruisers had 4.111111..... gearing Pinion 9 teeth, Ring gear 37 teeth.


Sorry, I couldn't recall if it was 4.10 or 4.11. I just got done doing our son's 70 GMC K2500. His must be the 4.11 and my LC is the 4.10. I guess he'll out-pull me now with the .01:1 difference.........(sarcasm)

It's still close enough that MANY GM trucks use 4.09 on one diff and the other is 4.11 on the other on the SAME truck. Typically, the 4.09 is in the REAR and the 4.11 is in the FRONT, which I would think be ass-backwards, but doing the math with turning radius' and other things, it's still a moot point.
 
You still have the 4.11:1 gear ration R&P? I thought I read somewhere in this thread you had 4.88:1's..........

No 4.88's here. It was suggested, but i'm just not feeling it. I do have the T-case crawler gears for when i need that, but the supercharger with stock gearing is fine with me for highway cruising at 80MPH.
 
Sorry, I couldn't recall if it was 4.10 or 4.11. I just got done doing our son's 70 GMC K2500. His must be the 4.11 and my LC is the 4.10. I guess he'll out-pull me now with the .01:1 difference.........(sarcasm)

It's still close enough that MANY GM trucks use 4.09 on one diff and the other is 4.11 on the other on the SAME truck. Typically, the 4.09 is in the REAR and the 4.11 is in the FRONT, which I would think be ass-backwards, but doing the math with turning radius' and other things, it's still a moot point.

Yep and I've got a 4.10 set from an 80 in the rear of my FJ40 with 4.11 up front. :)
 
Apologies for hijacking the thread.
Am I right that you have a Dana 40 drive/steer axle? The axles I built were 70-90, but the gear designers I worked with were responsible for the 35 series and up, and we built everything from 40 on up, that wasn't ordered for the on highway market. The gear designers were constantly fiddling with the tooth parameters, using the argument that they were trying to "optimize" the design for this or that characteristic. The results, during my tenure (and I was told up to that time) were negligible differences in both load carrying capacity and longevity, regardless of the series. Seems that the old Dana designers back in the 60s knew what they were doing.
Dana 'super' 70 and dana 60 low pinion front. Just reading way more than I wanted to these days about hypoid optimizations. It seems pretty evident that im in over my head in understanding the engineering.
 
Don't feel bad; I think most of the gear designers are too. I saw way too much "what-if" designing when I was there.
 
Back
Top Bottom